- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a zero-shot denoising method focusing on directionally persistent structured noise (DPSN) removal. This approach transforms noisy image into Fourier domain and uses the prior knowledge of the noise direction to locate the wedge region of possible corruption, and then uses GNN to reconstruct and recover the frequency coefficients. Additionally, this paper proposes to use directional gradient readout, anisotropic resampling, and residual transfer to preserve image structures and details. The experiments show that this approach achieves improvements on synthetic stripe noise. The method is also evaluated on real data through qualitative comparisons and the absolute correlation metric.
Critical strengths
- The problem of stripe noise removal has practical significance, and the method also uses a relatively reasonable structural prior. Transforming directionally structured noise to the Fourier domain for targeted restoration is intuitive.
- The synthetic experiments are relatively comprehensive and the performance on synthetic data is also good.
Critical weaknesses
- The real contributions of this paper are not clearly presented. Specifically, the first contribution presented in the Introduction largely overlaps with previous work DeStripe, which has proposed to use Fourier-domain GNN to recover frequency coefficients for stripe noise without clean data. Although this paper added some extensions and discussed the differences in the appendix, it doesn’t sufficiently clarify the limitations of DeStripe and how the proposed designs address them, and whether these extensions are novel. Therefore, the contribution, motivation and novelty of this paper are unclear.
- Experimental results have not sufficiently demonstrated the superiority of this method. For synthetic data, PSNR is only calculated on corrupted regions, and the full-image PSNR seems to be ignored. For real data, although some qualitative results show some improvements, the advantages are still not obvious and sufficient. The quantitative results mainly rely on absolute correlation which cannot directly reflect the stripe noise removal or the preservation of image structures. Additional no-reference metrics for stripe removal or other evaluation metrics suitable for scientific images would help.
Questions for authors
- What’s the major limitation of DeStripe and how does this paper address it? Could you clarify the main new contributions compared with DeStripe and how these changes improve the results?
- Could you report full-image PSNR for synthetic data and provide more quantitative results on real data?
- According to Eq.2, all non-DC coefficients within radius of 32 are marked as corrupted. But in Sec 3.2, the reference nodes should be uncorrupted and have a radial bandwidth of 5. Therefore, for corrupted nodes with a radius of at most 27, the reference set seems to be empty? How are these nodes handled in the implementation?