- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents UniLens, a unified framework for real-world all-in-one image restoration that includes data construction, instruction-conditioned adaptation, and task-conditioned evaluation. The proposed CODE encoder considers both content and degradation ordering supervision to identify degradation gaps to guide dataset construction process. Three routes are proposed, including offline construction, online synthesis, and retrieval, which are used to close the degradation distribution gap from real-world degradations. Single, joint, and selective degradation removal are all included. Experiments across multiple public benchmarks demonstrate promising results.
Critical strengths
- The paper presents a real-world data-construction pipeline for all-in-one image restoration, aiming to reduce the gap of degradation distribution between conventional synthetic training data and real-world images.
- The restoration experiments include single, composite, and selective degradation removal. The evaluation covers an extensive range of public benchmarks and demonstrates promising overall performance.
Critical weaknesses
- The choice of LPIPS for ordinal supervision requires further justification. Did the authors consider alternative perceptual metrics or degradation-specific statistics? It would be helpful to establish whether LPIPS-derived rankings remain reliable across the different degradation families considered.
- The contribution of the data-construction pipeline is difficult to separate from the capabilities of the used pretrained models. Comparisons using alternative generators would help clarify this relationship.
- The effective scale of training data and its influence on performance need clarification.
- Since data construction is guided by the selected reference images. What criteria of reference selection, and how is coverage of different scenes, degradation types, and severity levels ensured?
- How about the diversity of the constructed dataset in terms of degradation severity (ordering)? How do the authors ensure that all degradation levels of one of the degradations provided by reference images are covered, or the constructed training data is benchmark-oriented?
Questions for authors
The main questions are included above. In addition, the authors should better report the generation costs of data construction, it is one valuable aspect of the proposed dataset construction pipeline.