- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2(+1)
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces CANDOR for forecasting in networked dynamical systems. It decomposes historical representations into background, accumulation, release, and shock components. These representations support propagation over physical topology and functional dependency learning beyond that topology. Three forecast branches are combined through adaptive fusion. Experiments on two traffic benchmarks and three water quality datasets report consistent improvements over 15 baselines, supported by repeated runs, ablations, and additional analyses.
Critical strengths
- The empirical evaluation provides meaningful evidence of forecasting effectiveness. The paper compares against 15 baselines, reports results over three seeds, and evaluates two distinct application domains. The reported improvements reach 4.31% in traffic MAE and 5.47% in water quality MSE. The complete results and ablation studies in the appendix strengthen confidence that the gains extend beyond a single dataset or experimental setting. This is the strongest consideration supporting acceptance.
- The architecture offers a useful way to combine physical topology with dependencies beyond direct connectivity. The ablations show that the contributions of the physical and functional branches vary across datasets, which supports their complementary use. The model also remains compact, with fewer than 0.91 million parameters. These results give the approach practical value for forecasting systems with different interaction patterns.
Critical weaknesses
-
The relationship to D2STGNN is insufficiently documented, which creates a substantial concern about attribution and originality. In the supplied implementation excerpts, CANDOR’s LocalizedSpatiotemporalConvolution closely follows D2STGNN’s STLocalizedConv, including temporal window extraction, graph power construction, local mean pooling, and graph convolution. CANDOR’s RelationCompatibility also closely follows DistanceFunction in its feature extraction pipeline and query and key computations. However, D2STGNN is absent from the manuscript’s citations and baseline comparisons. D2STGNN already combines residual decomposition, separate dynamics modeling, and dynamic graph learning, so these connections are directly relevant to the paper’s central contribution. The authors need to clarify the extent of reuse, the substantive modifications, and the newly introduced methods. The physical branch ablation establishes that the branch is useful, while leaving its contribution beyond the existing design unresolved.
-
The rationale and specific effectiveness of the proposed decomposition remain insufficiently established. The paper does not clearly explain which system dynamics or statistical assumptions justify the four components and the use of current and subsequent background references. Learned extractors and auxiliary objectives specify the computation, but further evidence is needed to justify this particular partition. The existing ablations support the usefulness of the complete decomposition module, while leaving its advantage over similarly sized alternatives unresolved. The subsequent combination of the components also makes it difficult to distinguish gains from improved node features from gains in dependency learning. This matters because the paper presents decomposition before dependency learning as its central methodological principle.
Questions for authors
- Clarification of implementation and attribution:
Please specify which modules were reused or adapted from D2STGNN, particularly LocalizedSpatiotemporalConvolution and RelationCompatibility. Please clarify their provenance, identify the substantive modifications, and explain how the manuscript distinguishes existing components from new contributions.
- Targeted evidence for the claimed contribution:
Is there a comparison between CANDOR and D2STGNN using the same data splits, forecasting inputs, and evaluation protocol? Please also identify which controlled comparisons retain the same physical backbone and separately evaluate the contributions of the new decomposition and functional relationship modeling. This evidence would materially affect my assessment of the contribution beyond prior work.
- Clarification and targeted evidence for the decomposition:
Please explain the generative or statistical assumptions that motivate the four components and the shifted background reference. Are there comparisons with plausible alternative decompositions under similar capacity and the same forecasting backbone? Such evidence would help establish whether the reported gains depend on this specific partition and how it supports subsequent dependency learning.
5 comments
Weakness2: Dynamical motivation, capacity-matched comparisons, and dependency learning
Weakness2:
1. Dynamical motivation for the four roles. Appendix A.1 of the revised manuscript develops the construction from traffic conservation and river transport–reaction balances. Under a nonnegative transport allocation, a node's state has complementary receiving and releasing descriptions. The receiving description combines the locally retained contribution with incoming Accumulation. The releasing description combines the part retained for the subsequent state with outgoing Release. An additional forcing response contributes to both descriptions.
These two descriptions motivate Background, Accumulation, Release, and Shock, together with the current and subsequent Background references. Their difference links Accumulation and Release to background evolution. CANDOR uses this structure as an inductive bias for latent role extraction, with both references lying within the observed history. Appendix A.1 provides the assumptions and derivation connecting the physical balances to these reference-dependent roles.
2. Comparison with similarly sized alternative decompositions. We added a parameter-matched w/o Decomp. control and Moving Average, STL, TimeMixer-style, and Trend-Season (DLinear-style) alternatives across all five datasets. Trainable parameter counts differ from CANDOR by less than 0.08%. The shared prediction loss, branch prediction supervision, and historical prediction consistency are retained, while constraints tied to particular components or state-separation mechanisms follow the corresponding construction. Each added control uses three seeds.
CANDOR achieves the lowest mean primary error on all five datasets. Relative to the strongest alternative decomposition, the reductions are 1.37% on METR-LA, 2.97% on PEMS-BAY, 2.80% on BASIN030501, 0.90% on BASIN031300, and 0.63% on BASIN180102. The parameter-matched w/o Decomp. also remains worse across all five datasets. Detailed configurations, parameter counts, and complete results are provided in Appendix A.11.
3. How decomposition contributes to node representations and dependency learning. The decomposition organizes node features into dynamical roles, and the architecture uses those roles to guide relation construction and propagation. Recombining the components produces task-adaptive historical representations for forecasting and information exchange. Alongside this integration, role-specific pathways continue to guide the relational computations.
Background is retained separately to construct the Functional Branch's cross-node relations. Shock is retained separately to modulate the Physical Branch's propagation features before spatial aggregation. Role-consistency supervision further connects next-patch Background to local temporal states, current Release to propagation residuals, and next-patch Accumulation to incoming graph contributions. Therefore, the decomposition shapes both the representations exchanged between nodes and the learning of their interactions.
This connection explains how recombination fits the method's central principle. The contribution of decomposition is expressed through its use in the downstream architecture. Node representation learning, relation construction, and propagation are trained jointly, and their ablation effects describe contributions within this coupled framework. Appendix A.10 evaluates the physical, functional, and relation-learning mechanisms, while Appendix A.11 examines whether comparable capacity or conventional temporal components reproduce the forecasting benefits.
These comparisons support decomposition before dependency learning as a role-conditioned organization of local dynamics and cross-node interactions. The architecture specifies how the decomposed information is used, and the decomposition supplies the dynamical roles that guide this processing across different spatiotemporal systems. In this setting, CANDOR's forecasting advantage comes from the combined effects of the decomposition mechanism and the forecasting architecture.
Questions1-3: Implementation, controlled comparisons, and decomposition
Question1:
1. Implementation and attribution. We have responsed code reuse, source attribution, and CANDOR's contributions in our response to Weakness1.
Question2:
We have added a full-model comparison and a physical-module replacement experiment. Below, we specify what each ablation retains.
1. Full-model comparison across systems. We compare CANDOR and D²STGNN under the same data splits, forecasting inputs, and evaluation protocol (Appendix A.8).
We use the same CANDOR architecture across road traffic and river water-quality networks. CANDOR achieves improvements on both traffic and river datasets. These results support its cross-system adaptability that one model architecture performs effectively in two distinct spatiotemporal systems.
The detailed results are provided in Section 4.1 and Appendix A.9 of the revised manuscript.
2. Replacement of the entire physical module. We replace CANDOR's entire physical module with the D²STGNN-based module while retaining the four-role decomposition and functional branch. The replacement configuration is described in Section 4.2.
In paired comparisons over three seeds, CANDOR's original physical module achieves lower primary error in four of the five settings. Replacing it with the D²STGNN module:
- Increases METR-LA MAE by approximately 1.0%.
- Increases MSE on the three river datasets by approximately 0.3%-6.6% at the 192-hour horizon, with the largest increase on BASIN180102.
- Decreases PEMS-BAY MAE by approximately 0.1%.
These comparisons support the effectiveness of CANDOR's integrated physical-module design across systems, with the clearest benefit on BASIN180102. The results are shown in Figure 8 of the revised manuscript.
3. What each ablation retains in the physical backbone. The configurations are defined as follows.
(1) w/o Decomp. This configuration retains directed, delay-aware graph construction and the bidirectional shared-feedback autoregressive rollout. It replaces the four-role representations with undecomposed patch features and removes decomposition-dependent processing, including Shock modulation.
(2) w/o Aux. loss. This configuration retains the decomposition module and the complete forward computation of the physical branch. It removes decomposition-specific auxiliary supervision, including dual-reference reconstruction and role alignment.
(3) w/o Functional, w/o Relation, and avg Fusion. Both w/o Functional and w/o Relation retain the physical module:
- w/o Functional removes the entire functional branch.
- w/o Relation disables cross-node functional relation learning while retaining the rest of that branch.
- avg Fusion evaluates an alternative fusion configuration.
The results are reported in Figure 8 of the revised manuscript.
(4) w/o Physical. This configuration removes the entire physical backbone, leaving the functional branch to produce the forecast.
(5) Forward only. This configuration retains the forward physical path and removes the reverse path.
(6) Reverse only. This configuration retains the reverse physical path and removes the forward path.
(7) Raw adjacency. This configuration retains the complete physical backbone and uses only the original physical adjacency for propagation.
(8) D²STGNN Physical. This configuration replaces CANDOR's entire physical backbone with the physical modeling structure of D²STGNN.
4. Overall evidence from the ablations. The ablations show that the four-role decomposition contributes across most evaluated settings, while functional relations also provide useful predictive information in most settings. In summary, the functional and physical branches form complementary views that allow the same architecture to adapt to different domains and retain competitive forecasting performance.
Question3:
1. Dynamical assumptions. Appendix A.1 of the revised manuscript provides the detailed derivation of the dynamical assumptions motivating the four roles and the two background references.
2. Capacity-matched alternative decompositions. To evaluate the proposed decomposition, we compare it with four alternative decompositions under matched model capacity and the same forecasting framework:
- Moving Average.
- STL.
- TimeMixer-style.
- Trend-Season (DLinear-style).
Under matched model capacity, CANDOR achieves the lowest mean primary error on all five datasets. The detailed results and experimental specifications are provided in Appendix A.11 of the revised manuscript.
We hope the clarifications and evidence provided in these three comments address your Ethics Concerns. We thank you for the suggestions, which helped us clarify implementation attribution, strengthen the controlled comparisons, and explain the decomposition rationale more clearly.
Weakness1: Relationship to D²STGNN and methodological contributions
Weakness1:
We address four aspects of this concern: the implementation relationship between CANDOR and D²STGNN, the omission of D²STGNN from the original citations and baseline comparisons, the substantive differences between their physical modules, and CANDOR's contributions beyond its physical branch.
1. Code reuse, adaptations, and attribution. The implementation of CANDOR's physical branch adapts parts of D²STGNN's foundational implementation. The original implementation retained D2-style comments identifying modules that referenced D²STGNN. The two methods differ substantially in their detailed implementation and overall computational architecture. To clarify this relationship, the supplementary material provides a class-by-class implementation comparison between CANDOR's model.py and D²STGNN, including the LocalizedSpatiotemporalConvolution and RelationCompatibility modules, together with architectural diagrams to show their differences in implementation and design. Our original baseline selection prioritized representative work from the preceding three years. D²STGNN fell outside that selection window and was consequently omitted from the original baseline set.
The revised manuscript now formally cites and discusses D²STGNN, includes it as a full-model baseline, and adds an ablation replacing CANDOR's physical module with the corresponding D²STGNN module. The README accompanying the code also acknowledges D²STGNN and the other implementation references. Through manuscript citations, experimental comparisons, code attribution, and the implementation comparison, we clarify the connection and specific differences between CANDOR and D²STGNN.
2. Physical-branch differences. The distinction concerns the propagated states, aggregation weights, and forecasting feedback:
Direction-specific states. D²STGNN applies forward, backward, and adaptive graph supports to a shared diffusion representation. CANDOR constructs separate forward and reverse states before aggregation, using direction-specific node-calendar gates, temporal encoders, and residuals. Each path maintains its own temporal memory and propagation residuals, making state construction and evolution direction-specific.
Shock modulation and offset-specific weights. CANDOR uses Shock to modulate the propagation before graph aggregation. D²STGNN adapts its graph to the input sample but shares a spatial support across positions within the local window. CANDOR uses
Wd,τ=RowNorm(Td⊙ωd,τ⊙ad),
where Td restricts physical edges, ωd,τ assigns edge affinities by temporal offset, and ad adapts node relations to the observed history. The propagation weights vary across both offsets and samples.
Stepwise recombination and shared feedback. D²STGNN rolls out diffusion and inherent forecasts separately before combining them. At each step, CANDOR combines the local temporal state and graph contribution in each direction:
hi,p+1d=Li,pd+oi,pd.
The two directional predictions are averaged and fed back to both paths. Each path then updates its own temporal memory and propagation residuals. This coordinates the forecasts while retaining separate directional state evolution.
Role supervision and functional relations. Role-consistency losses align next-patch Background with local temporal states, current Release with propagation residuals, and next-patch Accumulation with graph contributions. An independent functional branch uses Background to guide sparse multi-relation discovery beyond physical edges. Context-adaptive fusion combines the functional, forward-propagation, and reverse-support forecasts.
The supplementary material documents these differences through the implementation comparison and architectural diagrams.
3. Contributions beyond the physical branch. The physical branch is important, especially on traffic datasets. Our objective also includes a broadly applicable model that performs well across spatiotemporal domains. This is our primary motivation. Ablations show that removing physical propagation has a relatively small effect on BASIN030501 and BASIN031300, where the functional branch and four-role decomposition contribute more. This reflects differences in dynamics and predictive dependencies across systems. CANDOR combines complementary mechanisms without requiring one branch to dominate every setting, achieving the lowest mean primary error on all five datasets among the compared methods.