- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
SCEU refines an endogenous-only linear forecast using multi-scale Temporal and Channel Utility representations conditioned on the current target state and forecast position. A gated, bounded residual controls the correction magnitude. The model is trained end to end with MAE loss, without utility annotations. Experiments on 13 datasets report competitive accuracy, component ablations, parameter sensitivity and evaluation under different future-covariate availability levels.
Critical strengths
- The motivation is clear. Beyond the CI, CD and CCM perspectives on whether and how channels interact, the paper considers how exogenous information differs in usefulness across future prediction steps. This provides a well-defined motivation for Step-Conditioned Exogenous Utility learning.
- The empirical evaluation is broad. The paper evaluates 13 real-world datasets, covering multivariate data and covariate-aware forecasting in electricity-market, energy and other settings.
Critical weaknesses
- Fine-grained ablations of the core design are insufficient. Table 2 mainly removes the entire Channel Utility or Temporal Utility branch, or the Adaptive Response Range. However, key choices include step-conditioned queries, state-conditioned utility, Softmax importance scores , tanh signed modulation , and their product . Their individual contributions relative to ordinary conditional attention or horizon-invariant weighting remain unclear. Useful ablations would remove step embeddings or state conditioning, replace signed utilities with nonnegative weights, or substitute standard cross-attention for utility scoring.
- The impact of bounded residuals on extreme-value forecasting is insufficiently evaluated. The final prediction is , with , and . Proposition 3 bounds the correction by . This may improve stability but could suppress responses to spikes, extreme weather or abrupt electricity-price changes. Aggregate MSE/MAE sensitivity analyses should be complemented by extreme-value subsets, peak errors, quantile losses or high-volatility periods.
Questions for authors
- Could utility learning and bounded correction become reusable components for forecasting backbones such as TimeXer, CrossLinear and PatchTST? What interfaces and additional assumptions would this require?
- Could the authors investigate patch lengths and more thoroughly, including different multi-scale combinations, shared versus distinct P/Q sets, the relationship between scale count and horizon , and effects on short- and long-horizon forecasting?
W1. Fine-grained ablations
We conducted four controlled ablations over 14 dataset–horizon settings: Shared Utility (removing step conditioning), No State (removing state conditioning), Softmax Only (removing signed modulation), and Cross-Attn (replacing utility scoring with standard cross-attention).
Positive values indicate higher errors relative to Full SCEU. Step conditioning provides the clearest benefit. Cross-attention replacement and removal of signed modulation also increase average errors, while state conditioning provides smaller, dataset-dependent gains. These results directly address the individual design choices and will be included in the revision.
W2. Bounded residuals and extreme events
Thank you for pointing out that aggregate errors can obscure performance on extreme values. We added a quantile-sliced evaluation on BE (H=24) and Weather (H=96). At each forecast step, we grouped test predictions by their true target values into the lowest 5%, middle 90%, and highest 5%. We then compared full SCEU, with the residual bound in Proposition 3, against the endogenous-only base forecast from the same model. The table reports relative error reductions.
SCEU improves forecasts of both unusually low and unusually high target values while keeping its corrections within the bound in Proposition 3. The largest gains occur for unusually low values, where SCEU reduces MAE by 56.39% on BE and 45.92% on Weather. For unusually high values, SCEU also reduces both MSE and MAE, with MAE reductions of 17.63% on BE and 14.68% on Weather relative to the endogenous-only base forecast.
Q1. Transferability to other backbones
We thank the reviewer for this suggestion. We integrated SCEU's adaptive bounded correction into TimeXer and evaluated it on BE and PJM at a forecast horizon of H=24, using a correction range of [0.1,1.0].
Values are MSE / MAE. Relative to the original TimeXer, the correction reduces MSE and MAE on PJM by 5.3% and 3.6%, respectively, and increases them on BE by 5.6% and 5.1%, respectively.
This experiment demonstrates that adaptive bounded correction can be integrated into TimeXer and can improve its forecasts, as observed on PJM. The different outcomes under the same correction range suggest that the correction range and gate initialization should be tuned for the target backbone and dataset.
Q2. Patch lengths and multi-scale configurations
We appreciate the suggestion. Default patch lengths follow DAG. We additionally evaluate alternative P/Q sets and scale configurations on BE and Energy at H=24,168, covering short- and longer-horizon forecasting.
P/Q combinations: Let A=[4,8,24] and B=[8,12,24]. AA shares P/Q sets, whereas AB and BA use distinct sets.
BB was also evaluated but did not achieve the best result. Neither shared nor distinct P/Q sets consistently dominate.
Scale combinations: K1–K4 contain one to four scales, respectively.
The results reveal horizon-dependent preferences: BE favors K2 at both horizons, while Energy favors K4 at H=24 and K3 at H=168. Thus, longer horizons do not necessarily require more scales, and increasing K does not guarantee better accuracy. Patch lengths determine temporal granularity, whereas K controls representation diversity and H determines prediction length. Their optimal combinations depend on dataset characteristics and horizon. Since scale count and patch composition vary together, their effects cannot be fully isolated. These experiments complement Section 5.3.2 and Figure 4 and will be clarified in the revision.