- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper provides a reasonable motivation for using wavelets to decompose the process of completing point clouds into coarse features (overall geometric structure) and fine features (including object edges and noise). The two features interact with each other to achieve more accurate completion. Comparative experiments show that this method performs best, and ablation studies also demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed module. The writing of the paper is clear and easy to read, and the entire process is also clear and easy to reproduce. However, the performance improvement of this paper on the ScanNet dataset is limited. Considering that ScanNet is a dataset composed of real-world data, it is necessary to analyze the reasons for the limited performance improvement. In addition, the ablation experiment for fine->coarse interaction only verified that the weight change is limited to 0.15-0.75, without verifying the case of no fine->coarse interaction (weight=0).
Critical strengths
-
Well-motivated architecture. Explicit frequency decomposition and coarse<->fine interaction provide an intuitive framework for coordinating global structure and local detail recovery.
-
Strong synthetic benchmark results. Proposed method improves over baselines on both known-category and unseen-category synthetic shape completion benchmarks.
-
Informative ablation studies. Component ablations support the effectiveness of cross-stream interaction, joint attention, and persistent observation conditioning.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited gains on real scans. Improvements on ScanNet are small, providing limited evidence of robustness to real-world degradation. Further analysis of these modest gains is needed.
-
Limited evaluation of ambiguity. A incomplete input may correspond to multiple reasonable geometric structures, and using CD alone to measure the accuracy of completion is insufficient.
-
Limited fine->coarse ablation. The ablation experiment for fine->coarse interaction only verified that the weight change is limited to 0.15-0.75, without verifying the case of no fine->coarse interaction (weight=0).
Questions for authors
-
Could the authors analyze why the gains on ScanNet are limited and discuss the robustness of the proposed method to real-world degradation?
-
How does the method handle ambiguity when an incomplete input corresponds to multiple reasonable geometric structures? Could the authors provide evaluation beyond CD and IoU to assess these alternatives?
-
Could the authors add an ablation with the fine->coarse interaction weight set to 0, while keeping coarse->fine interaction and other components unchanged, to isolate the contribution of fine->coarse interaction?
-
Could the authors clarify whether PRISM and baselines, particularly BridgeShape, use comparable data augmentation and training settings?
-
Could the authors provide direct visual comparisons with the strongest baseline, BridgeShape, on the same inputs to demonstrate differences in overall structure and fine details?
5 comments
3. Ablation Removing High→Low Feedback (W3; Q3)
The ablations in the main text (Table 4) already validate the role of cross-band interaction, while Table 7 examines sensitivity to the feedback coefficient; based on these results, we selected 0.25 as the High→Low coefficient. We further trained under the same settings, setting only the High→Low interaction coefficient to 0. The results are shown below.
| High→Low coefficient | CD ↓ | IoU ↑ |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | 3.863 | 70.879 |
| 0.25 | 3.603 | 72.951 |
The results show that detail feedback helps recover coarse structure. We will add this comparison to §4.3 and Appendix D.1.
4. Comparability of Data Augmentation and Training Settings (Q4)
BridgeShape reports a bridge training budget of 200k steps, using a batch size of 24, AdamW, and a learning rate of . PRISM uses the same batch size, optimizer, and learning rate for bridge training on ShapeNet, with a training budget of 100k steps.
Regarding data augmentation, the code released by BridgeShape only targets EPN, on which neither the public implementation of PRISM nor that of BridgeShape enables spatial data augmentation. For ShapeNet training, recent baselines such as BridgeShape and DiffComplete have not released their corresponding data augmentation procedures, whereas the public implementation of PatchComplete explicitly uses random flips, x/z-axis swaps, and ±2-voxel jitter.
We compare data augmentation on ShapeNet in Appendix D.3 (Table 10), with the following results.
| ShapeNet augmentation setting | CD ↓ | IoU ↑ |
|---|---|---|
| No Aug. | 4.117 | 67.944 |
| Yaw-4 only | 3.616 | 71.982 |
| PC-Aug | 3.599 | 72.952 |
The results show that even when retaining only Yaw-4 and removing PC-Aug, PRISM still achieves 3.616/71.982, outperforming BridgeShape’s 4.06/70.1 in Table 2. This indicates that the gains do not depend entirely on PC-Aug.
5. Visual Comparison with BridgeShape on the Same Inputs (Q5)
Figure 4 and Appendix H of the original manuscript already show structure and detail recovery across datasets and categories. Since BridgeShape has not yet provided the corresponding pretrained weights, a fair visual comparison of the final outputs is difficult.
Thank you for the responses and additional experiments. The fine->coarse weight=0 ablation resolves my concern, and I accept the explanation regarding the unavailable BridgeShape pretrained weights. The following concerns remain:
1. Limited gains on real scans. Adjusting the endpoint noise yields only modest gains on ScanNet, and the response does not explain why this adjustment improves performance. In addition, the main concern is the limited improvement on real-world data, rather than robustness to noise. Additional experiments with predefined synthetic noise do not directly address this concern.
2. Limited evaluation of ambiguity. An incomplete input may admit multiple reasonable completions. My concern is how plausible completions that differ from the ground-truth shape are evaluated (current metrics are insufficient to evaluate this issue). Reporting sample diversity and average reconstruction quality does not directly address this issue.
4. Training comparability. The clarified settings and Yaw-4 results partially address my concern. However, Yaw-4 is still data augmentation, and BridgeShape’s corresponding settings remain unclear, leaving the effects of architecture and augmentation insufficiently separated.
Thank you for recognizing the architectural motivation and experimental results, and for your constructive suggestions. Below, we address real-scan performance, completion ambiguity, interaction ablations, and comparison settings.
1. ScanNet Gains and Robustness to Real-World Degradations (W1; Q1)
The original manuscript already evaluates naturally occurring mixed degradations. Specifically, §4.1 explicitly states that ScanNet inputs simultaneously contain sensor noise, background clutter, and extreme sparsity, and Table 3 reports the corresponding quantitative results.
Since BridgeShape has not fully released the corresponding ScanNet training and evaluation configurations, we uniformly use zero endpoint noise across all datasets in the main text in the absence of directly reusable parameters. Testing different endpoint-noise levels on ScanNet with a fixed model and three sampling seeds shows that an endpoint-noise level of 0.5 further improves the average CD/IoU, indicating that moderate endpoint perturbations help recovery from real observations.
We will also add the complete endpoint-noise ablation results to the appendix.
We further conducted experiments with coordinate perturbations, structural interference, missing observations, and field-value noise on the full ShapeNet test set. For each operator, a subtype and a strength level are randomly selected and applied, as specified below.
The single-operator experiments apply G, C, O, and N separately; the mixed-degradation experiment applies each of the four operators once to every input, with a randomized order. The results are shown below.
2. Evaluation Metrics and Multiple Plausible Completions (W2; Q2)
We follow the corresponding benchmarks in using CD/IoU and report occupancy F1 in the appendix to evaluate surface distance and occupancy overlap for a single completion. The supplementary evaluation on the full ScanNet test set under the same protocol additionally reports the surface F-score.
The default evaluation uses zero endpoint noise, yielding a deterministic completion for each input; enabling endpoint noise allows the same model to generate multiple results from different endpoints. Thus, although OT-ODE performs deterministic transport given an endpoint, random endpoints still induce a conditional distribution over outputs.
To examine this sampling mechanism, the supplementary experiments on the full ShapeNet and ScanNet test sets generate ten results per input and report both differences between samples and average reconstruction quality.
This table shows the controllable effect of endpoint noise on geometric diversity and recovery quality.