- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes BRICE, a brain-inspired recurrent encoder for point cloud completion. By incorporating feedforward-feedback connections under the Predictive Coding framework, BRICE aims to improve feature representations and enhance the recovery of missing geometric structures. The proposed module is designed to be plug-and-play and is evaluated across multiple point cloud completion baselines and benchmarks. While the brain-inspired perspective is interesting and the experiments demonstrate certain improvements, I have concerns regarding the methodological novelty and the consistency of performance gains.
Critical strengths
-
This paper proposes a plug-and-play recurrent module for point cloud completion and evaluates its effectiveness across multiple baselines and benchmarks.
-
The brain-inspired perspective on improving point cloud completion is interesting. The extensive quantitative comparisons, qualitative visualizations, and ablation studies provide some evidence supporting the effectiveness of the proposed method.
Critical weaknesses
-
I have some concerns regarding the originality of the proposed method. In particular, the differences between BRICE and the existing work FBNet [1] should be further clarified. Both methods explore feedback mechanisms for point cloud completion. The authors are encouraged to provide a more detailed comparison and explicitly highlight the methodological contributions of BRICE beyond existing feedback-based approaches.
-
Although BRICE improves the performance of several baselines, the improvements are relatively marginal in some cases. For example, in Table 2, the improvement over the original SnowflakeNet is almost negligible. Moreover, as shown in Table 3, integrating BRICE into SymmCompletion and ODGNet even leads to performance degradation. These results raise concerns about the consistency and general applicability of the proposed module. Further discussion of the conditions under which BRICE is effective would strengthen the experimental analysis.
[1] FBNet: Feedback Network for Point Cloud Completion, ECCV 2022.
Questions for authors
See Critical Weaknesses.
4 comments
Response to Reviewer sP9m (2/2)
W2: Although BRICE improves the performance of several baselines, the improvements are relatively marginal in some cases. For example, in Table 2, the improvement over the original SnowflakeNet is almost negligible. Moreover, as shown in Table 3, integrating BRICE into SymmCompletion and ODGNet even leads to performance degradation. These results raise concerns about the consistency and general applicability of the proposed module. Further discussion of the conditions under which BRICE is effective would strengthen the experimental analysis.
Response: As you have noted, because BRICE is a plug-and-play module built upon explicit theoretical priors, its effectiveness indeed possesses specific applicability boundaries. We candidly attribute these phenomena to the following factors, which also represent the limitations of our current work: SnowflakeNet intrinsically incorporates an exceptionally powerful and complex 'Snowflake Point Deconvolution (SPD)' mechanism. This decoder has already pushed the extraction of local geometric features to an extreme engineering limit. In such scenarios, the performance bottleneck of the overall network is often no longer the feature representation capacity of the encoder, causing the gains introduced by BRICE to appear relatively marginal. However, even on such a formidable baseline, BRICE still ensures a stable performance lower bound without requiring any alterations to the decoder's physical architecture.
A detailed explanation regarding the performance degradation observed with SymmCompletion and ODGNet, along with a discussion of BRICE's optimal operating conditions, has been provided in Section 4.2 of the manuscript. The specific details are as follows:
On the PCN dataset, the undesirable adaptation of BRICE on ODGNet may relate to the dictionary-guided decoder of ODGNet that strongly abstracts common morphological features from all objects of the same category as a strong prior knowledge to facilitate 3D completion. This decoder design is well-suited for man-made objects (such as planes, vehicles, etc.) from which shared structural knowledge can be easily generalized, and the limited diversity of objects (only 8 classes) of PCN further amplifies the effect of the decoder. Adding BRICE to ODGNet probably breaks the formation of shared knowledge. BRICE’s failing to improve SymmCompletion may due to the latter's tailored decoder for 3D geometric symmetry as prior knowledge. Given that all 8 object classes in the PCN dataset are artificial objects with strong bilateral symmetry, the integration of BRICE disrupts the symmetry prior, leading to a decline in performance.
[1] Xuejun Yan, Hongyu Yan, Jingjing Wang, Hang Du, Zhihong Wu, Di Xie, Shiliang Pu, and Li Lu. Fbnet: Feedback network for point cloud completion. In European conference on computer vision, 2022.
We hope our responses have successfully addressed your concerns and clarified any questions you had regarding the manuscript. Please let us know if you require any further discussion or clarification!
Thank you to the authors for their response and additional experiments. After considering the other reviewers’ comments, I remain concerned that the largest reported gain relies on a PointAttN baseline that the authors acknowledge did not converge optimally. The gains are also inconsistent across baselines, and the new controls do not match computational cost. These issues limit the strength of the paper’s general claims. I therefore maintain my original score.
I encourage the authors to continue refining the paper. With a stronger experimental evaluation and more carefully scoped claims, I believe this work can find a suitable venue.
Response to Reviewer sP9m
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you for your follow-up. We would like to clarify the misunderstanding caused by the improper phrasing in our previous response:
We must sincerely apologize for the inaccurate statement ("failed to reach an optimal convergence state") in our previous rebuttal, which contradicted our actual experimental results and misled your judgment. First, PointAttN (6.95) fully reached optimal convergence rather than failing to converge; we have uploaded the training loss curves of PointAttN, +BRICE, and +BRICE+pre in the attachment, which clearly demonstrate that it has reached convergence. The reason for our poor phrasing in the previous round is that the original PointAttN paper did not report results on MVP2K; what we actually intended to convey was that "PointAttN’s native architecture suffers from an inherent representation bottleneck under the multi-category (16 classes) and sparser input setting of MVP2K, resulting in a slightly higher absolute error (6.95) compared to more recent baselines such as CRA-PCN," rather than suggesting that it was not trained to convergence.
Furthermore, our four newly added independent control experiments directly verify this: the original PointAttN (6.95), w/ equal-budget feedforward with added feedforward layers (6.99), w/ generic recurrent with standard recurrence (6.88), and w/ pre with LHD pretraining (6.87) all stably converged within a very narrow range of 6.87–6.99. This demonstrates that around 6.95 reflects the true performance of the PointAttN encoder after full convergence on MVP2K, and it is only through the introduction of BRICE that this representation bottleneck is broken (6.95→5.62, and 5.55 with pretraining).
We sincerely hope that these clarifications and the attached training curves address your remaining concerns, and we would be deeply grateful if you could reconsider your evaluation of our work.
Best regards,
Authors
Response to Reviewer sP9m (1/2)
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you very much for carefully reviewing our work and for your valuable feedback. We have now uploaded the revised manuscript. In the PDF file, all newly added or modified sections have been highlighted in yellow for easier identification. Additionally, to provide a deeper understanding of our work, we have included an explanatory video in the supplementary materials. We kindly invite you to review it at your convenience.
W1: I have some concerns regarding the originality of the proposed method. In particular, the differences between BRICE and the existing work FBNet [1] should be further clarified. Both methods explore feedback mechanisms for point cloud completion. The authors are encouraged to provide a more detailed comparison and explicitly highlight the methodological contributions of BRICE beyond existing feedback-based approaches.
Response: We fully agree that FBNet (ECCV 2022) [1] is an excellent and pioneering work exploring feedback mechanisms for point cloud completion. However, BRICE differs from FBNet in several fundamental aspects. First, they differ in the location of the feedback (recurrent structure). BRICE's recurrence occurs at the very front end of the network, whereas FBNet employs recurrence in the later stages, specifically within the decoder. Second, the computational mechanisms are different. BRICE utilizes a recurrent computational mechanism guided by predictive coding (modeling the primary visual cortex), featuring layer-wise feature reconstruction and feedback. In contrast, FBNet relies on standard implicit multi-layer feature feedback without a strong reconstruction process. Third, BRICE is proposed as a universal, plug-and-play encoder capable of enhancing most mainstream point cloud completion networks, whereas the feedback recurrent computation in FBNet does not share this general applicability. Fourth, the completion performance of BRICE combined with mainstream networks significantly surpasses that of FBNet.
We even conducted an interesting experiment by attempting to enhance FBNet using BRICE. We evaluated the direct integration of BRICE and FBNet on the MVP2K dataset. The results are as follows:
Table: Experiments for FBNet on the MVP2K by L2-CD. Omitted by ×10−4 for readability.
As shown in the table above, forcibly combining BRICE (a dynamic encoder with feedback) and FBNet (an iterative decoder with feedback) not only fails to improve performance (the error increases from 6.31 to 6.53) but also causes a severe surge in network parameters and computational overhead. This failure stems from conflicts in their neurobiological plausibility and underlying structural designs. A detailed analysis is as follows: First, the BRICE+FBNet hybrid forms a full-chain, physical-level loop. This forces every layer of the network to attempt to reconstruct the point cloud, causing the "incomplete" physical morphology of the input to be propagated all the way to the end, which is actually detrimental to the recovery of missing high-frequency information. Second, the feedback mechanisms in BRICE and FBNet are fundamentally different, leading to a functional mismatch upon integration. FBNet’s feedback is implicit and macroscopic (re-encoding the output point cloud and concatenating it with previous layer features). In contrast, BRICE is explicit and microscopic, directly computing the Chamfer Distance (CD) reconstruction error between the top-down predicted features and the bottom-up actual features within the latent feature space.