acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Fourier-Latent Diffusion for Constrained Generation of Triply Periodic Minimal Surfaces

Abstract

We present a generative framework for the constrained design of -symmetric triply periodic minimal surfaces (TPMS) with low residual mean curvature. Existing TPMS design pipelines either explore a limited set of canonical analytical families or rely on computationally expensive numerical procedures, making it difficult to efficiently generate diverse candidates under geometric and/or mechanical requirements. Our approach learns a distribution of solver-generated TPMS in a compact Fourier space where periodicity and symmetry are guaranteed by construction. This representation eliminates the need for a learned geometric decoder and enables the training of an effective diffusion model that generates low-mean-curvature candidates conditioned on sparse geometric constraints, selected homogenized elastic properties, or their combination. A subsequent coefficient-space refinement further reduces the residual mean curvature. Experiments show that our approach outperforms trigonometric, SDF-based, and standard Fourier-space baselines and enables controllable, high-quality generation under geometric and low-dimensional mechanical constraints. Overall, the proposed framework provides a compact and efficient design space for generating near-minimal periodic structures under user-specified requirements.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
triply periodic minimal surfaces (TPMS), diffusion model, generation model, metamaterial

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_inxzOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents a Fourier-latent diffusion framework for generating triply periodic minimal surfaces (TPMS) under geometric and mechanical constraints. The authors construct a dataset of 18,704 solver-generated TPMS and represent them using a compact, symmetry-constrained Fourier basis. A conditional diffusion model is trained to generate Fourier coefficients from random noise, optionally conditioned on sparse spatial points or selected elastic properties. The generated surfaces are further refined through coefficient-space curvature optimization. Experiments demonstrate unconditional generation, conditional generation, and shape editing, with improvements in mean curvature over several generative baselines.

Critical strengths

S1. Compact representation with explicit geometric constraints.

The proposed Fourier representation guarantees periodicity and D2h symmetry by construction, reducing the representation to 4,096 coefficients without requiring a learned geometric decoder. This provides a compact design space and enables analytical curvature computation and coefficient-space refinement.

S2. Demonstration of geometric and mechanical conditioning.

The framework supports sparse-point constraints, selected elastic-property targets, and their combination. The experiments demonstrate that conditional generative modeling can produce approximately constraint-satisfying TPMS within the considered design space.

Critical weaknesses

W1. Limited methodological novelty and insufficient justification for diffusion-based generation.

The proposed framework mainly combines established techniques, including Fourier representations, symmetry constraints, standard conditional diffusion, and gradient-based curvature refinement. The methodological novelty beyond their integration remains limited. More fundamentally, the paper does not adequately justify why learning a distribution of precomputed TPMS is preferable to directly optimizing structures under geometric and physical constraints. Modern computational design workflows can combine procedural geometry generation, numerical solvers, and simulation-driven optimization. Given the existing dataset of 18,704 TPMS, a natural alternative would be to retrieve suitable candidates and refine their Fourier coefficients using physical feedback.

Although Appendix F.5 investigates direct coefficient optimization, it does not adequately evaluate retrieval-based initialization. Moreover, comparisons focus on generic generative baselines rather than competitive inverse-design methods, and different refinement strategies are applied across methods.

Consequently, the paper fails to demonstrate that diffusion provides meaningful advantages over simpler solver-driven or optimization-based approaches, substantially weakening its novelty and significance.

W2. Limited generalization and unclear practical utility.

The framework relies on a relatively small dataset of 18,704 procedurally generated TPMS and a strongly constrained D2h-symmetric Fourier representation. While these priors improve efficiency, they substantially restrict geometric expressiveness and raise concerns about generalization beyond the training distribution.

The reported nearest-neighbor Chamfer distance is compared against diffusion inversion error, but these metrics measure different properties and do not establish meaningful generative novelty. Furthermore, conditional experiments involve only 20–30 samples per setting, with 16-point geometric constraints and a few low-dimensional elastic properties. Systematic evaluations of unseen boundary configurations, out-of-distribution constraints, and more complex engineering requirements are missing. Appendix J also demonstrates failures under unseen or conflicting conditions.

More importantly, the paper does not demonstrate a realistic engineering application where its generative approach improves constraint satisfaction, design quality, or computational efficiency over existing optimization workflows.

Overall, the experiments demonstrate conditional sampling within a narrow geometric distribution, but provide insufficient evidence of generalization, robustness, or practical significance.

Questions for authors

Q1. Comparison with Existing 3D Generation Methods. How does the proposed method compare with modern 3D generators such as Meshy or Tripo, followed by periodicity enforcement and curvature optimization? Does the specialized Fourier diffusion model provide measurable advantages in geometric quality, constraint satisfaction, or efficiency?

Q2. Comparison with Prior Inverse Design Methods

MIND (Xue et al., SIGGRAPH 2025) already explores diffusion-based inverse design of periodic microstructures conditioned on mechanical properties. Why is this closely related method not included in the quantitative comparisons? Can the authors compare both approaches under the same geometric and mechanical constraints to demonstrate the advantages of the proposed Fourier representation?

Q3. Comparison with Coding Agent-based Workflows.

Can the authors compare against a Claude Code-based pipeline that generates parametric TPMS geometry, runs numerical simulations, and iteratively refines the design using physical feedback? How do the approaches compare in constraint satisfaction, computational cost, and design quality?

Q4. Generalization Beyond Training Data.

Can the authors evaluate performance on unseen boundary configurations and out-of-distribution mechanical targets? How do they ensure that rotation-augmented samples do not introduce leakage between training and validation sets?

Reference:

Xue, T., et al. MIND: Microstructure INverse Design with Generative Hybrid Neural Representation. ACM SIGGRAPH 2025 Conference Papers, Article 125, 2025.

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal (1/2)

Q1. Methodological novelty and practical value. What is the key methodological novelty beyond integrating existing components, and can the method outperform conventional optimization on a realistic engineering task?

Existing TPMS design methods face substantial limitations: the procedural construction of Makatura et al. (2023) requires costly per-instance numerical solving and does not support conditional generation, while low-order trigonometric formulations span a narrow design space with low genus and limited structural diversity, and often yield surfaces with high residual mean curvature. Our framework is purposefully designed to address these limitations: the symmetry-reduced Fourier representation provides a compact design space with exact periodicity and D2hD_{2h} symmetry; transformer-based diffusion learns the distribution of TPMS and enables rapid generation; conditional modules support user-specified geometric and mechanical targets; and analytic coefficient-space refinement reduces residual curvature without violating the representation guarantees. Our method generates valid TPMS structures with a high success rate, and they are compatible with manufacturing processes such as 3D printing.

Q2. Value of diffusion. What does the learned prior add over retrieving a suitable candidate from the 18,704 TPMS and refining its Fourier coefficients with simulation feedback?

We additionally conducted this experiment under point conditioning. Using the same protocol to construct the target points, we retrieved the closest shape from the dataset and jointly optimized it with the point loss and mean-curvature loss. We found that the optimized shapes developed pronounced spiky artifacts with extremely high curvature. Moreover, retrieving and optimizing a single shape took approximately 40 seconds, nearly 6×6\times slower than our direct forward generation. We present the new qualitative results in Appendix F.5 and Figure 16 of the revised manuscript.

Q3. MIND comparison. Why was MIND omitted from the quantitative evaluation? Can both methods be tested under the same geometric and mechanical constraints?

We briefly discuss MIND in Section 2. We do not include it as a quantitative baseline for the following reasons:
(1) Data and output-geometry mismatch. MIND’s full training dataset and pretrained checkpoints are not directly available in its public repository. Even if obtained upon request, their applicability to our task remains unclear. Moreover, MIND is trained on four structural categories and cannot guarantee that an output belongs to the shell category, let alone TPMS. In contrast, our model is specifically design to only output TPMS.
(2) Symmetry mismatch. MIND’s Holoplane representation enforces cubic OhO_h symmetry by construction, including axis permutations. This is more restrictive than our D2hD_{2h} setting. Supporting the full D2hD_{2h} space would require redesigning the Holoplane representation and retraining the model, which would substantially depart from the original MIND method.

Q4. Meshy and Tripo. How would these generators compare after periodicity enforcement and curvature optimization, in terms of geometry quality, constraint satisfaction, and efficiency?

We used the following explicit text prompt to generate TPMS-like meshes with Meshy T2.5 and Tripo H3.0:
“A single cube-shaped unit cell with edge length 1 of a complex Triply Periodic Minimal Surface. One smooth, continuous, very thin curved sheet whose mean curvature is zero everywhere. Strictly periodic: the surface on each face of the cube exactly matches the opposite face, so the cell tiles seamlessly in all three directions. No flat faces, no sharp edges, no texture, plain grey material.”
However, the resulting meshes bore little resemblance to TPMS, and some even extended beyond the prescribed periodic unit-cell boundaries. The fundamental limitation is that these text-to-3D models cannot explicitly enforce the defining geometric constraints of TPMS. Moreover, the generated meshes are not amenable to subsequent periodicity enforcement or curvature optimization. Producing a single mesh takes approximately 90 seconds with Meshy and 70 seconds with Tripo, both substantially slower than our method. We present the new results in Appendix K and Figure 18 of the revised manuscript.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal (2/2)

Q5. Claude Code workflow. How would an agent that generates parametric TPMS and iteratively refines them using simulation feedback compare in constraint satisfaction, cost, and design quality?

Neither Claude nor ChatGPT can directly generate valid TPMS structures from scratch, as neither provides a TPMS-specific geometry generator or learned geometric prior. Such a workflow would still need to combine with existing TPMS construction methods, such as Surface Evolver (Brakke, 1992) or Procedural Metamaterials (Makatura et al., 2023), followed by repeated simulation and iterative optimization. These approaches are computationally expensive, do not support conditional generation, and are not guaranteed to produce a valid structure satisfying the target constraints. Agent-driven simulation-in-the-loop design is an interesting direction for future exploration, but such a workflow is currently not comparable to our method.

Q6. Generalization and shape novelty. Does comparing nearest-neighbor Chamfer distance with inversion error establish generative novelty? How does the method perform on unseen boundary configurations and out-of-distribution mechanical targets? How to ensure that rotation-augmented samples do not introduce leakage between training and validation sets?

We do not compare the two metrics as measures of the same property. The inversion error serves only as a reference scale for how closely the model can reconstruct a known shape. If the generated samples were memorized training shapes, their nearest-neighbor Chamfer distance would fall to this level, yet it is substantially larger (0.0091 vs. 0.0037), indicating that the generated surfaces are not near-copies of the training data. As shown in Fig. 10, our model also generates shapes with new topologies or obvious geometric differences from their nearest training neighbors. We revised the wording in Section 4.1.

For point conditioning, we randomly select a dataset shape, sample 16 points from its surface, and apply Gaussian perturbations with σ=0.01\sigma=0.01, clipped to ±0.03\pm0.03 per coordinate. This creates diverse geometric conditions close to valid TPMS priors. The point subsets are resampled during training, and the test configurations are independently constructed and perturbed. Thus, although the source geometry comes from the dataset, the specific point conditions are not observed during training. For material conditioning, we sample target values between the minimum and maximum properties observed in the dataset. Performance may degrade for OOD targets, reflecting the common extrapolation limits of data-driven models.

Rotation augmentation was performed before the dataset split, so rotated variants were not explicitly grouped within the same split. However, we performance shape-wise deduplication, making sure no any pair of TPMS, including half-period shifting, has close Euclidean distance. Moreover, we note that TPMS structures are represented in a fixed unit-cell coordinate system, where the xx, yy, and zz axes have physical meaning. A rotation generally changes the Fourier representation and direction-dependent properties. We treat a rotated variant as geometrically identical only if it coincides with the original shape, possibly after a half-period shift. Additionally, we rigorously compared the validation candidates and their Fourier coefficients against those in the training set:
(1) Among the 1,870 validation candidates, none of them exactly matched a training shape within the unit cell or shared its Fourier coefficients., thereby ruling out direct data leakage;
(2) Among the 1,870 validation candidates, 542 do not belong to any rotation family present in the training set. We reran inversion on all these 542 candidates using the same evaluation protocol and obtained an even lower mean CD of 3.77×10−33.77\times10^{-3}, compared with 3.85×10−33.85\times10^{-3} over the original 1,000 validation candidates.
Thus, excluding all rotation-overlapping instances does not degrade reconstruction accuracy, indicating that the reported performance is not attributable to rotation overlap.

Thank you for the rebuttal and additional experiments.

However, my main concerns remain. The framework primarily combines established techniques within a highly restricted geometric distribution, without demonstrating sufficient methodological novelty or practical significance.

The Meshy/Tripo comparison is also unconvincing, as it does not use the strongest available high-fidelity models (Meshy 7.1 and Tripo H3.1). More importantly, testing text-to-3D generation alone is not a fair comparison with geometry generation followed by constraint enforcement and optimization.

The added experiments still do not establish clear advantages over simulation-driven inverse design, while generalization beyond the restricted training distribution remains insufficiently demonstrated.

I therefore maintain my original rejection recommendation.

Reviewer_xZtpOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a method for generating periodic surfaces through diffusion in a Fourier latent space, aiming to produce structures with low residual mean curvature while satisfying geometric and mechanical conditions. The method uses a cosine-product basis with D2h{D_{2h}} symmetry to represent implicit surfaces through a compact set of Fourier coefficients and learns their distribution from a solver-generated dataset. The framework supports generation conditioned on sparse points, mechanical properties, or both, and further reduces curvature through subsequent optimization in coefficient space. Experiments cover unconditional generation, conditional design, shape reconstruction, and editing.

Critical strengths
  1. The representation design is clearly aligned with the target structures.
The chosen Fourier basis guarantees the specified periodicity and reflection symmetries by construction and reduces representational redundancy within the selected symmetry class. These properties are preserved during coefficient updates, providing useful structural constraints for generation and subsequent optimization. The paper also explicitly acknowledges that low residual curvature does not guarantee that the resulting surfaces are exact minimal surfaces.
  2. The dataset construction has substantive value.
The paper uses a solver to generate surfaces from various fundamental domains and boundary configurations, followed by symmetrization, normalization, and deduplication, yielding 18704 samples. Compared with merely varying the parameters of a small set of classical analytic surfaces, this pipeline explores a richer range of structural variations and provides a valuable data foundation for learning a generative prior over periodic surfaces.
  3. Conditional design has practical value, and mechanical evaluation uses a numerical solver.
The method considers both local geometric conditions and global mechanical responses and demonstrates generation under joint conditioning. The mechanical properties of generated structures are evaluated through periodic finite-element homogenization calculations, providing direct numerical verification of condition satisfaction. The results in Table 2 indicate the framework’s potential for approximate control over geometry and physical properties.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The stability of the curvature objective and evaluation metrics under scaling requires further clarification.
Scaling the implicit field by a positive factor, f↦cf{f \mapsto cf}, where c>0{c>0}, does not change the zero level set or its true geometric curvature. However, when the gradient norm enters the clamping regime defined by the fixed threshold δ{\delta}, the regularized curvature estimate in Eq. (25) of the appendix may decrease as the coefficient magnitudes decrease; the penalty on field values in Eq. (3) also decreases. This indicates a potential route to scale degeneracy in both the objective and the evaluation metrics.
Furthermore, Eq. (4) in the main text and Eq. (25) in the appendix are not equivalent within the clamping regime, so the expression used in practice needs to be specified. This analysis does not establish that the reported experimental results have been affected. However, the paper currently provides insufficient information about the threshold, gradient scales, and independent curvature checks to rule out this risk.
  2. The evaluation metrics and sample sizes for quantitative comparisons of conditional generation are insufficient.
Each setting in Table 2 includes only 20–30 samples. The source and range of the target conditions, whether they come from held-out structures, the number of attempts per target, and the failure cases remain insufficiently clear. Consequently, the mean errors are insufficient to fully characterize the reliability of conditional generation. Appendix F.5 already provides a qualitative comparison with direct coefficient optimization, but a quantitative comparison using the same targets and an explicitly specified computational budget is still missing, limiting the assessment of the benefits provided by the learned prior.
  3. The filtering and refinement strategies limit the assessment of overall generation performance and the sources of improvement.
Table 1 follows a protocol of generating 300 candidates and retaining the 150 with the lowest curvature for each method, a setting that the authors explicitly disclose. The proposed method achieves a mean absolute curvature of 0.67 after filtering, compared with 1.16 across all 300 candidates. This supports evaluation in a candidate-selection setting, but the unfiltered result distributions and the proportions meeting a specified quality threshold are still needed for each method to assess overall output quality. Moreover, different methods use different curvature refinement strategies, so the differences after refinement reflect contributions from the representation, the generative model, and the optimization procedure. Comparing complete pipelines is meaningful, but it is insufficient to isolate the benefits of the proposed representation.
Questions for authors
  1. Does the implementation use Eq. (4) or Eq. (25), and what is the exact value of δ{\delta} ? How many sampled surface points fall within the gradient-norm clamping regime before and after optimization? Could the authors test uniform scaling of the Fourier coefficients for a fixed surface and use an independent geometric curvature estimator to check whether the main results remain consistent?
  2. How are the target properties and constraint points in Table 2 selected, and do they come from held-out underlying geometries? How many generation attempts are allowed per target, and are the outputs filtered? Could the authors report unfiltered success rates and failure cases under explicitly specified tolerances for geometric and physical-property errors? Does Table 2 report the final results after curvature refinement?
  3. Could the authors provide the result distributions for all 300 candidates from each baseline, or the proportion meeting the same curvature threshold? For the standard Fourier baseline, does the performance gap persist after refinement in coefficient space under a comparable computational budget?
  4. After rotational data augmentation, are all rotated versions of the same solver-generated geometry assigned to the same data split? If the current split is not grouped by original geometry, could the authors clarify its effect on the validation results, distinguishing generalization to new underlying geometries from reconstruction of rotated variants of previously seen geometries?
4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal (1/2)

Q1. Curvature under coefficient scaling. Which formula is implemented, Eq. (4) or Eq. (25), and what is δ? How many points fall in the small-gradient regime before and after refinement? Can a fixed-surface scaling test and an independent mesh-based estimator validate the results?

Thank you for pointing this out. Eq. (4) is currently written imprecisely. Our implementation evaluates curvature using Eq. (25), the analytic expansion of the standard divergence formulation, with δ=10−12\delta=10^{-12}. We have corrected Eq. (4) and clarified this in the revision. We also specify the value of δ\delta in Appendix H.
To address the remaining concerns, we use the fourth example in Fig. 15 as a representative case and perform the requested validations. No evaluated vertex falls into the small-gradient regime, either before or after refinement. Scaling all coefficients by c∈[0.01,100]c\in[0.01,100] while fixing the evaluation surface changes the mean curvature by at most 0.0000950.000095%. These results indicate that numerical regularization has a negligible effect on curvature evaluation. Moreover, an independent mesh-normal-divergence estimator confirms a reduction from 1.02 to 0.41, consistent with the analytic reduction from 1.00 to 0.40.

Q2. Table 1 and standard Fourier refinement. Can the authors report curvature distributions or threshold pass rates for all 300 candidates per method? Does the gap to standard Fourier persist under a comparable coefficient-space refinement budget?

We first clarify that, for every method in Table 1, we select the 150 candidates with the lowest ∣H∣avg|H|_{\mathrm{avg}} from that method’s own 300 valid generated candidates; this selection is applied consistently to all methods and not only to ours. We additionally evaluated all 300 valid candidates for each method rather than only the subset in Table 1. Using ∣H∣avg<2.0|H|_{\mathrm{avg}} < 2.0 as a common threshold, the pass rates are 92.0% (276/300) for ours, 89.7% (269/300) for Trig, 82.3% (247/300) for SDF-Diffusion, 80.0% (240/300) for SDFusion, and 67.3% (202/300) for standard Fourier. Their corresponding post-refinement mean ∣H∣avg|H|_{\mathrm{avg}} values are 1.16, 1.38, 1.46, 1.49, and 1.92, respectively. Ours, Trig, and standard Fourier were refined using the same coefficient-space analytic refinement budget (one of our contributions), while the two SDF-based models were refined using MCF because their representations do not support our analytic refinement. Under the directly comparable budget, ours retains a substantial advantage over standard Fourier in both mean curvature and pass rate, confirming that the gap is not caused by candidate selection or an unfair refinement budget. We have added the threshold and the corresponding success rate to the first paragraph of Section 4.1 in the revised manuscript.

Q3. Direct coefficient optimization. Can the authors compare diffusion with the direct Fourier optimization in Appendix F.5 quantitatively, using identical targets and a specified compute budget?

We clarify that the examples in Appendix F.5 are not selectively chosen failure cases, and all conditioning targets are sampled from conditions in the dataset. We tested direct coefficient optimization repeatedly with multiple random and frequency-decayed initializations, and all trials produced invalid structures; Fig. 16 shows only a representative subset. Direct optimization lacks a principled initialization or learned structural prior, and different initial coefficients converge to substantially different local solutions.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal (2/2)

Q4. Table 2 evaluation protocol. Where do the targets come from, what ranges do they cover, and are their geometries held out? How many attempts are made per target? Were outputs filtered or refined? Can the authors report unfiltered success rates at explicit tolerances and show failures?

For single-property conditioning, we randomly sample a target value within the dataset’s minimum–maximum range, the sampled value need not exactly match an existing training value. For point conditioning, each test condition is constructed by randomly selecting a dataset shape, sampling 16 points from its surface, and applying small perturbations. During training, the 16 conditioning points are independently resampled at every epoch and only training surfaces are used; therefore, the exact test point set {pi}(1≤i≤16)\{p_i\} (1\leq i\leq 16) is not necessarily observed during training. For dual conditioning, we first sample a property target, randomly select a dataset shape with a nearby property value, and obtain the point condition in the same way. Although the conditions are constructed with reference to the dataset, their exact values or point combinations are not necessarily present during training.
We consider a candidate successful if its surface is connected, ∣H∣avg<2.0|H|_{\mathrm{avg}} < 2.0, its average point distance is below 0.025$L$ (LL=1 in our experiments), and its relative property error is below 0.15. Single-modality condition candidates must satisfy both the applicable error and the curvature threshold, while jointly conditioned candidates must simultaneously satisfy all three thresholds. The table below reports the success number across six experimental settings, with 50 random attempts per setting. We have added these details to Section 4.2 and reported the corresponding success counts in Table 2 of the revised manuscript.

\text{Condition} & \\;\text{Points}\\; & \\;\text{Bulk}\\; & \\;\text{Shear}\\; & \\;\text{Bulk} + \text{shear}\\; & \\;\text{Points} + C_{11}\\; & \\;\text{Points} + \text{bulk}\\; \\\\[6pt] \hline \text{Successes} & 33 & 26 & 29 & 29 & 20 & 23 \end{array}$$ The results in Table 2 are randomly selected from successful candidates, and all reported generation results are obtained after curvature refinement. The unfiltered success rates under the explicit tolerances are reported in the table above, and representative failure cases are shown in Appendix J. **Q5. Rotation augmentation and data splits.** Are all rotations of a solver-generated shape kept in the same split? If rotations cross splits, how does this affect validation reconstruction and claims of generalization to new geometries? Rotation augmentation was performed before the dataset split, so rotated variants were not explicitly grouped within the same split. However, we performance shape-wise deduplication, making sure no any pair of TPMS, including half-period shifting, has close Euclidean distance. Moreover, we note that TPMS structures are represented in a fixed unit-cell coordinate system, where the $x$, $y$, and $z$ axes have physical meaning. A rotation generally changes the Fourier representation and direction-dependent properties. We treat a rotated variant as geometrically identical only if it coincides with the original shape, possibly after a half-period shift. Additionally, we rigorously compared the validation candidates and their Fourier coefficients against those in the training set:\ (1) Among the 1,870 validation candidates, none of them exactly matched a training shape within the unit cell or shared its Fourier coefficients., thereby ruling out direct data leakage;\ (2) Among the 1,870 validation candidates, 542 do not belong to any rotation family present in the training set. We reran inversion on all these 542 candidates using the same evaluation protocol and obtained an even lower mean CD of $3.77\times10^{-3}$, compared with $3.85\times10^{-3}$ over the original 1,000 validation candidates. \ Thus, excluding all rotation-overlapping instances does not degrade reconstruction accuracy, indicating that the reported performance is not attributable to rotation overlap.

Thank you for your reply. I will maintain my score.

Thank you very much for your feedback!

Reviewer_RtzEOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents an application-oriented generative pipeline for designing near-minimal D2hD_{2h}-symmetric triply periodic minimal surfaces (TPMS). The authors construct a dataset of 18,704 solver-derived TPMS and encode them in a symmetry-reduced Fourier representation. This representation guarantees periodicity and reflection symmetry, reduces the coefficient dimensionality, and permits analytic curvature computation. A transformer-based diffusion model then supports unconditional generation, conditioning on sparse geometric points or selected homogenized elastic properties, and joint conditioning. Finally, coefficient-space optimization reduces residual mean curvature.

Critical strengths

(1) The symmetry-adapted Fourier representation is well matched to the TPMS problem. The method guarantees periodicity and D2hD_{2h} symmetry for every generated sample while reducing the number of coefficients. The representation also avoids a learned geometric decoder and provides analytic spatial derivatives for curvature refinement. This is an elegant use of known domain structure.

(2) The method supports unconditional sampling, sparse-point constraints, low-dimensional mechanical-property targets, joint conditioning, inversion, and local editing. The work is potentially useful for computational material design. The experiments indicate lower residual curvature than the evaluated baselines within this application setting.

Critical weaknesses

(1) The methodological contribution appears primarily application-specific rather than broadly relevant to diffusion modeling. Most components, including the denoising objective, UViT-style architecture, and cross-attention conditioning, are established techniques. The main novelty is the D2hD_{2h}-adapted cosine basis, which follows naturally from the assumed periodicity and reflection symmetry. Although effective for TPMS, the paper neither develops a general symmetry-reduced diffusion framework nor demonstrates applicability to other symmetry classes or domains. The work therefore reads as a strong TPMS application rather than a broadly consequential advance in diffusion-based generation.

(2) The generation evaluation does not fully establish reliability under the stated design requirements. The main experiments emphasize mean absolute curvature and average conditional errors, which can conceal local defects and individual failures. Although the paper reports curvature percentiles for inversion and illustrates disconnected or degenerate outputs under joint conditioning, it does not report corresponding curvature tails, invalid-output rates, or joint constraint-success rates for the main generation experiments.

Questions for authors

(1) Can the authors report curvature tail statistics and disconnected or degenerate output rates for the generation experiments? For each applicable conditioning setting, what fraction of outputs simultaneously satisfies the geometric, mechanical, and curvature criteria?

(2) How are conflicting point and material targets identified? Do disconnected or degenerate outputs also occur for joint targets known to be feasible within the dataset?

3 comments

Q1. Scope of the contribution. How broadly does the symmetry-reduced Fourier approach apply beyond this TPMS setting, including other symmetry classes or domains?

Our Fourier representation and UViT-style diffusion framework can be adapted to different classes of periodic structures. Fourier modes compatible with the unit cell guarantee periodicity by construction. Symmetry can be enforced either by modifying the basis in Eq. (1) or by imposing additional constraints on the coefficients. The same diffusion backbone can then be trained on the corresponding coefficient representation.
Beyond D2hD_{2h}, the representation can accommodate other symmetry constraints. For example, D4hD_{4h} symmetry with its fourfold axis along zz can be enforced by requiring ahkℓ=akhℓa_{hk\ell}=a_{kh\ell}. For OhO_h symmetry, coefficients related by any permutation of h,k,ℓh,k,\ell must share the same value. A prerequisite is that the training shapes must satisfy the selected symmetry constraints. Once these constraints are specified, the remaining workflow is unchanged: train our diffusion model on the corresponding coefficients, generate new coefficients from random noise, and substitute them into the basis to reconstruct the implicit field. The geometry is then extracted as its zero level set, following the same procedure used in our current framework.

Q2. Curvature tails and invalid outputs. Can the authors report curvature tail statistics and the rates of disconnected or degenerate outputs for the generation experiments?

For the unconditional random generation task, we evaluated outputs from 100 randomly selected seeds, of which around 80% produced valid, connected structures. For the 150 refined shapes reported in Table 1, we analytically evaluated the pointwise absolute mean curvature ∣H∣|H| over all surface vertices. We first computed the 95th and 99th percentiles independently for each shape and then averaged them across all 150 shapes. The resulting mean P95 and P99 values are 2.57 and 5.49, respectively, while the corresponding mean ∣H∣avg|H|_{\mathrm{avg}} is 0.67, consistent with Table 1. Figure 5 shows colormaps of pointwise mean curvature.

Q3. Joint success rates. For each applicable conditioning setting, what fraction of outputs meets the geometric, mechanical, and curvature criteria simultaneously?

We consider a candidate successful if its surface is connected, ∣H∣avg<2.0|H|_{\mathrm{avg}}<2.0, its average point distance is below 0.025$L$ (LL=1 in our experiments), and its relative property error is below 0.15. Single-modality condition candidates must satisfy both the applicable error and the curvature threshold, while jointly conditioned candidates must simultaneously satisfy all three thresholds. The table below reports the success number across six experimental settings, with 50 random attempts per setting. We have added these details to Section 4.2 and reported the corresponding success counts in Table 2 of the revised manuscript.

\text{Condition} & \\;\text{Points}\\; & \\;\text{Bulk}\\; & \\;\text{Shear}\\; & \\;\text{Bulk} + \text{shear}\\; & \\;\text{Points} + C_{11}\\; & \\;\text{Points} + \text{bulk}\\; \\\\[6pt] \hline \text{Successes} & 33 & 26 & 29 & 29 & 20 & 23 \end{array}$$ The results in Table 2 are randomly selected from successful candidates, and all reported generation results are obtained after curvature refinement. **Q4. Conflicting targets.** How are conflicts between point and material targets identified? Do disconnected or degenerate outputs also occur for joint targets known to be feasible within the dataset? The “conflicting” here denotes joint targets that are empirically difficult to satisfy simultaneously. We agree that the word may be too strong for this meaning, and we will replace it with “challenging joint targets” in the revision. Since diffusion sampling starts from random noise, an individual sample may occasionally fail to meet the thresholds even for targets known to be feasible. Nevertheless, the success rate for dataset-derived targets is substantially higher than for arbitrarily sampled joint targets.

Thank you for the detailed response. The proposed D4hD_{4h} and OhO_h coefficient constraints clarify how the representation could be extended, although their effectiveness has not been tested. The demonstrated contribution remains a compact Fourier representation and generation pipeline for D2hD_{2h}-symmetric TPMS. My concern is whether this constitutes a sufficiently significant contribution for the broader machine learning community, given prior work such as MIND that also combines symmetry-aware representations with diffusion for microstructure inverse design. Evidence from other symmetry classes or periodic microstructure families would help establish how far the method generalizes beyond the distribution represented by its 18,704-shape dataset.

The diffusion architecture and training objective largely follow established methods. The domain-specific contribution appears to lie in the Fourier representation and curvature refinement, rather than in a new diffusion modeling technique for periodic microstructures. For these reasons, I maintain my weak reject recommendation.

Thank you very much for your feedback!

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response

We sincerely appreciate the detailed reviews and the thoughtful feedback provided by all reviewers. In addition to addressing specific comments from each reviewer, we would like to outline our primary contributions:
[Idea] Existing TPMS design methods often require costly numerical solves for each new design or offer limited control over user-specified requirements. We address this gap with a framework that rapidly generates near-minimal TPMS conditioned on user-specified geometric constraints, mechanical targets, or both [inxz, RtzE, xZtp].
[Methodology] We build a diverse dataset of TPMS using a numerical solver [xZtp], encode the surfaces in a compact Fourier basis that guarantees periodicity and (D_{2h}) symmetry [inxz, RtzE, xZtp], and train a conditional diffusion model to generate Fourier coefficients. We then refine the generated surfaces directly in coefficient space to reduce residual mean curvature using analytic derivatives [inxz, RtzE].
[Experiments] Our method achieves lower residual curvature than all evaluated baselines [RtzE]. We verify the mechanical properties of generated surfaces through periodic finite-element homogenization [xZtp]. The revision reports success rates for unconditional and conditional generation, adds a retrieval-based initialization to the direct optimization baseline, and presents qualitative comparisons with Meshy and Tripo.
[Presentation] The manuscript was found to be clear and easy to read [inxz, xZtp].

During the rebuttal period, we revised the manuscript in response to the reviewers’ feedback. The changes listed below are highlighted in blue in the revised manuscript:
(1) Added a curvature threshold for unconditional generation and reported the corresponding pass rate across all 300 valid candidates (Section 4.1);
(2) Defined success criteria for conditional generation and reported success counts and evaluation sample sizes for all six settings (Section 4.2 and Table 2);
(3) Added a retrieval-based initialization to the direct Fourier-space optimization baseline and illustrated the resulting surface artifacts (Appendix F.5 and Figure 16);
(4) Clarified the mean-curvature formula and specified the numerical regularization constant used in practice (Eq. (4) and Appendix H);
(5) Revised the wording on “challenging joint targets” (Appendix J);
(6) Added a qualitative comparison and generation timings for Meshy and Tripo on the TPMS task (Appendix K and Figure 18).

We hope these responses address the reviewers’ concerns. We thank the reviewers and the Area Chair for their time and consideration.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.