- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes the Degradation Frequency Curve (DFC), an explicit spectral representation that describes image degradation using band-wise residual-to-degraded energy ratios. Based on DFC, the authors develop DFC-IR, which converts scale-specific degradation curves into spectral tokens and uses them to guide coarse-to-fine image restoration. The method aims to improve restoration under single, composite, and unseen degradation conditions without requiring degradation labels during inference. Experiments on standard all-in-one benchmarks, composite degradations, unseen tasks, and real-world images show competitive performance, while the ablation studies and quantitative analyses support the effectiveness of the proposed degradation representation.
Critical strengths
The paper provides a meaningful new perspective on degradation modeling. Instead of representing degradation implicitly through features or prompts, it models degradation as an explicit frequency curve that can be measured, compared, and decomposed into reusable spectral tokens.
Critical weaknesses
-
DFC depends on intermediate restoration quality during inference. Since clean images are unavailable, inaccurate early restoration results may lead to inaccurate DFC estimation, especially for unseen or complex degradations.
-
The analysis of DFC properties is limited. Its content robustness and degradation sensitivity are mainly validated on synthetic haze, rain, and noise, without equivalent analysis for blur, low-light, snow, or composite degradations.
Questions for authors
-
DFC construction and training supervision rely on clean ground-truth images. In real-world datasets, the ground truth may contain noise, misalignment, or remaining degradation, so the robustness of DFC-IR to imperfect ground truth is unclear.
-
During inference, DFC is estimated from intermediate restoration results. It remains unclear how estimation errors from early stages affect the subsequent restoration process, especially under unseen degradations.
4 comments
Response to reviewer obes (Q1)
[Q1] Impact of Imperfect Ground Truth
We clarify that the DFCs used for restoration guidance during both training and inference are estimated from degraded images and intermediate restorations rather than directly constructed from ground truth. If real-world datasets are used only for zero-shot evaluation without training or fine-tuning, imperfections in their ground truth do not affect DFC estimation or the restoration process. However, if imperfect ground truth is used for training, it may affect supervision and potentially influence restoration performance. This is a common challenge for supervised image restoration methods. Investigating robustness to imperfect training targets remains an important direction for future work.
We sincerely appreciate the careful thought behind your comments and your recognition of the value of explicit frequency-based degradation modeling. Your questions encouraged us to more directly investigate how early-stage DFC estimation affects subsequent restoration, extend the analysis of DFC properties to a broader range of degradations, and clarify the impact of imperfect ground truth. These additional analyses and clarifications have strengthened the experimental foundation of our work and made our discussion more comprehensive and rigorous. We are truly grateful for your constructive guidance in improving our paper. We hope the new evidence and clarifications address your concerns and would sincerely appreciate it if you could reconsider your assessment.
The authors' response has addressed my concerns. Therefore, I have decided to maintain my original score.
We are pleased that our response has addressed your concerns. We sincerely appreciate your thoughtful review and constructive suggestions, which have helped us strengthen our analysis and improve the manuscript. Thank you again for your time and consideration.
Response to reviewer obes (W1, W2, Q2)
We sincerely appreciate your insightful comments and questions, which have greatly contributed to improving our work. We address your concerns as follows.
[W1, Q2] Impact of Early-Stage DFC Estimation Errors on Subsequent Restoration
We evaluate the impact of early-stage DFC estimation errors on subsequent restoration under unseen degradations (UIEB and CSD) using the pretrained five-degradation model. Specifically, we control the DFC estimation error at the early decoding stage (s2) by interpolating between the estimated and reference DFCs:
Dλs2=(1−λ)Dests2+λDrefs2,
while the subsequent stage (s1) estimates its DFC normally without intervention. The scale-wise DFC errors and restoration PSNR are reported below.
Tab. R4-1. Effect of Early-Stage DFC Estimation Errors on Subsequent Restoration under Unseen Degradations.
The results show that reducing early-stage DFC estimation errors improves subsequent estimation accuracy and restoration performance on both UIEB and CSD. This confirms that more accurate early-stage DFC guidance leads to better subsequent restoration under unseen degradations.
[W2] Analysis of DFC Properties across More Degradation Types
We extend the DFC property analysis to blur, low-light, snow, and composite haze+snow degradations on the MiO100, visualizing the mean normalized DFC profiles with standard deviation bands. Within each degradation, the standard deviation bands remain narrow , while the mean normalized DFC profiles differ across degradation types. The extended visualizations are provided in Fig. 12 (Appendix B.5) of the revision.
We further conduct a quantitative analysis of DFC's content robustness and degradation sensitivity across all seven degradation types using the Wasserstein-1 distance. The results are reported below.
Tab. R4-2. Within- and Between-Degradation Wasserstein-1 Distances across Seven Degradation Types.
The results show that the between-degradation distance consistently exceeds the within-degradation distance across all seven degradation types, with averages of 0.1486 and 0.0351, respectively, yielding a separation ratio of 4.23. These results provide additional evidence for the content robustness and degradation sensitivity of DFC. We have added this analysis to Table 17 (Appendix B.5) of the revision.