- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes EFSG for short-term traffic forecasting. The model builds a local branch using temporal convolutions and an adaptive graph, applies Euler Frequency Modulation (EFM) to adjust spectral magnitudes and phases, and constructs a dynamic graph based on similarities between node spectral magnitudes. Gated fusion then combines these representations for multi-step prediction. The authors report lower MAE than the listed baselines on PEMS03, PEMS04, NYC-Bike, and NYC-Taxi, together with lower peak GPU memory usage than TEDDCF.
Critical strengths
- The research problem is practically relevant. Changes in traffic peak magnitude and timing, as well as sudden demand fluctuations, directly affect traffic management and resource allocation and warrant investigation.
- The model workflow is reasonably clear. The architecture diagram and equations describe the modules and their data flow in sufficient detail to help readers understand the design.
- The reported MAE and memory results are promising. EFSG performs well in MAE relative to the listed baselines. Compared with TEDDCF, the authors report an approximately 19.9% reduction in MAE on NYC-Bike Pick-up and a 60% reduction in peak GPU memory usage on PEMS04.
Critical weaknesses
- The references contain multiple errors. At least seven entries contain incorrect author names. For example, Jiandong Bai in A3T-GCN is listed as Jie Bai, and Aoyu Liu and Yaying Zhang in STIDGCN are listed as Ao Liu and Yuzhou Zhang. The volume for MAGCRN should be 287 rather than 275, and the DOI for the official HiFiNet paper should be 10.1609/aaai.v40i18.38579. The bibliography requires a thorough check.
- Important related work and comparative baselines are missing. The published FMTGCN also combines Euler-based magnitude and phase modulation, graph construction using spectral magnitudes and a Gaussian kernel, and local temporal convolutions. It is neither cited nor compared against, leaving the novelty of EFSG unclear. FISTGCN is cited but excluded from the experiments. The introduction also uses A3T-GCN and STGODE as examples of computationally expensive models, without experimental comparisons or supporting cost measurements.
- Dataset coverage is limited, and the key scenarios are not directly evaluated. The study uses only four datasets, concentrated in two groups of closely related settings: PEMS03/04 both concern highway traffic flow, while NYC-Bike/Taxi capture travel demand in the same city and period. This coverage is insufficient to thoroughly establish effectiveness under complex, non-stationary traffic conditions. There is also no separate evaluation of sudden events or highly fluctuating periods, nor case studies and effect analyses of relationships between geographically non-adjacent nodes. More diverse settings or explicitly identified event samples are needed to validate these two central claims.
- Performance varies across metrics without sufficient analysis. MAPE is not the best on either PEMS03 or PEMS04. On both NYC-Bike tasks, EFSG improves MAE over TEDDCF but has worse RMSE and MAPE. For example, Pick-up MAPE increases from 52.41% to 56.94%. The paper primarily emphasizes MAE improvements without adequately explaining this trade-off or demonstrating that peak forecasting consequently improves.
- The ablation evidence is insufficient. Table 4 reports only aggregate metrics on NYC-Taxi. Removing the dynamic graph slightly improves some Drop-off metrics, and phase-only modulation also outperforms the full model on some metrics. Removing the entire frequency branch degrades performance, but this does not establish the necessity of magnitude modulation and spectral propagation individually, or the benefits of their interaction. The small differences are reported without standard deviations or confidence intervals, so stronger statistical support is needed.
Questions for authors
- Regarding missing related work and baselines: What are the substantive differences between EFSG and FMTGCN in magnitude and phase modulation, spectral graph construction, and temporal convolutions? Please add a discussion and direct comparison, and explain why the cited FISTGCN, as well as A3T-GCN and STGODE used in the introduction to discuss computational costs, are absent from the experiments.
- Regarding limited dataset and scenario coverage: How do the four datasets concentrated in two closely related types of settings support the claims about handling complex, non-stationary traffic? Please provide evidence from more diverse settings or explicitly identified event samples, and validate the practical benefits for forecasting sudden fluctuations and exploiting relationships between geographically non-adjacent nodes.
- Regarding inconsistent performance across metrics: Please explain why MAPE is not the best on PEMS03/04 and why MAE improves on NYC-Bike while RMSE and MAPE worsen. How do these results support the claimed improvement in peak forecasting?
- Regarding the ablation evidence: Please provide key module ablations across datasets, together with standard deviations or confidence intervals. Do the results where phase-only modulation or removal of the dynamic graph outperforms the full model on some metrics still support the necessity of magnitude modulation and spectral propagation, and the benefits of their interaction?
4 comments
Please Respond to the Authors’ Rebuttal
Dear Reviewer GmsR,
The discussion period ends in a few hours. Could you kindly check the authors’ responses and let us know whether your concerns have been addressed?
Thank you!
Best regards, The AC
I thank the authors for their clarifications, particularly regarding methodological differences, trade-offs among evaluation metrics, and computational costs. I also appreciate the clarification of the scope of the conclusions and the proposed revisions. However, the manuscript contains multiple issues concerning reference accuracy, comparisons with related work, and the wording of its claims. The novelty and depth of experimental validation also fall short of my expectations. Considering the overall quality and contribution of the work, I maintain my original score.
Euler Frequency Modulation for Non-Stationary Spatiotemporal Graph Traffic Forecasting
FMTGCN\cite{liu2026fmtgcn} maps traffic series to the frequency domain via FFT and complex convolution, applies Euler-based amplitude and phase terms, and constructs a spectrum-aware dynamic graph with Gaussian kernels on spectral magnitudes. However, its modulation parameters are essentially static (shared, input-agnostic), and it lacks an explicit local spatio-temporal graph pathway that couples physical topology with adaptive and sparse neighborhood graphs. Such designs are insufficient under non-stationary regimes where peak strength, peak timing, and local connectivity drift over time. Our 3SGNN addresses these gaps with input-dependent dynamic magnitude--phase modulation and a local graph branch tailored to non-stationary spatio-temporal forecasting.
Euler Frequency Modulation for Non-Stationary Spatiotemporal Graph Traffic Forecasting
We thank the reviewer for the detailed assessment. We clarify novelty, evidence, and revisions. Core results stand; we tighten wording where evidence is narrower.