- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes GeoHaze, a geometry-conditioned spectral propagation framework for image dehazing. Building upon the damped-wave spectral operator introduced in WaveFormer, the proposed method incorporates monocular depth information through depth-conditioned initial velocity, wavelet-driven adaptive kinematics, and a geometry-gated frequency-decoupled decoder. Extensive experiments across natural and remote-sensing dehazing benchmarks demonstrate competitive performance.
Critical strengths
-
The paper addresses a meaningful problem concerning the reliability of monocular depth priors in image restoration.
-
The authors provide extensive architectural ablations, depth-corruption experiments, and implementation details.
Critical weaknesses
Weakeness 1
The authors emphasize the limitations of RGB-only image dehazing in the Introduction and Figure 1, suggesting that additional monocular depth guidance is important for structure-preserving restoration. However, this motivation is not sufficiently supported by the existing literature, as several RGB-only dehazing methods have already demonstrated substantially stronger performance on the same benchmarks.
For example, ConvIR [1] (TPAMI 2024) achieves PSNR values of 20.66 dB, 25.36 dB, and 22.44 dB on NH-HAZE, O-HAZE, and I-HAZE, respectively, outperforming GeoHaze (19.64 dB, 24.97 dB, and 19.14 dB) across all three datasets. Similarly, FocalNet [2] (ICCV 2023) achieves 20.43 dB on NH-HAZE and 25.50 dB on O-HAZE, while MB-TaylorFormer-v2 [3] (TPAMI 2025) reports 20.77 dB and 25.43 dB, respectively. Furthermore, Table 2 of MB-TaylorFormer-v2 includes several additional methods that achieve stronger results than those reported in Table 1 of this submission.
These observations raise two major concerns. First, the motivation regarding the inherent limitations of RGB-only dehazing appears overstated, since existing RGB-only approaches can achieve competitive or even superior restoration quality without explicit depth guidance. Second, the omission of these strong and well-established baselines makes the experimental comparisons incomplete and potentially misleading regarding the competitiveness of the proposed method.
While these results do not necessarily imply that depth guidance is ineffective, they substantially weaken the empirical justification for its necessity in the proposed framework. The authors should include comparisons with stronger RGB-only methods and provide more convincing evidence demonstrating the specific advantages of incorporating monocular depth guidance.
[1]Yuning Cui, Wenqi Ren, Xiaochun Cao, and Alois Knoll. Revitalizing convolutional network for image restoration. TPAMI, 2024.
[2]Yuning Cui, Wenqi Ren, Xiaochun Cao, and Alois Knoll. Focal network for image restoration. In ICCV, 2023.
[3]Jin, Zhi, et al. MB-TaylorFormer V2: Improved multi-branch linear transformer expanded by Taylor formula for image restoration. TPAMI, 2025.
Weakness 2
Equations (3)–(5) are overly concise and not sufficiently self-contained, with several mathematical notations left undefined or inadequately explained. Moreover, the formulation builds upon existing methods without clearly distinguishing the proposed contributions from prior work. As these equations describe the core methodology of GeoHaze, the insufficient explanations make it difficult to understand the technical details and identify the actual novelty of the proposed approach.
Questions for authors
- Clarification or experiments metioned from above Critical Weaknesses.
- Can the authors compare direct depth fusion and geometry-conditioned propagation within an identical architecture?
4 comments
2. Motivation of Depth Guidance
Concern: Section 1 and Fig. 1 suggest that RGB-only dehazing is inherently limited, yet strong RGB-only methods already restore these benchmarks well. Please provide more convincing, specific advantages of monocular depth inside the proposed framework.
Direct answer. We would like to clarify the motivation again here. The question is conditional: monocular geometry is already used by depth-assisted dehazers. We take a step further to ask how imperfect geometry should enter the network.
Within-architecture ablation. All depth branches removed; same backbone as Full:
| Dataset | RGB-only | Full | PSNR | SSIM | LPIPS | MSE |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| I-HAZE | 18.4800 | 19.1400 | ||||
| O-HAZE | 24.2400 | 24.9700 | ||||
| NH-HAZE | 18.9400 | 19.6400 |
Full improves all four metrics on each set. O/NH PSNR gains are only / dB above I-HAZE; we report an in-architecture depth-path benefit. On RW$^2$AH / RSID, shuffling depth costs / dB while is only / ; is lower than for SSDG. A clear-image DA3 depth proxy gains dB on RW$^2$AH (diagnostic only). Depth is used at test time.
Revision. We have revised Sec. 1 and Fig. 1(a) to clarify the conditional role of imperfect geometry.
3. Self-Containedness of Eqs. (3)–(5) and Relation to WaveFormer
Concern: Equations (3)–(5) are overly concise and not sufficiently self-contained, with several mathematical notations left undefined or inadequately explained ... the insufficient explanations make it difficult to understand the technical details and identify the actual novelty of the proposed approach.
Direct answer. We agree that the submitted Eqs. (3)–(5) were too compact to read as a self-contained method description. In the revision, each equation is tied to an explicit role so that the technical story and the novelty boundary are both clear. Conceptually: Eq. (3) defines the 2D damped-wave equation on the feature grid, with wave speed and damping ; Eq. (6) gives the projected spectral update. The GeoHaze-specific insight is that imperfect monocular depth should not overwrite appearance as fused content, but condition that carrier. Concretely, RGB alone forms the propagated state , while depth enters only as a gated drive ; sample-level are predicted from joint RGB–depth Haar statistics (WDKE); and the residual path after the spectral step stays RGB-gated, with depth reused only as bounded frequency gates in decoding (GFDB). Thus the novelty of GeoHaze is geometry-conditioned driving and cross-modal kinematics on top of an existing spectral wave engine, with RGB remaining the appearance carrier. Every symbol is now defined at first use in Secs. 3.1–3.2, with Algorithm 1 (Appendix A.4) giving one HWPB forward pass and tensor shapes, and Table 10 / Appendix A.3–A.5 listing the full contract (, , , , , , and the projected map).
4. Direct Depth Fusion vs. Geometry-Conditioned Propagation in One Architecture
Concern: Can the authors compare direct depth fusion and geometry-conditioned propagation within an identical architecture?
Direct answer. Yes. We replace only how depth enters the wave block, keeping backbone, WDKE/GFDB depth inputs, loss, and schedule fixed (shared panel with Reviewer rUxe).
Evidence.
| Dataset | Variant | PSNR | SSIM | LPIPS | MSE |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RSID | C0 (depth as gated drive) | 27.0900 | 0.9625 | 0.0287 | 0.002700 |
| RSID | C1 (RGB self-drive) | 26.5000 | 0.9540 | 0.0420 | 0.003093 |
| RSID | C2 (depth as state content) | 26.6300 | 0.9560 | 0.0385 | 0.003002 |
| RSID | C3 (concat replacement) | 26.5500 | 0.9548 | 0.0401 | 0.003057 |
| RSID | C4 (cross-attention replacement) | ||||
| RW$^2$AH | C0 | 22.4100 | 0.6610 | 0.3011 | 0.010600 |
| RW$^2$AH | C1 | 21.9300 | 0.6410 | 0.3240 | 0.011836 |
| RW$^2$AH | C2 |
C0 exceeds C2 by / dB (RSID / RW$^2$AH) and C4 by dB on RSID. Zero-velocity is not the RGB-drive control. Full four-metric results are provided in Table 29 of Appendix H.3. Under these matched replacements, gated-drive is stronger than the listed content-fusion alternatives.
We appreciate your constructive commments agian and sincerely hope this clarification addresses your concerns.
Response to rebuttal
I thank the authors for the detailed response and for taking the time to run additional experiments under a matched evaluation protocol. The rebuttal addresses most of my concerns, and the new comparisons with ConvIR, FocalNet, and MB-TaylorFormer-v2 show that GeoHaze is competitive on I-HAZE and O-HAZE. Given the modest PSNR gains over some baselines, I am still weighing whether the new results warrant raising my score. I will take the other reviewers’ assessments into account before finalizing my rating.
Dear Reviewer bTXe,
Thank you very much for your follow-up and for carefully reconsidering our submission. We sincerely appreciate your recognition that the matched comparisons address most of your concerns.
We acknowledge that the PSNR improvements on the natural haze benchmarks are modest and have revised the manuscript to avoid overstating performance. We would like to clarify once more here: Our main contribution is the geometry-conditioned interaction mechanism, which improves the same backbone over RGB-only and direct-fusion alternatives while remaining competitive across natural-image and remote-sensing settings.
For completeness, we have also corrected Appendix B.3 to clarify that GeoHaze and the newly evaluated baselines use the same tiled inference protocol at the original image resolution, without resizing or test-time augmentation.
We are grateful for your constructive comments, which have helped us improve the clarity and scope of the paper. If you have any remaining questions or concerns, we would be very happy to provide further clarification or address them.
Dear Reviewer bTXe,
Thank you for the constructive comments. We address your concerns below.
1. Strong RGB-only Baselines and Protocol Alignment
Direct answer. Thank you for the recommendation. We have added ConvIR, FocalNet, and MB-TaylorFormer V2 to the comparison and cited these works in the revised paper. We also identified and cited ArtIR (TIP 2026), whose efficient adaptive large-kernel design further supports our view that broad spatial context is important for image restoration. We disagree, however, with the claim that several RGB-only dehazing methods have already demonstrated substantially stronger performance on the same benchmarks, for three reasons: 1, PSNR alone does not comprehensively measure dehazing quality: structure, color cast, and perceptual detail matter, so we always report SSIM / LPIPS / MSE together with qualitative comparisons. 2, fair comparison requires a unified protocol; we retrain the listed RGB-only methods under our splits, crops, and tile inference next to GeoHaze, and the resulting scores can differ from the numbers reported in the original papers. 3, our goal is to show that introducing depth through the proposed gated-drive mechanism yields strong performance and cross-domain generalization on both natural-image and remote-sensing dehazing, whereas many existing methods remain strong mainly within a single domain.
Matched protocol. Published baselines and our setting differ in two ways: (1) train on all non-test images vs.\ our hold-outs (NH-HAZE 45/5/5; I-HAZE 25/5/5; O-HAZE 35/5/5); (2) our pipeline (384×384 crops, 512×512 tile inference) vs.\ release-specific full-resolution / resize. As a result, published ConvIR-B PSNR values you cite (22.44 / 25.36 / 20.66 dB on I/O/NH-HAZE) should therefore not be line-compared to Table 1. Under this unified protocol we retrain ConvIR-B, FocalNet, and MB-TaylorFormer-v2-L from official code for the I/O-HAZE comparison; absolute scores differ from the papers and are kept separate from the released-checkpoint reevaluation in Appendix H.2. Every entry below shares the same experimental setting:
GeoHaze exceeds ConvIR-B on I/O-HAZE in PSNR (+0.70 / +0.67 dB) and is strongest or second on SSIM / LPIPS / MSE. On O-HAZE, MB-TaylorFormer-v2-L remains higher in PSNR. Relative to published ConvIR-B on I-HAZE (19.14 vs 22.44), the gap remains large and is not attributed entirely to protocol. The released-weight and matched-retraining evaluations are kept separate in Appendix H.2. Structure-oriented gains inside our backbone are in Sec. 2 (T3), not a claim that RGB-only dehazing is inherently weak.
Remote sensing. We have also investigated their performance on RRSHID-thin:
Aa can be seen, GeoHaze leads this panel. Natural-haze PSNR advantages do not consistently transfer under this broader domain panel; geometry-conditioned GeoHaze stays strong on aerial RRSHID-thin.
Revision. We have included released-weight reevaluations in Tables 23–24 and matched-retraining results on I/O-HAZE and RRSHID-thin in Tables 25–26 in Appendix H.2 of the revised paper.