- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This work introduces TrussOrbit as a representation of metamaterial that addresses the first issue: the symmetry of metamaterial generation is usually hard to satisfy. Then they introduce an evaluation pipeline SMCO, to evaluate fixed-size groups using stiffness-matching and binary validity rewards. The tokenization method coupled with SFT + SMCO (GRPO-like reward) training enables effective generation of metamaterial.
Critical strengths
- The generation results are solid, especially regarding the success rate and reconstruction results.
- The generation latency is state-of-the-art compared to previous work.
Critical weaknesses
-
[Novelty] The introduction claims two existing issues, which are kind of little weak. For the first issue, there are several existing works have emerged to address it by using the property of periodicity and symmetry, such as [1,2]. For the second issue, the one-to-many issue mainly lies in generative model, which can usually be addressed by tuning the generation random seeds or noise, and how this work addresses it is not clear.
-
[Presentations] The writing of main text requires further polish to improve readability.
-
[Presentations] The evaluation requires more details. How the validity check is conducted and how data coverage is computed are not clearly defined.
-
[Results concern] From the qualitative experiments, it seems the model tends to repeat the Target model, resulting in a more similar lower NRMSE. This means lower NRMSE is achieved by repeating the generation; is the model capable of generating new structures or it tend to repeat datasets?
-
[Soundness] The methods use self-defined datasets, metrics, and computation. Some important baselines such as mace+ve [3], and other methods and metrics listed in previous benchmarks [4] can be included to improve the robustness.
Some minor concerns (some suggestions that may not influence rating):
-
Some specialized words require further explanation or definition to improve readability, such as Counterfactual rewards, where the meaning or indication of counterfactual is not clear.
-
Some definitions are not clear. For example, how the v_i is represented; is it a coordinate? A more detailed and formal definition might be better for readers.
-
All notations and abbreviations should be explained when first used, such as FEM, U_im, VGH, MAPE.
-
Paragraph (Lines 243 to 250) is not well-structured. The descriptions of the symbols and the proposed representations are not clear. It might be better to describe the representation design in readable language and explain each symbol accordingly.
[1] uniTruss: Li Zheng, Konstantinos Karapiperis, Siddhant Kumar, Dennis M. Kochmann Nature Communications. 2023
[2] Abu-Mualla, M., Huang, J. Inverse design of curved mechanical metamaterials with geometric AI: a generative diffusion operates in compact latent space of cellular structures. npj Metamaterials..2025.
[3] Grega, Ivan, et al. Energy-conserving equivariant GNN for elasticity of lattice architected metamaterials.ICLR. Vol. 2024. 2024.
[4] Chen et al. MetamatBench: Integrating Heterogeneous Data, Computational Tools, and Visual Interface for Metamaterial Discovery. KDD. 2025
Questions for authors
- How you explictly address the one-to-many problem and how you evaluate it?
- Can the generation results be new, or it tends to repeat existing generations with similar stiffness (lower NRMSE)?
- Is it possible to compare with more methods such as paper "Energy-conserving equivariant GNN for elasticity of lattice architected metamaterials"[3], or more metrics, such as some metrics and methods in the previous metamaterial benchmark[4]?