- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
CyPhy-STN jointly forecasts multiple variables at graph nodes. Cyclic attention relates node histories within each variable, followed by graph messages inspired by continuity, diffusion, relaxation, advection, and reaction. Physical roles determine message inputs, and edge gates weight their contributions. Experiments cover two traffic and two atmospheric datasets, with a reported advantage in average rank and relative regret.
Critical strengths
- The evaluation covers two traffic and two atmospheric datasets with five seeds and per-variable results. CyPhy-STN keeps the best average rank after low-scale channels are excluded (Table 16), so the ranking is not explained by those channels alone.
- The graph pathway helps on traffic. Removing all physics messages worsens normalized error on both datasets (Table 9), and Figure 3 shows approximately 22% and 29% lower last-step flow MAE than the temporal-only variant on PEMS04 and PEMS08.
Critical weaknesses
I am not convinced that the experiments establish the contribution of channel-aware routing. Table 6 broadcasts mechanism outputs to all latent channels on PEMS04, PEMS08, and KnowAir. Physical roles still determine the source channels, but these three datasets do not test selective output routing. Beijing is the only selective case. There, the full model is worse than the temporal-only variant at the default horizon: MAE 51.143 versus 49.561, and normalized MAE 0.621 versus 0.614 (Table 2). Figure 3 does show gains at later horizons. Those gains, however, do not tell us whether selective routing helps compared with broadcasting the same messages. Removing individual operators does not answer that question either.
The definition of routing is also unclear. The abstract says learned routing determines which physical variables enter each mechanism. Sections 3.2.3 and A.1 instead describe specified roles and target-channel maps, alongside learned edge gates. Fixed role assignments are reasonable, but the paper should identify what is actually learned. As written, the claimed novelty and the experiments do not line up.
Questions for authors
- Are the source-role assignments, regime groups, and target-channel maps in Table 6 fixed configuration, or does training change any of them? Is “learned routing” intended to refer only to the edge gates in Equation (10)?
- On Beijing, how does selective routing compare with broadcasting the same mechanism outputs, with the remaining architecture and training held fixed? Pollutant errors across lead times would show whether routing contributes to the later-horizon gains.
Statement on Weaknesses and Questions
We want to thank the reviewer for the feedback and want to take the weaknesses as a chance for improvement.
W1 / Q2 – Contribution of selective routing
Routing has two parts, not clearly separated in the paper. We apologize for that.
We did not compare selective vs. broadcast output routing on Beijing. We no longer claim it as a contribution. Input routing is tested. On KnowAir, we varied the transported-quantity role, all else fixed (Tin=Tout=24, five seeds):
Results therefore change in a structured way.
Gap to temporal-only on Beijing. Physics raises the error over the first steps and lowers it later. It overtakes temporal-only from about step 10 (KnowAir) and step 25–30 (Beijing) (Fig. 3). Over 24 steps, this is neutral on KnowAir and negative on Beijing.
W2 / Q1 – What is learned? Only the edge gates?
Yes. Roles, regime groups and target-channel maps (Table 6) are fixed configuration. Training does not change them. Learnt are:
"Learnt routing" in the abstract was imprecise. The abstract and Sec. 3.2.3 are revised to avoid misunderstandings. We now claim the role-based mechanism is set, not learnt routing.