- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces ScaleBlind, a point cloud completion framework designed for scenarios where the ground-truth shape scale is unavailable during inference. The authors highlight that conventional point cloud completion benchmarks often rely on ground-truth-based normalization, which introduces privileged scale information that may not be accessible in practical applications. To address this issue, ScaleBlind leverages a pretrained image generation model to complete multi-view renderings of partial point clouds, reconstructs a coarse geometric prior through voxel voting, and incorporates the recovered prior into a coarse-to-fine completion network. Experiments demonstrate promising completion performance under both GT-scale-free and conventional evaluation settings.
Critical strengths
-
The paper identifies an important limitation of conventional point cloud completion protocols and investigates completion under unknown global scale. This setting is practically relevant, particularly when substantial missing regions prevent partial observations from preserving the full spatial extent of an object.
-
The proposed framework provides a coherent solution by combining foundation-model-based image completion, multi-view geometric prior reconstruction, and prior-guided point cloud refinement. The experimental results demonstrate competitive performance and improvements over several existing methods, supporting the potential of the proposed approach.
Critical weaknesses
-
The experimental comparisons omit several recent point cloud completion methods, such as SymmCompletion (AAAI'25) and Hyper-PCN (CVPR'26). More importantly, under the GT-scale-free setting, most existing baselines are provided with scale estimates produced by ScaleBlind's prior acquisition module. While this is a reasonable strategy for comparing completion architectures under a shared scale estimate, it does not fully establish that conventional completion architectures are inherently unable to handle unknown-scale inputs. A more informative comparison would retrain representative baselines, such as AdaPoinTr, using partial-only normalization during both training and inference. This would help clarify whether the reported improvements primarily originate from the proposed scale estimation mechanism, the completion architecture, or their combination.
-
Recovering the unknown global extent of incomplete objects is a central motivation and contribution of this paper. However, the current evaluation primarily relies on conventional completion metrics, including CD, DCD, and F-Score. These metrics assess the quality of the final completed point clouds but do not directly measure the accuracy of the recovered scale. I suggest reporting explicit scale estimation metrics, such as the relative error between the estimated and ground-truth shape scales.
-
The current ablation studies mainly investigate the confidence attribute, hierarchical image features, and the number of viewpoints. Although these results are useful, they do not sufficiently disentangle the contributions of the major components of the proposed framework. In particular, it would be helpful to evaluate the completion network without the generated geometric prior, with scale estimation alone, and with different combinations of geometric candidate points and image features. Additionally, the computational analysis could be more comprehensive. Since the framework relies on multiple image generation calls and volumetric prior reconstruction, its practical efficiency is an important consideration. Although the supplementary material includes an analysis of inference time with different numbers of viewpoints, a breakdown of the complete inference pipeline, including image generation, voxel voting, and point cloud refinement, would better characterize the computational overhead.
Questions for authors
-
Have the authors considered retraining conventional completion methods under partial-only normalization, without using ScaleBlind's estimated scale? How would their performance compare with the proposed method?
-
Can the authors provide quantitative results for the recovered scale itself, rather than evaluating only the final completion quality? How does scale estimation accuracy vary with the missing ratio?
-
What is the relative contribution of the scale estimation module and the prior-guided completion network? In particular, how would the performance change if the estimated scale were retained but the generated geometric prior and image features were removed?
-
What is the end-to-end inference time per object, including the multi-view image generation process? How much computational overhead does the proposed framework introduce compared with conventional point cloud completion methods?
6 comments
W2: Recovering the unknown global extent of incomplete objects is a central motivation and contribution of this paper. However, the current evaluation primarily relies on conventional completion metrics, including CD, DCD, and F-Score. These metrics assess the quality of the final completed point clouds but do not directly measure the accuracy of the recovered scale. I suggest reporting explicit scale estimation metrics, such as the relative error between the estimated and ground-truth shape scales.
A: We introduce Global Scale Error (GSE) to directly measure the relative error between the estimated global extent and the ground-truth complete shape. The detailed formulation and evaluation procedure are provided in Appendix E.7 (Eqs. (8)–(10) and Table E5) of the revised paper.
Specifically, during data construction, we divide each complete shape into the partial observation and the removed region. We independently normalize the partial observation and generate geometric candidates through multi-view voxel voting. To evaluate scale recovery, we align the normalized partial observation back to its original coordinates and apply the same inverse transformation to the voting candidates. We then combine the transformed candidates with the original partial observation and compute GSE as the relative difference between the bounding-box diagonal lengths of the estimated complete shape and the GT. GT information is used only for evaluation, not for constructing the geometric priors.
The quantitative results under different missing ratios are reported below.
| Missing Ratio | GSE ↓ |
|---|---|
| 25% | 7.04% |
| 50% | 9.31% |
| 75% | 12.52% |
GSE increases from 7.04% to 12.52% as the missing ratio rises from 25% to 75%, indicating that scale estimation becomes more challenging with greater incompleteness. These results directly quantify the accuracy of our recovered global extent, with a relative error of 12.52% even at a 75% missing ratio.
W3-1: The current ablation studies mainly investigate the confidence attribute, hierarchical image features, and the number of viewpoints. Although these results are useful, they do not sufficiently disentangle the contributions of the major components of the proposed framework. In particular, it would be helpful to evaluate the completion network without the generated geometric prior, with scale estimation alone, and with different combinations of geometric candidate points and image features.
A: We conduct additional ablation experiments to separately examine the contributions of scale estimation alone, geometric candidate points, and image features, as well as the effects of geometric prior confidence and the number of image views used for completion. These experiments complement the existing ablations on confidence attributes and hierarchical image features in Table 2 and the viewpoint analysis in Fig. E3. These additional experiments are included in Appendices E.4–E.6 (Tables E2–E4) of the revised paper.
1. Scale Estimation and Component Ablation
To directly assess the contribution of scale estimation alone, we retain the estimated scale obtained from P_merge for normalization, but remove both the voting candidates and image features from the completion network. We also evaluate two additional configurations: (1) w/o Joint Normalization, where we use the independently normalized partial point cloud as the geometric input while retaining image features; and (2) w/o Image Features, where we retain P_merge-based normalization and geometric candidates but remove the image feature branch.
| Metric | Full Model | w/o Joint Normalization | Scale Estimation Only | w/o Image Features |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CD-Avg ↓ | 6.21 | 8.89 | 7.81 | 7.52 |
| DCD-Avg ↓ | 0.514 | 0.576 | 0.563 | 0.559 |
| F1 ↑ | 0.871 | 0.764 | 0.793 | 0.801 |
The scale-estimation-only variant achieves a CD-Avg of 7.81, demonstrating that the estimated scale can support completion even without geometric candidates or image features as network inputs. Adding geometric candidates further reduces CD to 7.52, while incorporating image features improves it to 6.21. Similar improvements are observed in DCD and F1. In comparison, using only the independently normalized partial point cloud with image features yields a CD of 8.89. These results highlight the complementary benefits of estimated scale, geometric candidates, and image features in our framework.
2. Generated 3D Priors (Confidence Threshold)
To investigate the influence of generated geometric priors, we vary the confidence threshold τ ∈ {0.0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, 1.0}, while keeping the partial input and 13 image features unchanged. At τ = 0, we retain voxels with probability > 0 to exclude zero-probability voxels. For all other thresholds, we retain voxels with probability ≥ τ.
| Metric | τ = 0.0 | τ = 0.2 | τ = 0.4 | τ = 0.6 | τ = 0.8 (Default) | τ = 1.0 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CD-Avg ↓ | 11.73 | 8.97 | 7.17 | 6.39 | 6.21 | 6.71 |
| DCD-Avg ↓ | 0.728 | 0.583 | 0.551 | 0.528 | 0.514 | 0.542 |
| F1 ↑ | 0.621 | 0.752 | 0.812 | 0.863 | 0.871 | 0.850 |
Lower thresholds retain more unreliable geometric candidates and degrade completion performance, while overly strict thresholds may discard useful geometric information. The default threshold τ = 0.8 achieves the best performance across all three metrics, confirming the importance of confidence-aware geometric prior selection.
3. Image Features (Number of Views)
To isolate the contribution of image features, we fix the geometric prior and estimated scale for each sample, varying only the number of images provided to the completion network. Specifically, we randomly select 1, 3, 5, 7, 9, or 11 views from the original 13, and train each setting independently using reproducible random sampling.
| Metric | 1 View | 3 Views | 5 Views | 7 Views | 9 Views | 11 Views | 13 Views (Default) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CD-Avg ↓ | 6.68 | 6.60 | 6.54 | 6.45 | 6.37 | 6.29 | 6.21 |
| DCD-Avg ↓ | 0.541 | 0.537 | 0.536 | 0.531 | 0.527 | 0.520 | 0.514 |
| F1 ↑ | 0.852 | 0.855 | 0.857 | 0.862 | 0.864 | 0.867 | 0.871 |
With geometric priors and estimated scales fixed, increasing the number of image views consistently improves completion performance. CD-Avg decreases from 6.68 with one view to 6.21 with 13 views, demonstrating that multi-view image features provide complementary guidance for geometric refinement.
Thank you for your insightful comments. We answer your concerns and questions in the following.
A: We additionally evaluate SymmCompletion (AAAI 2025) and Hyper-PCN (CVPR 2026) under the same GT-scale-free and GT-scale-tied protocols as Table 1. Under the GT-scale-free setting, both baselines use our estimated scales for normalization, consistent with the original comparisons. The additional baseline results have been incorporated into Sec. 3.1 (Table 1) of the revised paper.
The results are reported below, with each entry corresponding to GT-scale-free / GT-scale-tied.
ScaleBlind achieves the best overall performance across all three metrics under both protocols. Under GT-scale-free evaluation, its CD-Avg is 6.21, compared with 6.76 for Hyper-PCN and 6.83 for SymmCompletion.
A: We additionally retrain five representative baselines (AdaPoinTr, SVDFormer, CRA-PCN, GeoFormer, and PCDreamer) from scratch using partial-only normalization during both training and testing, eliminating the train–test normalization mismatch. We compare these results with the GT-scale-free results in Table 1, where the baselines use our estimated scales, to distinguish the benefits of scale information and the completion framework.
For each baseline, the two values correspond to Partial-only-Retrained) / With-Our-Scale (Table 1), respectively. ScaleBlind is evaluated under its original GT-scale-free setting. We only report the average CD, DCD, and F1 in the following, the full numbers can be found in Appendix F.7 (Table F4).
Result interpretation: Comparing ScaleBlind with baselines using our estimated scales (With-Our-Scale) reveals the advantage of our prior-guided completion framework under shared scale information. Comparing ScaleBlind with baselines retrained under partial-only normalization (Partial-only-Rerained) reflects the combined benefits of scale estimation and completion. The difference between Partial-only-Retrained and With-Our-Scale further indicates the benefit that our estimated scales provide to conventional completion methods.
In general, across all three metrics, ScaleBlind obtains the best performance against all baselines. Particularly, the gain comes primarily from the scale estimation mechanism.
Take PCDreamer as an example, ScaleBlind reduces CD-Avg from 7.05 to 6.21 (11.9% reduction), demonstrating the advantage of our prior-guided completion framework. ScaleBlind achieves a larger CD reduction from 9.73 to 6.21 (36.2% reduction) compared with the Partial-only-Retrained version, reflecting the combined benefits of scale estimation and prior-guided completion. The difference between these two improvements (3.52 − 0.84 = 2.68) provides an approximate indication of the benefit associated with our estimated scale. These results highlight the complementary contributions of scale recovery and the completion framework.