- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents LiMamba, a diffusion model for LiDAR scene completion that combines a sparse convolutional backbone with Mamba blocks to capture broader spatial context. Its main idea is to process point features in three parallel orders—Z-order, radial, and azimuth—so that each branch captures different spatial relationships. Learned gates fuse the branches, while scan dropout encourages the model to use multiple views. Experiments show improved completion quality on SemanticKITTI and zero-shot transfer to KITTI-360.
Critical strengths
1.The diffusion-only gains are convincing: 0.1 m IoU rises from LiDPM’s 6.3 to 8.5. The range analysis also shows larger gains far from the sensor, where completion is harder. 2. The scan, dropout, fusion, and placement ablations are helpful. Zero-shot transfer and separate training/inference cost reports make the evaluation more useful.
Critical weaknesses
1.The benefit of physically motivated scans is not fully isolated. The claimed capacity matching lacks per-variant details, and there is no repeated-order, three-branch control. The gains could partly come from extra branches rather than the chosen geometry. 2. The overall advantage is mixed. After refinement, 0.1 m IoU trails LiDPM (11.3 vs. 14.9), while sampling is slower (29.2 vs. 26.4 s). Windowed attention has no accuracy comparison, so its timing alone cannot establish a better accuracy–cost trade-off. 3. The claim that scan dropout prevents gate collapse lacks direct evidence. Table 6 shows better completion scores, but no gate-weight statistics or training curves. This supports dropout’s usefulness, not the proposed explanation. 4. The ablations use only 100 validation scans, with no reported variation across training seeds. Several differences are small, so it is hard to tell whether the preferred dropout rate and fusion design are consistently better.
Questions for authors
1.How were parameters and FLOPs matched within 2% across the ablations? Please provide the actual configurations and counts. 2. Was windowed attention used at all four deep stages or only enc3/enc4, as Table 10 states? Is completion accuracy available under the same protocol?