- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The authors propose DeCoDy, a method for long-horizon traffic forecasting. They identify three challenges for long-horizon forecasting: (1) delayed interactions among nodes and their temporal accumulation, (2) changing dependencies across phases and days, and (3) the joint representation of long-term periodicity and local peak and trough variations. To address these challenges, the authors introduce a multi-delay interaction and accumulation module, a phase evolution and adaptive coupling module, and a global and local residual representation module. In experiments on four real-world datasets, DeCoDy outperforms the baseline methods.
Critical strengths
- S1: On the four datasets, the proposed method achieves lower RMSE and MAE than the baselines in most cases, which empirically demonstrates its effectiveness compared to the baselines.
Critical weaknesses
- W1: The authors raise three challenges for long-horizon forecasting, but the manuscript does not sufficiently explain why these challenges matter for long-horizon forecasting. This raises a fundamental question about the motivation of the work.
- W1-1: In Figure 1(a), the drops at nodes C and D precede the drop at the target (node B) by only about 10 minutes. Such delayed interactions are short-term, and their temporal accumulation is not actually observed either. Moreover, there is no intuitive explanation of how these interactions could be exploited for multi-day forecasting.
- W1-2: The paper does not explain why the continuous traffic evolution should pose a problem for long-horizon forecasting. In Figure 1(b), although the negative deviation persists for more than 100 steps across a day boundary, this is not a variation spanning the multi-day forecast horizons (288–2016 steps) that the paper targets.
- W2: The presentation is unclear and difficult to follow.
- W2-1: Some figures are difficult to understand. For example, in Figure 1(a), the axis labels do not describe the plotted quantities, so it is unclear what is being shown. In Figure 1(b), the manuscript does not explain what the vertical-axis label "deviation" refers to in the main body.
- W2-2: In Section 3, many symbols are introduced without definition, which makes it difficult to follow the derivations and their meaning (e.g., \mu in Eq. (1), \phi in Eq. (3), \beta and \sigma in Eq. (4), \eta in Eq. (6), \rho in Eq. (7), ...).
Questions for authors
- Q1: Related to W1, I understand that the three challenges raised in Introduction are all reasonable from the perspective of traffic forecasting, but could you explain why they become important problems specifically in long-horizon forecasting?
- Q2: Figure 2 explicitly says "traffic flow." Is the proposed method restricted to traffic flow, with travel speed, density, or other traffic variables out of scope? In my understanding, "traffic flow" usually refers to the number of vehicles passing per unit time.
- Q3: In the experiments, what is the intention behind changing the input sequence length depending on the forecast horizon?