- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper asks where spike generation should sit relative to neighbourhood max aggregation when converting DGCNN’s EdgeConv into a spiking point-cloud network. It argues that spiking each edge response and then taking a max (Spike-before-Max) destroys the neighbour competition that makes EdgeConv work, and it proposes a Max-First rule that takes the channel-wise max of continuous edge features before the spike nonlinearity. A second module, APTEC, avoids unrolling dynamic graph construction over true timesteps by repeating a feature across a short pseudo-time window, integrating it with a leaky spiking neuron, applying an input-dependent threshold adapted from membrane-potential rectification, and compressing the window with a logical OR.
Validation is on ModelNet10/40, ScanObjectNN, and ShapeNetPart, with S3DIS in the appendix. The main accuracy jump comes from Max-First: on ModelNet40, Spike-before-Max scores 79.09% (T=1) and 84.11% (T=4), while Max-First real-temporal scoring reaches 91.77% and 92.18%. The full APTEC model (1.8M parameters, T=4) reaches 92.38% on ModelNet40 and 85.1% instance mIoU on ShapeNetPart, close to ANN DGCNN (92.9% and 85.2%), and the authors estimate energy at 0.22 mJ versus 11.23 mJ for DGCNN. On S3DIS, Max-First also helps, but APTEC (42.23% mIoU) falls well behind real-temporal Max-First (50.03%, against DGCNN at 51.51%).
Critical strengths
The Max-First ablation isolates a large, recurring failure of naive spiking conversion. Replacing Spike-before-Max with neighbourhood max before the spike raises ModelNet40 from 79.09% to 91.77% at T=1 and from 84.11% to 92.18% at T=4 (Table 3), with the same direction of effect on ModelNet10 and ScanObjectNN PB-T50-RS. The appendix repeats the pattern on S3DIS: 38.38% to 48.18% mIoU at T=1, and 42.01% to 50.03% at T=4 under real-temporal processing (Table 8). This is consequential because the comparison holds the backbone fixed and changes operator order, so the gain is not an artifact of a larger Transformer or Mamba. It is the result that could justify a paper even if the rest of the system were scaled back.
The paper reports where its temporal shortcut fails. APTEC is not uniformly declared a win. Table 8 shows real-temporal Max-First within 1.5 points of DGCNN on S3DIS, while pseudo-temporal compression drops to 42.23%. That split makes the ModelNet results readable: most of the recovered accuracy is the ordering rule, and pseudo-time is a task-dependent approximation. I weigh this more heavily than the absolute ModelNet numbers, which sit on a saturated benchmark.
Critical weaknesses
- How is FPS-KNN deployed using asynchronous hardware during inference?
- Table 1 should cite the source paper for each compared method. The baselines are also not current; the paper should at least report performance against related work published at ICLR 2026.
Questions for authors
See the Weaknesses.