- Rating
- 4(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes the "Compact Local, Abstract Global" (CLAG) representation principle for 3D point cloud representation using SNNs. Originally, this idea is inspired by The Hilbert–Schmidt Independence Criterion as a unified metric of nonlinear dependency. The author proposed two complementary methods: HSTC, which performs token compression based on SVD spectral analysis and an adaptive token budget, together with an HSIC consistency constraint; and NAAB, which performs HSIC dependency suppression together with a diversity mechanism anchored by entropy and kernel density. Experiments cover classification, segmentation, and detection tasks on five datasets: ModelNet10/40, ScanObjectNN, SemanticKITTI, and KITTI, as long as report low-data and ablation results. The paper also provides duality/complementary slackness analysis, generalization bounds, and sample complexity analysis.
Critical strengths
- Using HSIC as a unified measure of nonlinear dependency and pointing out that dependency should be regulated in opposite directions at the local and global scales is more reasonable than "uniform compression" or "uniform preservation", which are usuallt applied by many prior works. Proofs show that HSTC combines spectral analysis, adaptive budgeting, saliency, and batch-level structural consistency. While NAAB simultaneously considers dependency suppression and representation diversity, avoiding collapse caused by merely minimizing HSIC. (Importance: 9/10)
- The supplementary analysis regarding the duality and generalization bounds of the proposed CLAG contributes positively to the study of representation learning in SNNs. (Importance: 8/10)
- Experiments show that this approach is quite powerful for 3D tasks, beating up the trending methods like E-3DSNN and SpikingPointMamba. (Importance: 6/10)
Critical weaknesses
- Regarding the relationship between local enhancement of nonlinear dependence and high-level reduction of nonlinear dependence and the biological visual system, the author only uses the hierarchical structure of the primary visual cortex as an analogy, without delving into the functional organization mechanism of the relevant division of labor in the visual nervous system. (Importance: 9/10)
- Neither the manuscript nor the supp. material provides experimental visualization results for the actual model, making it difficult to intuitively gauge the model's performance. (Importance: 8/10)
Questions for authors
Clarification requests:
- Please provide more biological evidence to support the core idea of the paper: Is bio-CNS appear similar behavior that preserves non linear dependencies before and after compression at the local scale, and suppresses it between inputs and spiking features at the global scale?
Suggestions for this and future work:
- The authors did not provide a comparison of model parameter counts in the experiments section, just accuracy, FPS and theoretical energy, which is inappropriate for fair comparison.
- The layout of Figure 1 is overly cluttered, and the curves on the right-hand side are not explained in the figure legend. Furthermore, Figure 1 is not cited anywhere in the main text.
- The ablation study only reports results, but the efficiency differences between “HSTC only” and “NAAB only” are not explained in the main text. It is recommended to add analysis of these differences.
- Typos that needs checking: inconsistently uses “3D point-cloud” and “3D point cloud” in the title and main text;
- Recommended to add a unified notation table in the appendix. The paper introduces a large number of symbols, such as ,, and . Although some symbols are defined when they first appear, they are scattered across the main text and appendix, resulting in poor readability.
3 comments
Response
I appreciate the authors‘ response. When I said that I asked for more visualization results, I actually mean the visualization of the Segmentation tasks, since the visual aid speaks for itself. I'll raise my score for most of my concerns are addressed in the new version manuscript.
Response to Reviewer uAMZ
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the clarification. We apologize for the misunderstanding regarding the visualization results. We fully agree that visual comparisons speak for themselves for the semantic segmentation task on SemanticKITTI. We will include these visualizations in our revised manuscript. We greatly appreciate your constructive suggestions.
Response to Reviewer uAMZ: Strengthened Biological Grounding, Added Visualizations, and Fair Parameter Comparison
We sincerely thank the reviewer for providing the most constructive feedback among the three reviews. Your insightful comments have significantly helped us improve the quality of this manuscript.
W1 & C1: We have expanded the theoretical foundation by incorporating functional theories such as Predictive Coding and Information Bottleneck, rather than relying solely on anatomical analogies. We have refined the Introduction to explicitly state that CLAG is a computational principle. Additionally, we have refined the theoretical derivations.
W2 : We have added a t-SNE visualization in Appendix J (Fig. 3) to intuitively demonstrate the evolution from entangled input representations to highly separated latent semantic clusters, effectively showcasing the performance of our method.
S1 :We have added a parameter comparison. CLAG-SNN has 1,875,536 parameters, while the E-3DSNN baseline has 1,874,216. The increase of exactly 1,320 parameters is solely due to the auxiliary classification head. HSTC is parameter-free, and NAAB's only trainable addition is this auxiliary head. The modules change where computation is spent, not the parameter count.
S3 :We have added a detailed analysis of the ablation study in the main text. HSTC physically reduces the token count to achieve a substantial FPS gain. NAAB does not alter the token count but reduces power consumption and improves accuracy by suppressing redundancy. The combination achieves both spatial and temporal efficiency.
S2, S4, S5 : We have completely redrawn Figure 1, properly cited it in the text with detailed legends, added a comprehensive notation table in Appendix I (Table 13), and thoroughly proofread the manuscript to standardize terminology (e.g., "3D point cloud").
We believe these rigorous revisions have substantially improved the theoretical soundness, experimental transparency, and practical value of this work. We sincerely thank the reviewer for the guidance that elevated the quality of this paper.