- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SUMI, a symmetry-guided diffusion refinement module for point cloud completion. By incorporating iterative diffusion into a coarse-to-fine framework, the method aims to improve local geometric details while preserving global structural consistency. The paper is well-written and presents extensive experiments across multiple benchmarks. However, I have concerns regarding the clarity of the research motivation, the methodological novelty, and whether the relatively limited performance improvements justify the additional computational overhead.
While this paper is well-presented and supported by extensive experimental evaluations, I remain concerned about its methodological novelty and the relatively limited performance gains compared with the additional computational overhead. In particular, the authors should better distinguish SUMI from existing symmetry-guided and diffusion-based point cloud completion methods and provide a more convincing justification for its design. Further clarifying the specific contributions of SUMI to the point cloud completion task would substantially improve the quality of this paper. Given these concerns, I consider even my current score of 2 to be somewhat generous.
Critical strengths
-
The paper is generally well-written and well-organized, with a clear presentation and good overall readability. The figures and illustrations effectively support the explanation of the proposed framework.
-
The proposed method is evaluated on multiple benchmarks, including PCN, ShapeNet-55/34, and MVP. The quantitative comparisons, qualitative visualizations, and ablation studies provide a relatively comprehensive experimental evaluation and demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed approach to some extent.
Critical weaknesses
-
Unclear research motivation. The motivation of this paper is not sufficiently clear or convincing. Recovering finer local geometric details is a common challenge that has already been extensively investigated by existing point cloud completion methods, such as SeedFormer [1] and CRA-PCN [2]. Therefore, the authors should further clarify the specific limitations of existing approaches and explain why the proposed diffusion-based refinement module is necessary to address them.
-
Concerns about methodological novelty. SUMI can be viewed as an incremental improvement over SymmCompletion [3] through the introduction of a diffusion-based refinement module. Moreover, the methodological differences between the proposed diffusion mechanism and existing diffusion-based point cloud completion methods, particularly 3DDM [4], should be further elaborated. A more detailed discussion is needed to clarify the unique contributions of SUMI beyond existing symmetry-guided and diffusion-based approaches.
-
Concerns about the effectiveness and computational overhead. I have concerns about whether the performance improvements justify the additional computational cost. As reported in Table A6, the largest SUMI configuration requires approximately 9.7% more peak GPU memory than SymmCompletion. However, the average CD in Table 1 improves only slightly from 6.33 to 6.27 (approximately 0.95%) for the main SUMI configuration. Although these results correspond to different SUMI configurations, they raise concerns about the overall trade-off between completion accuracy and computational efficiency. A more comprehensive efficiency analysis would help establish the practical benefits of the proposed method.
[1] SeedFormer: Patch Seeds based Point Cloud Completion with Upsample Transformer. ECCV 2022.
[2] CRA-PCN: Point Cloud Completion with Intra- and Inter-level Cross-ResolutionTransformers. AAAI 2024.
[3] SymmCompletion: High-Fidelity and High-Consistency Point Cloud Completion with Symmetry Guidance. AAAI 2025.
[4] 3DDM:Physically-based Anisotropic 3D Diffusion Model with 3D Gaussian for Point Cloud Completion. AAAI 2026.
Questions for authors
See Critical Weaknesses.