- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies what a forecasting model should predict when an upstream sensor stops helping and whether it should remember the previous delay. It compares using the target's history alone with keeping the original model but replacing the sensor input with its training average. This choice affects both prediction accuracy and how much delay information the model retains.
Critical strengths
- The paper raises a potentially useful forecasting problem, although its real-world relevance remains unclear.
Critical weaknesses
-
The writing is difficult to follow. The abstract and introduction introduce technical details before explaining the basic idea.
- The first two sentences do not clearly connect the possible causes of forecast error to what the model should "predict and remember."
- Terms such as "inactive prediction," "cancellation benefit," and "inactive delays" appear without clear explanations.
- The introduction also needs clearer explanations of "active state" and "inactive state."
-
The problem setting feels ad hoc. The paper does not establish that the specific relationship-loss setting occurs in the real-world datasets it uses.
-
The experimental scope is limited. The household experiment uses real sensor inputs, but its targets are generated using the same two controlled mechanisms. Although the paper includes some real-data and baseline comparisons, broader evaluation against forecasting baselines on standard benchmarks is needed.
-
The reference assumption is not well justified. Losing a sensor's influence is not necessarily equivalent to setting its input to the training average, even when the model still uses the target's recent history.
-
Given the lack of clarity in the current presentation, a clearer overview figure of the problem setting and method is needed to help readers follow the paper.
Questions for authors
- Can the authors test the full method against forecasting and online-adaptation baselines on real data with verified delay changes and relationship loss?