- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
Depth-free RGB-D. Uses a frozen depth estimation foundation model for transferring depth relative structure, multi-scale features and boundary information. Uses this for a geometry branch, then uses cross-modal enhancement. Finally, it is a distillation net, so distils this. Shows good results. Claims that RGB-D depth is not always high quality, and with repeated fusion can cause negative transfer. Main claims (non-results):
- Reformulate RGB-D SOD on RGB-Driven geometry learning avoiding depth-induced negative transfer at source rather than calibrating sensor depth after it enters detector.
- Multi-level distillation, cross modal enhancement and reliability aware fusion
- In related work under: reliable or unavailable depth - GeoDistill internalizes geometry in an RGB-Driven branch so neither sensor depth or external depth estimator is required at inference.
Critical strengths
- Results show good gains.
- The architecture is novel.
Critical weaknesses
Clarity on contribution and novelty of contribution. This paper makes many claims towards novelty, clouding the contribution. This makes it hard to pick apart what the actual contributions are. As such this review examines the claims specifically from the summary above.
3 &2) reliability aware fusion: This idea is well-established. For example, fully-published before this conference due date: Channel-Wise Contribution Assessment for RGB-D Salient Object Detection, Cheng, et al, ACM Transactions on Multimedia Computing, Communications and Applications, Volume 22, Issue 8, 2026. Cheng et al directly uses reliability aware fusion for RGB-D. More generally, This type of reliability/uncertainty/error driven training idea in SOD/COD has a long history, for example, Modeling aleatoric uncertainty for camouflaged object detection, Liu, et al, WACV 2022. 2) Distillation itself in SOD is not novel and is well-known: eg., Self-distillation salient object detection via generalized diversity loss, Yunfei Zheng, Pattern Recognition, 2025.
1 & 4) The core claim of the paper is around using RGB-D at training time and RGB only at test time with some type of distillation. This has been commonly done with train time only branches. This is a long-established topic, early papers that have depth supervision at training time to improve the performance of RGB only SOD at test time include: RGB-D Salient Object Detection with Ubiquitous Target Awareness, Y Zhao 2021, ARXIV; and, Is depth really necessary for salient object detection? Zhao et al, ACM Multimedia 2020.
The difference that the authors seem to be drawing towards is that the network does not supervise using the depth directly. The implication is that the depth supervision is not direct. Here in the literature review the authors contrast with SATNet. Where the estimated depth map enters as an explicit modality. The difference claimed here in Fig 1 is to distil and use geometry teaching rather than use Depth Ground truth and learn depth estimation. Yet depth is shown as a direct training input from Depth Anything V2 in the top of Fig 2, and the network directly uses Depth Anything V2 features. This is slightly indirect depth supervision – the difference is not very strong from above. Yes, the network also uses distillation and edges (Taken directly from Ye 2025), but this does not appear to be the only place where depth features are available directly to the network. So although the Geometry branch trains RGB based features, they are supervised directly from a depth network at training time (not conceptually different to Zhao et al 2020 and Zhao et al 2021. So rather than a conceptual difference this difference seems mostly an internal architectural difference as the inputs are the same, and overall the network has direct access to depth feature supervision at training time.
Questions for authors
The key question is whether this is a misunderstanding of the paper, that there is a strong conceptual difference from the background literature in terms of the manner in which depth supervision (estimated or otherwise) is being used at training time to distill an RGB only network for SOD at test time. Or whether it is an architectural difference. I cannot see evidence that there is a strong conceptual novelty from prior work in SOD.
3 comments
Summary?
So, not RGB-only. Using Depth Anything V2 within the learning loop as SgFx points out. Not using explicit depth as explicit supervision, or using foundation model generated depth directly as supervision, but using Depth Anything V2 within the learning so that foundation model generated depth is available within the overall learning pipeline? The difference you point to is using "geometry" - features from the foundation model, rather than its output, which is depth? - "replacing target-dataset measured-depth supervision with foundation-guided, SOD-adapted geometry".
Also, as SgFx points out, always ignoring sensor depth as the premise, rather than considering where to replace it? -
Thank you for following up. We agree our wording blurred depth-guided training and RGB-only inference.
1. What enters the learning pipeline? DA-V2 is a frozen, training-only teacher. During SOD training, it takes RGB—not measured depth—as input and provides four encoder features, predicted relative depth, and derived boundaries. The student uses both feature distillation and auxiliary depth/boundary supervision. The depth shown in Fig. 2 is the teacher's prediction, not sensor input. Neither measured depth nor DA-V2 is needed at inference. Our setting is no target-dataset sensor-depth supervision and RGB-only inference, not training without depth-derived knowledge.
2. Are “geometry features” simply depth features? We claim neither a new feature type nor that DA-V2 encoder features contain geometry exclusively. “Geometry” denotes depth-specialized structural knowledge adapted to SOD. The final model combines feature distillation with depth-output supervision; it does not replace the latter entirely. Table 4(b) shows that, with DA-V2 fixed, feature-only exceeds output-only supervision on SIP (: .907 vs. .893; MAE: .036 vs. .042). Under matched feature-only settings, DA-V2 also exceeds plain DINOv2 (SIP MAE: .036 vs. .039), supporting the usefulness of depth-specialized representations. Crucially, direct DA-V2 feature fusion underperforms the task-adapted geometry student (Table 4(d), SIP : .898 vs. .912). The contribution is therefore not merely accessing DA-V2 features, but transferring and adapting them for saliency. We do not claim distillation itself is new.
3. Why always omit measured depth? This is a deployment constraint, not a claim of universal optimality. Selective RGB-D fusion is valid when depth is available, but requires that input and judgments about its usefulness. We study the complementary setting without these requirements. Our new analysis reveals the trade-off: on Worst-1000, GeoDistill achieves =.752 versus .719 for the strongest RGB-D baseline; on high-usefulness subsets, RGB-D methods slightly outperform ours. We do not claim ignoring reliable depth is always better.
Our contribution is a tested method for learning SOD-adapted representations from depth-foundation guidance without measured depth in target SOD datasets, not a new RGB-only inference paradigm or definition of geometry. We will clarify this and Fig. 2. We are confident that our work makes a meaningful contribution to the field and will inspire further research into sensor-depth-independent, task-adaptive geometry learning for SOD.
Clarifying the Core Novelty and Providing Evidence for Task-Adaptive Geometry Distillation
We thank the reviewer for this critique. We agree that depth-assisted training with RGB-only inference (Zhao et al., 2020, 2021), distillation, reliability-guided fusion, and edge-aware decoding are not individually new. Our presentation blurred this distinction. We do not claim to invent these ingredients or RGB-only inference. We instead focus on acquiring and using geometry for SOD without dataset sensor-depth supervision.
1. What differs from prior depth-assisted SOD?
Zhao et al. (2020, 2021) use measured depth from RGB-D training sets as supervision and remove it at inference. Our SOD training uses RGB-mask pairs, not their measured depth. A frozen Depth Anything V2 (DA-V2) model processes RGB and provides relative-depth outputs, intermediate encoder features, and boundaries as training targets. This is depth-related supervision, not learning without prior depth knowledge. The difference is the source and form of supervision: pretrained geometric priors rather than measured target-dataset depth labels.
SATNet substitutes Depth Anything pseudo-depth but still feeds an estimated depth map to its detector. GeoDistill internalizes teacher knowledge in an RGB-driven geometry branch; neither sensor depth nor a running depth estimator is needed at inference. Retraining on RGB-only DUTS-TR further demonstrates this flexibility.
In Fig. 2, the frozen teacher receives RGB; the depth shown is its prediction, not observed depth fed to the student. Fig. 1 contrasts measured-depth and foundation-teacher supervision, not the absence of all depth-derived knowledge.
2. Why is this more than swapping depth labels?
Our geometry branch learns from complementary output, feature, and boundary targets while being optimized for SOD. Feature interaction and a learned gate regulate where geometry influences saliency. Neither distillation nor gating is claimed as a new primitive.
The cited 2026 channel-wise contribution work regulates observed RGB-D modalities, whereas our fusion regulates RGB-derived geometry. We also acknowledge that AETP/ESC decoding primitives originate from Ye et al. (2025).
Our contribution is the task-adaptive acquisition and utilization of foundation geometry without target-dataset depth, not a new theory of distillation, uncertainty, or fusion.
3. What experimental evidence supports this distinction?
Revised Table 4 isolates five design choices:
(a) Supervision source: On SIP, DA-V2 output supervision improves Sm from .886 (unsupervised geometry branch) to .893, whereas measured GT-depth supervision reaches .887. This supports foundation geometry over directly reproducing measured depth.
(b) Knowledge representation: With DA-V2 fixed, feature-only distillation improves SIP Sm/MAE from .893/.042 (output-only) to .907/.036; combining both reaches .912/.033. Thus, our transfer is more effective than simply reproducing pseudo-depth.
(c) Teacher knowledge: Under matched feature-only distillation, DA-V2 encoder features outperform plain DINOv2 on SIP (Sm: .907 vs. .905; MAE: .036 vs. .039), also improving DUT-RGBD and COME-H. This supports depth-specialized representations beyond generic visual features, although pretraining data differences may contribute.
(d) Task adaptation: Direct DA-V2 feature fusion is weaker than geometry-student distillation (SIP Sm: .898 vs. .912), demonstrating the benefit of adapting teacher representations to SOD.
(e) Geometry utilization: Replacing reliability-aware fusion with Concat increases SIP MAE from .033 to .038, validating our fusion design without claiming conceptual novelty for reliability gating.
The new depth-cue analysis further clarifies our scope. On the 1,000 samples with the least useful depth cues, GeoDistill achieves Sm=.752 versus .719 for the strongest RGB-D competitor. Conversely, RGB-D methods slightly outperform ours when depth is informative. This supports avoiding dependence on unreliable or uninformative depth, not assuming all sensor depth is harmful.
In summary, our novelty is not RGB-only inference, distillation, reliability gating, or decoder primitives individually. It lies in replacing target-dataset measured-depth supervision with foundation-guided, SOD-adapted geometry and selectively utilizing it without external depth at inference. The new supervision, teacher, transfer, and fusion controls substantiate this method-level contribution. We will revise our contribution statements and figure labels accordingly.