acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Revise, Don't Predict: Environment Response for Time Series Forecasting with Future Exogenous Variables

Abstract

In time series forecasting, future exogenous variables describe the environment over the forecasting horizon, offering information that historical observations alone cannot provide. Existing forecasters exploit such variables through feature fusion, cross-variable interaction, or conditional generation, focusing mainly on *how* future exogenous information enters a forecaster. We study a complementary question: *what should a dedicated future-environment pathway predict—the full target, or the change to a forecast already supported by history?* We formalize the latter as ***Environment Response***: history first establishes a reference forecast, and the future environment guides how this reference should change. Under squared loss, this role corresponds to the gap between the history-only and environment-aware Bayes predictors, isolating what the future environment adds beyond history. Building on this formulation, we propose **Environment-Guided Flow (EGF)**, which constructs the reference from complementary historical views, encodes the future environment relative to a reference environment, and progressively refines the reference forecast through conditional flow. Beyond EGF, Environment Response can be integrated into existing TSF-X forecasters as a lightweight adapter: on three representative backbones, assigning a matched environment pathway the Response role lowers MSE relative to using it for full-target prediction on 9 of 12 datasets for each backbone, and target-aligned diagnostics show that it moves environment-induced forecast changes closer to the target-required correction. On 12 real-world benchmarks, EGF achieves the best result on 23 of 24 dataset–metric averages.

Primary area:
learning on time series and dynamical systems
Keywords:
Time series forecasting, Exogenous variables, Flow matching, Forecast refinement

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 30%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.67 over 3 reviews, above 70% of the others.
Reviewer_tVvMOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies how to assign a dedicated future-environment pathway in time series forecasting with exogenous variables (TSF-X). The authors compare three roles (Native, Direct, and Response) under matched adapters on three backbones. They find that the Response role consistently lowers MSE relative to Direct, and propose Environment-Guided Flow (EGF) to realize it through three stages: History Belief, Environment Transport, and Flow Refinement. Experiments on 12 TSF-X datasets show EGF achieves the best result on 23 of 24 dataset-metric averages, with stage-level ablations confirming each component's contribution.

Critical strengths
  1. Forecasting with known future exogenous variables is widely applicable in industry and represents a promising research direction. This paper decouples the task from the perspectives of history belief and environment response, which is clean, well-motivated, and practically meaningful.

  2. The motivation in the main text is developed logically and smoothly. The method section is well-paced, covering key designs without redundancy. Figures and tables are clear and intuitive, making the paper highly readable and well-written overall.

  3. The Bayes decomposition in Eq. (1) and Appendix A.1 provides a clean theoretical foundation for the reference-plus-update inductive bias. The identity that the response has zero conditional mean given X and that its squared norm equals the reduction in Bayes risk is elegant and justifies the design.

  4. The paper compares against several recent strong TSF-X baselines and achieves state-of-the-art performance. The detailed experiments in the appendices provide solid empirical support for the method. The experimental design is rigorous and the conclusions are credible.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The rationale for flow matching is not sufficiently justified. Although Table 3 ablates against a one-step correction, that variant uses an MLP, whereas the vector field in Appendix B.3 is far more complex. This ablation cannot disentangle whether the gain comes from flow matching or from the more expressive vector field. I suggest adding a "one-step vector field" variant to verify the empirical necessity of flow matching.
  2. Section 4.2 demonstrates transferability across TSF-X methods. I am curious whether extending it to general time series forecasting methods (e.g., PatchTST) would also yield gains. This would validate the generality of the paradigm and help clarify whether it depends on the exogenous-variable modeling capacity specific to TSF-X.
Questions for authors

Please refer to Weaknesses.

Reviewer_XZhcOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies time series forecasting with future exogenous variables and argues that future environmental information should revise a history-supported reference forecast rather than directly participate in full-target prediction. Based on this idea, the authors introduce Environment Response and develop Environment-Guided Flow (EGF), consisting of History Belief, Environment Transport, and Flow Refinement to construct a history-supported reference, model future environmental changes and reweight historical hypotheses, and progressively refine the correction through conditional flow. Experiments are conducted on 12 real-world datasets, with additional Native, Direct, and Response comparisons on three backbones, DAG, CrossLinear, and TimeXer. Response achieves lower MSE than Direct on 9/12 datasets for each backbone, while the full EGF obtains the best result on 23/24 dataset--metric averages. Target-aligned correction analysis, environment intervention, and stage-level ablations are further used to validate the proposed design.

Critical strengths
  1. The authors provide a targeted reformulation of how future exogenous variables should be used in forecasting. Rather than jointly using historical information and future exogenous information for full-target prediction, the paper formulates forecasting as a history-supported reference prediction plus an environment-induced incremental response, and gives this response a clear statistical interpretation through conditional expectation decomposition. Based on this formulation, History Belief, Environment Transport, and Flow Refinement form a coherent methodological pipeline in EGF. In particular, future environmental information is not simply fused as an additional input, but is used relative to a reference environment to reweight historical hypotheses and progressively revise the reference forecast, keeping the method design closely aligned with the central problem posed by the paper.
  2. The paper provides relatively convincing cross-model validation of this design principle. The authors construct Direct and Response variants with matched parameter counts and temporal receptive fields on three different backbones, DAG, CrossLinear, and TimeXer. Response achieves lower MSE than Direct on 9/129/12 datasets for each of the three backbones, suggesting that the observed advantage is not specific to EGF itself. The full EGF further achieves the best result on 23/2423/24 dataset--metric averages across 12 datasets, and the paper complements these results with target-aligned correction analysis, environment interventions, and stage-level ablations to further examine how the proposed design operates.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper’s core claim is that the performance gain comes from shifting the predictive role of future exogenous variables from Direct to Response, but the current experiments do not fully isolate this factor. Although Direct and Response are matched in parameter count and temporal receptive field, they still differ in reference construction and initialization/optimization path, and RQ3 does not directly compare the parameter-matched Direct and Response variants. Therefore, the current evidence is insufficient to attribute the improvement specifically to the predictive role itself, which directly weakens the central claim of “Revise, Don’t Predict.”
  2. The paper contains recurring irregularities in figure presentation, including misaligned hats on mathematical symbols, notation inconsistent with the main text, inconsistent fonts and annotation styles, and noticeable differences in rendering quality across subfigures. These issues affect readability and reduce the transparency of the figure-generation process and result reproducibility. Since the paper relies heavily on visualizations to explain correction geometry, environment intervention, and internal mechanisms, these presentation issues weaken confidence in the reliability of the experimental presentation.
Questions for authors
  1. RQ2 uses Direct and Response to evaluate the effect of the predictive role, whereas RQ3 instead compares DAG with DAG+Response. As a result, Figure 3 simultaneously changes two factors: the introduction of a dedicated environment-response pathway and the predictive role assigned to that pathway. Why is the correction geometry not compared directly between Direct and Response? Under such a comparison, do target progress and off-target deviation still exhibit the same trends?
  2. The definition of the history-supported reference is not consistent across backbones. DAG uses a genuine history-only prediction, whereas CrossLinear and TimeXer construct the reference using the native forecast path under a persistence environment. The former is a history-only forecast, while the latter is still produced by the original future-aware forecasting path with the future environment replaced by persistence values. Given these different reference constructions, how can the paper support the claim that Response has the same semantics and is directly comparable across the three backbones?
  3. Response does not outperform Direct on every dataset. For example, CrossLinear shows a noticeable degradation on Sdwpfm1. Do these failure cases share any common characteristics? Under what conditions is Environment Response expected to be beneficial, and what are the empirical boundaries of its applicability?
  4. In Table 1, EGF results are averaged over five random seeds, DAG is reproduced using the official implementation, while most other baselines use results reported in their original papers. Are these results based on the same data splits, forecasting settings, and model-selection protocols? If these protocols are not fully aligned, to what extent does this affect the claim that EGF achieves the best result on 23/2423/24 dataset--metric averages?
  5. The paper states that the proposal and gate output layers in Response are initialized to zero, so that the initial prediction satisfies Y^R=Y^N\hat{Y}_R=\hat{Y}_N, meaning that Response starts from the Native prediction and learns a residual correction. Does Direct use an equivalent initialization that also aligns its initial prediction with Native? If not, how can the gain attributed to the predictive role be separated from the effect of residual initialization and the resulting optimization trajectory?
  6. Flow Refinement progressively updates the prediction through multiple velocity evaluations, whereas Table 3 uses a one-step MLP as the alternative. The two therefore differ not only in the refinement formulation, but also in their iterative computation. Has the paper compared against a single-step Flow variant, different numbers of refinement steps, or an iterative correction baseline with more closely matched computation? Without such controls, it is difficult to determine whether the improvement in Table 3 comes from flow-based refinement itself or from multi-step iterative refinement.
Reviewer_WRyqOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Environment-Guided Flow (EGF) for time series forecasting with future exogenous variables (TSF-X). The paper is well motivated and addresses a lot of applications in real-world scenarios. The proposed Environment Response formulation is intuitive and shares some similarities with classical residual-based methods and additive models. The paper also provides a clear mathematical explanation of Environment Response, although the theoretical analysis is largely based on established properties of conditional expectations rather than new theoretical results. The experimental results are quite competitive. EGF achieves the best MSE on 11 out of 12 datasets and the best MAE on all 12 datasets, outperforming several recent forecasting baselines.

Critical strengths
  1. It is a well-motivated paper and proposes an intuitive and effective forecasting framework to incorporate exogenous variables. The proposed framework combines multiple components.

  2. Competitive experimental results. The cross-backbone transfer experiments also look good to me.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The proposed framework looks over-complicated to me. The complete EGF includes too many components, such as multi-scale Transformer, phase view, environment contrast, KL trust et al. In particular, the flow refinement part requires more justification for its complicated design.
  2. The mathematical explanation looks good to me but does not provide in-depth insights to me. It is largely based on established properties of conditional expectations rather than new theoretical results. In other words, the theoretical novelty is rather limited to me.
Questions for authors
  1. The justification of flow matching. The one-step MLP refinement does not fully separate the benefits of flowing matching from other components.
  2. Most future exogenous variables are not directly observed but are instead predictions generated by other forecasting models, such as electricity demand and temperature forecasts. In real-world applications, these forecasts often underestimate extreme values, such as temperatures reaching 42°C. Such prediction errors may cause the proposed Environment Response mechanism to produce inaccurate or insufficient corrections to the reference forecast, potentially degrading overall forecasting performance. How robust is the proposed framework to errors and biases in future exogenous variables, particularly under extreme conditions?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.