- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents a Fourier-latent diffusion framework for generating triply periodic minimal surfaces (TPMS) under geometric and mechanical constraints. The authors construct a dataset of 18,704 solver-generated TPMS and represent them using a compact, symmetry-constrained Fourier basis. A conditional diffusion model is trained to generate Fourier coefficients from random noise, optionally conditioned on sparse spatial points or selected elastic properties. The generated surfaces are further refined through coefficient-space curvature optimization. Experiments demonstrate unconditional generation, conditional generation, and shape editing, with improvements in mean curvature over several generative baselines.
Critical strengths
S1. Compact representation with explicit geometric constraints.
The proposed Fourier representation guarantees periodicity and D2h symmetry by construction, reducing the representation to 4,096 coefficients without requiring a learned geometric decoder. This provides a compact design space and enables analytical curvature computation and coefficient-space refinement.
S2. Demonstration of geometric and mechanical conditioning.
The framework supports sparse-point constraints, selected elastic-property targets, and their combination. The experiments demonstrate that conditional generative modeling can produce approximately constraint-satisfying TPMS within the considered design space.
Critical weaknesses
W1. Limited methodological novelty and insufficient justification for diffusion-based generation.
The proposed framework mainly combines established techniques, including Fourier representations, symmetry constraints, standard conditional diffusion, and gradient-based curvature refinement. The methodological novelty beyond their integration remains limited. More fundamentally, the paper does not adequately justify why learning a distribution of precomputed TPMS is preferable to directly optimizing structures under geometric and physical constraints. Modern computational design workflows can combine procedural geometry generation, numerical solvers, and simulation-driven optimization. Given the existing dataset of 18,704 TPMS, a natural alternative would be to retrieve suitable candidates and refine their Fourier coefficients using physical feedback.
Although Appendix F.5 investigates direct coefficient optimization, it does not adequately evaluate retrieval-based initialization. Moreover, comparisons focus on generic generative baselines rather than competitive inverse-design methods, and different refinement strategies are applied across methods.
Consequently, the paper fails to demonstrate that diffusion provides meaningful advantages over simpler solver-driven or optimization-based approaches, substantially weakening its novelty and significance.
W2. Limited generalization and unclear practical utility.
The framework relies on a relatively small dataset of 18,704 procedurally generated TPMS and a strongly constrained D2h-symmetric Fourier representation. While these priors improve efficiency, they substantially restrict geometric expressiveness and raise concerns about generalization beyond the training distribution.
The reported nearest-neighbor Chamfer distance is compared against diffusion inversion error, but these metrics measure different properties and do not establish meaningful generative novelty. Furthermore, conditional experiments involve only 20–30 samples per setting, with 16-point geometric constraints and a few low-dimensional elastic properties. Systematic evaluations of unseen boundary configurations, out-of-distribution constraints, and more complex engineering requirements are missing. Appendix J also demonstrates failures under unseen or conflicting conditions.
More importantly, the paper does not demonstrate a realistic engineering application where its generative approach improves constraint satisfaction, design quality, or computational efficiency over existing optimization workflows.
Overall, the experiments demonstrate conditional sampling within a narrow geometric distribution, but provide insufficient evidence of generalization, robustness, or practical significance.
Questions for authors
Q1. Comparison with Existing 3D Generation Methods. How does the proposed method compare with modern 3D generators such as Meshy or Tripo, followed by periodicity enforcement and curvature optimization? Does the specialized Fourier diffusion model provide measurable advantages in geometric quality, constraint satisfaction, or efficiency?
Q2. Comparison with Prior Inverse Design Methods
MIND (Xue et al., SIGGRAPH 2025) already explores diffusion-based inverse design of periodic microstructures conditioned on mechanical properties. Why is this closely related method not included in the quantitative comparisons? Can the authors compare both approaches under the same geometric and mechanical constraints to demonstrate the advantages of the proposed Fourier representation?
Q3. Comparison with Coding Agent-based Workflows.
Can the authors compare against a Claude Code-based pipeline that generates parametric TPMS geometry, runs numerical simulations, and iteratively refines the design using physical feedback? How do the approaches compare in constraint satisfaction, computational cost, and design quality?
Q4. Generalization Beyond Training Data.
Can the authors evaluate performance on unseen boundary configurations and out-of-distribution mechanical targets? How do they ensure that rotation-augmented samples do not introduce leakage between training and validation sets?
Reference:
Xue, T., et al. MIND: Microstructure INverse Design with Generative Hybrid Neural Representation. ACM SIGGRAPH 2025 Conference Papers, Article 125, 2025.
3 comments
Rebuttal (2/2)
Q5. Claude Code workflow. How would an agent that generates parametric TPMS and iteratively refines them using simulation feedback compare in constraint satisfaction, cost, and design quality?
Neither Claude nor ChatGPT can directly generate valid TPMS structures from scratch, as neither provides a TPMS-specific geometry generator or learned geometric prior. Such a workflow would still need to combine with existing TPMS construction methods, such as Surface Evolver (Brakke, 1992) or Procedural Metamaterials (Makatura et al., 2023), followed by repeated simulation and iterative optimization. These approaches are computationally expensive, do not support conditional generation, and are not guaranteed to produce a valid structure satisfying the target constraints. Agent-driven simulation-in-the-loop design is an interesting direction for future exploration, but such a workflow is currently not comparable to our method.
Q6. Generalization and shape novelty. Does comparing nearest-neighbor Chamfer distance with inversion error establish generative novelty? How does the method perform on unseen boundary configurations and out-of-distribution mechanical targets? How to ensure that rotation-augmented samples do not introduce leakage between training and validation sets?
We do not compare the two metrics as measures of the same property. The inversion error serves only as a reference scale for how closely the model can reconstruct a known shape. If the generated samples were memorized training shapes, their nearest-neighbor Chamfer distance would fall to this level, yet it is substantially larger (0.0091 vs. 0.0037), indicating that the generated surfaces are not near-copies of the training data. As shown in Fig. 10, our model also generates shapes with new topologies or obvious geometric differences from their nearest training neighbors. We revised the wording in Section 4.1.
For point conditioning, we randomly select a dataset shape, sample 16 points from its surface, and apply Gaussian perturbations with , clipped to per coordinate. This creates diverse geometric conditions close to valid TPMS priors. The point subsets are resampled during training, and the test configurations are independently constructed and perturbed. Thus, although the source geometry comes from the dataset, the specific point conditions are not observed during training. For material conditioning, we sample target values between the minimum and maximum properties observed in the dataset. Performance may degrade for OOD targets, reflecting the common extrapolation limits of data-driven models.
Rotation augmentation was performed before the dataset split, so rotated variants were not explicitly grouped within the same split. However, we performance shape-wise deduplication, making sure no any pair of TPMS, including half-period shifting, has close Euclidean distance. Moreover, we note that TPMS structures are represented in a fixed unit-cell coordinate system, where the , , and axes have physical meaning. A rotation generally changes the Fourier representation and direction-dependent properties. We treat a rotated variant as geometrically identical only if it coincides with the original shape, possibly after a half-period shift. Additionally, we rigorously compared the validation candidates and their Fourier coefficients against those in the training set:
(1) Among the 1,870 validation candidates, none of them exactly matched a training shape within the unit cell or shared its Fourier coefficients., thereby ruling out direct data leakage;
(2) Among the 1,870 validation candidates, 542 do not belong to any rotation family present in the training set. We reran inversion on all these 542 candidates using the same evaluation protocol and obtained an even lower mean CD of , compared with over the original 1,000 validation candidates.
Thus, excluding all rotation-overlapping instances does not degrade reconstruction accuracy, indicating that the reported performance is not attributable to rotation overlap.
Thank you for the rebuttal and additional experiments.
However, my main concerns remain. The framework primarily combines established techniques within a highly restricted geometric distribution, without demonstrating sufficient methodological novelty or practical significance.
The Meshy/Tripo comparison is also unconvincing, as it does not use the strongest available high-fidelity models (Meshy 7.1 and Tripo H3.1). More importantly, testing text-to-3D generation alone is not a fair comparison with geometry generation followed by constraint enforcement and optimization.
The added experiments still do not establish clear advantages over simulation-driven inverse design, while generalization beyond the restricted training distribution remains insufficiently demonstrated.
I therefore maintain my original rejection recommendation.
Rebuttal (1/2)
Q1. Methodological novelty and practical value. What is the key methodological novelty beyond integrating existing components, and can the method outperform conventional optimization on a realistic engineering task?
Existing TPMS design methods face substantial limitations: the procedural construction of Makatura et al. (2023) requires costly per-instance numerical solving and does not support conditional generation, while low-order trigonometric formulations span a narrow design space with low genus and limited structural diversity, and often yield surfaces with high residual mean curvature. Our framework is purposefully designed to address these limitations: the symmetry-reduced Fourier representation provides a compact design space with exact periodicity and D2h symmetry; transformer-based diffusion learns the distribution of TPMS and enables rapid generation; conditional modules support user-specified geometric and mechanical targets; and analytic coefficient-space refinement reduces residual curvature without violating the representation guarantees. Our method generates valid TPMS structures with a high success rate, and they are compatible with manufacturing processes such as 3D printing.
Q2. Value of diffusion. What does the learned prior add over retrieving a suitable candidate from the 18,704 TPMS and refining its Fourier coefficients with simulation feedback?
We additionally conducted this experiment under point conditioning. Using the same protocol to construct the target points, we retrieved the closest shape from the dataset and jointly optimized it with the point loss and mean-curvature loss. We found that the optimized shapes developed pronounced spiky artifacts with extremely high curvature. Moreover, retrieving and optimizing a single shape took approximately 40 seconds, nearly 6× slower than our direct forward generation. We present the new qualitative results in Appendix F.5 and Figure 16 of the revised manuscript.
Q3. MIND comparison. Why was MIND omitted from the quantitative evaluation? Can both methods be tested under the same geometric and mechanical constraints?
We briefly discuss MIND in Section 2. We do not include it as a quantitative baseline for the following reasons:
(1) Data and output-geometry mismatch. MIND’s full training dataset and pretrained checkpoints are not directly available in its public repository. Even if obtained upon request, their applicability to our task remains unclear. Moreover, MIND is trained on four structural categories and cannot guarantee that an output belongs to the shell category, let alone TPMS. In contrast, our model is specifically design to only output TPMS.
(2) Symmetry mismatch. MIND’s Holoplane representation enforces cubic Oh symmetry by construction, including axis permutations. This is more restrictive than our D2h setting. Supporting the full D2h space would require redesigning the Holoplane representation and retraining the model, which would substantially depart from the original MIND method.
Q4. Meshy and Tripo. How would these generators compare after periodicity enforcement and curvature optimization, in terms of geometry quality, constraint satisfaction, and efficiency?
We used the following explicit text prompt to generate TPMS-like meshes with Meshy T2.5 and Tripo H3.0:
“A single cube-shaped unit cell with edge length 1 of a complex Triply Periodic Minimal Surface. One smooth, continuous, very thin curved sheet whose mean curvature is zero everywhere. Strictly periodic: the surface on each face of the cube exactly matches the opposite face, so the cell tiles seamlessly in all three directions. No flat faces, no sharp edges, no texture, plain grey material.”
However, the resulting meshes bore little resemblance to TPMS, and some even extended beyond the prescribed periodic unit-cell boundaries. The fundamental limitation is that these text-to-3D models cannot explicitly enforce the defining geometric constraints of TPMS. Moreover, the generated meshes are not amenable to subsequent periodicity enforcement or curvature optimization. Producing a single mesh takes approximately 90 seconds with Meshy and 70 seconds with Tripo, both substantially slower than our method. We present the new results in Appendix K and Figure 18 of the revised manuscript.