- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The authors propose a novel module, ReQuA, which helps time-series foundation models (TSFMs) leverage auxiliary variables to capture residual prediction errors that the original model has not yet eliminated. The proposed framework consists of query aggregation, residual grounding, and global calibration.
Critical strengths
The method is well-designed, with a coherent set of complementary mechanisms. In addition to the Query Aggregator, the authors introduce residual grounding and a second-stage global calibration procedure. Residual grounding encourages the query representation to learn error structures that remain unexplained by the frozen backbone, while calibration uses a global scalar to control the magnitude of the correction and mitigate the risk of overcorrection.
Critical weaknesses
-
The related work section discusses several existing covariate-aware adaptation methods for time-series foundation models (TSFMs), yet these methods are not included in the experimental comparisons. The authors' justification for excluding them is insufficient. I would expect these recent and relevant methods to be included in the evaluation.
-
Given that the reported results vary across different TSFMs, evaluating the proposed method on only a limited number of time-series foundation models as backbones is insufficient. The authors should consider a broader range of models to better establish the generalizability of the proposed approach.
-
The authors should provide a more in-depth analysis of the conditions under which residuals remain predictable. If a sufficiently powerful model produces residuals between its predictions and the ground truth that are nearly unpredictable and resemble random noise, the proposed method may have corresponding limitations. This possibility should be investigated and discussed more thoroughly.
-
Figure 1 requires further refinement, particularly in its visual presentation. The overlap between arrows and figure boundaries detracts from the clarity and polish of the figure, making it fall short of the standard expected of a formal framework diagram in a research paper.
Questions for authors
See in the Critical Weakness part.
2 comments
Thanks to the author for the additional experiments, this solved most of my concerns, and I’ll be raising my score.
**Response to Reviewer nVs2**
Thank you for the helpful suggestions, and in particular for the question of when residuals remain predictable. We examined this with a negative control, and we also added the comparisons and backbones you requested.
Q1. Comparisons with existing adaptation methods
We added UniCA, ChronosX, and CoRA, together with supervised iTransformer and TimeXer. The table reports the mean of per-dataset percentage error reductions against native-multivariate frozen Chronos-2 on the same eight tasks (higher is better).
UniCA is ahead on average MAE. The average MSE values are close (19.50 for ReQuA, 19.22 for UniCA), and ReQuA uses 1.70M trainable parameters and 5% of the downstream training origins. Because CoRA is run through a channel-independent Chronos-2 interface and ReQuA adapts the native multivariate model, the comparison is not strictly like-for-like.
Q2. Broader backbone evaluation
In addition to Chronos-2, TimesFM-3, and Moirai-1.1, we evaluated ReQuA on Chronos-Bolt-base and Timestral-28M (Mistral AI, October 2026). Improvements are computed against each model's own frozen baseline and then averaged across datasets.
These five backbones differ in architecture and output head. Chronos-Bolt is evaluated at horizon 64 (24 for ILI) instead of 96. The Moirai-1.1 average MSE gain equals the Chronos-2 value by coincidence.
Q3. Conditions for residual predictability
Let I denote the information available to the adapter at inference time, and define the frozen-model residual as
r = y − ŷ_frozen. Under squared error, the optimal unconstrained additive correction isg*(I) = E[r | I]. If r is independent zero-mean noise, theng*(I) = 0.We tested this boundary on ETTh1 with an MSE-matched negative control. We replaced the training, validation, and test targets with
ỹ = ŷ_frozen + ε, where ε is independent Gaussian noise matched to the second moment of the real frozen residual. ReQuA's training, checkpoint selection, residual grounding, and held-out scalar calibration were unchanged.Frozen-model test MSE was closely matched (0.3999 vs. 0.4022). On independent noise, the MSE gain disappears and calibration shrinks the correction scale to 0.092, whereas with real residuals ReQuA retains a +7.52% MSE improvement. ReQuA's gain depends on the frozen residual being predictable from the auxiliary history. Our horizon study (Appendix E.2) shows the same pattern. On ETTh1 at H = 720 the gain disappears (ΔMSE −1.04%), consistent with the residual becoming less predictable from historical covariates at long horizons.
Q4. Figure 1
We redesigned the framework diagram so that arrows no longer overlap module boundaries and frozen and trainable modules are visually distinct. The horizon-conditioning path is now explicit, and the correction is shown to modify only the target's forecast-generating latent states.