- Rating
- 4
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies the supervision ambiguity in unlabeled real-image dehazing: satisfying the atmospheric scattering reconstruction relation does not mean that the predicted transmission corresponds to the true scene behind the clear image; even enforcing consistency across different constructed views may retain a common absolute-state offset. The authors accordingly propose Relative-to-Absolute Supervision (R2AS), which separates the relative information that can be determined by controlled haze intervention from the absolute-state selection that requires prior guidance from a teacher.
Specifically, RSC performs relative calibration using the known optical depth differences between constructed views, combined with observation reconstruction constraints. ASA then projects the aligned multi-view teacher predictions onto a one-dimensional feasible set to obtain a shared absolute-state supervision target, and trains the student model via distillation. The paper provides a relative error bound and a conditional projection guarantee, and validates the method on four unpaired datasets and two paired datasets, together with experiments on modules, losses, the number of views, and atmospheric light perturbation.
Critical strengths
-
The authors do not equate reconstruction consistency with recovery correctness; instead, they separate the identifiable relative information from the prior-guided absolute selection. RSC and ASA each take on one of these responsibilities, so the problem analysis maps directly onto the training objective and the algorithmic pipeline. In my view, this decomposition of the supervision design is the paper's most commendable contribution.
-
The paper compares the baseline, RSC-only, ASA-only, and the full model, and further ablates the RSC losses, tests intervention strengths outside the training range, and analyzes the number of views and atmospheric light perturbation. The reduction in relative optical depth error and observation error means the experiments go beyond no-reference quality scores. The results on the paired datasets also provide supplementary support for the recovery quality.
Critical weaknesses
The overall contribution of ASA is supported, but the independent contribution of the projection operation relative to ordinary distillation and multi-view aggregation has not been fully isolated. The existing module ablations show that adding ASA improves several metrics, and the multi-view experiments show that adding teacher evidence is beneficial. However, ASA simultaneously involves teacher supervision, multi-view information integration, feasible-set projection, and additional student training. Therefore, the current results cannot yet fully distinguish which step the gains mainly come from.
Questions for authors
-
The existing anchoring-strength experiments cover multiple non-zero strengths, but do not yet directly show the corresponding result for no projection at all. With everything else held constant, how does the method perform when using the raw teacher targets, or only the aligned multi-view averaged targets?
-
The full model improves on several metrics, but, for example, TOPIQ on RTTS is lower than the RSC-only result. The authors have already reported this phenomenon. Can representative examples be analyzed to determine whether this corresponds to a trade-off in residual haze, color, texture, or contrast, so as to analyze the specific quality dimensions that ASA improves?
no response here
I didn't see a response here!