- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes Input-Condition Integration (ICI) for frozen covariate-aware time series foundation models. It replays historical events under three input conditions, fits event-aligned quantile corrections, and uses chronological validation to select native or corrected forecasts. Evaluation covers controlled synthetic relationships and real-world benchmarks with three backbones. However, the principal real-world results are explicitly labeled as illustrative placeholders and reused in the main analysis, substantially undermining the credibility and significance of the empirical claims and raising serious concerns about the integrity of the experimental reporting.
Critical strengths
- Separating historical forecast correction from conditioning-response diagnostics is a sensible design choice that allows correction without requiring a strong backbone response.
- The synthetic setup includes null and relationship-shift conditions, making the method's dependence on transferable historical relationships explicit.
Critical weaknesses
- The central real-world evidence is presented as both experimental results and drafting placeholders. Table 2 repeats all 18 corresponding values from Table 7, whose caption explicitly designates the numbers as placeholders; Table 8 does likewise for the earlier cohort. Section 4.3 and Appendix E.1 interpret these results as empirical findings, and Table 9 repeats Table 7's aggregate values. No replacement set of measured results is identified in the manuscript. This is a serious reporting-integrity concern that prevents reliance on the real-world conclusions. Treating the captions as obsolete drafting text would not adequately resolve the contradiction without substantiating the reported results.
- The method is not compared with the cited TFMAdapter (CIKM 2025), and no real-world event-only ablation isolates the value of three-view guidance. Most improvement in the synthetic ablation comes from the base correction, leaving the added mechanism's practical contribution unclear.
Questions for authors
- Are the values in Tables 2, 7, 8, and 9 measured results or placeholders? If the captions are obsolete, what existing experimental evidence substantiates the reported values and their interpretation?
- Under the same available history and covariates, how does ICI compare with TFMAdapter and its own event-only correction on real-world tasks?
2 comments
Dear authors, the rebuttal phase is nearing its end. If there is no further information to provide, I will maintain my current ratings and recommend rejection.
Thank you for your careful review. We appreciate your observation that separating historical forecast correction from conditioning-response diagnostics allows the method to apply a correction even when the backbone responds weakly. We also appreciate your point that the null and relationship-shift experiments make the method’s reliance on transferable historical relationships explicit.
During drafting, we generated Tables 7 and 8 in Appendix E with temporary values, and the table-generation process automatically added a note to each caption identifying the values as placeholders. We replaced those values with results from completed experiments before submission. We overlooked the notes when updating the tables. Table 2 reports selected task-level results from Table 7.
We also found errors in some of the reported macro averages in Tables 7 and 8. The affected averages from Table 7 also appear in the "All cases" column of Table 9. We apologize for leaving the placeholder notes in the captions and for the errors in the reported averages.
Thank you for suggesting real-world comparisons with TFMAdapter and with our event-only correction under the same available history and covariates. As you point out, the base correction accounts for most of the gains in the synthetic ablation. Your suggestions give us clear priorities for a future revision, particularly for assessing what three-view guidance adds on real-world tasks.