- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a fixed-point sampler for constraining pretrained diffusion models. It feeds the difference between a denoised prediction and its constraint projection back into the noisy state, then denoises and corrects again to balance constraint adherence with plausible shape. The authors provide a conditional convergence analysis and evaluate the method on point-cloud completion and anatomical reconstruction, among other tasks.
Critical strengths
-
Feeding constraint corrections into the noisy state is a simple and practical design. Denoising again after each correction lets the pretrained model respond to the change while continuing to supply a shape prior. The update uses the projection residual without retraining or backpropagating through the denoiser, making it convenient to apply existing models to different geometric constraints.
-
The complete sampler achieves competitive constraint adherence and shape quality. Point-cloud completion and the anatomical reconstruction tasks cover several geometric constraints, with comparisons against multiple families of constrained samplers supporting the empirical advantage. These results establish practical value across different constraint tasks.
Critical weaknesses
-
The central fixed-point inner loop is not sufficiently justified over a simpler sampler. In Supplementary Tables 13 and 23, removing the loop while retaining the same sampling process and projection at the end of each step preserves much of the performance on point-cloud completion and aorta reconstruction. Computation falls substantially for point-cloud completion. The larger skull improvement is encouraging, but that ablation covers one case. The complete sampler's advantage over other methods therefore does not establish that fixed-point iteration itself provides a substantial advance commensurate with its extra computation.
-
The geometric feasibility evaluation does not establish the central claim of exact hard-constraint satisfaction. The main text presents exact feasibility as a key advantage over existing methods, but the pass criteria in Appendix A.6.2 use the 95th percentile of observation-point distances and can leave individual coverage violations undetected. Appendix A.3 provides conditional analysis for approximate projections, without establishing that the practical correction operators satisfy those conditions. The results show improved adherence, but do not verify the strict feasibility emphasized in the paper.
Questions for authors
-
For which constraints does the inner loop provide consistent gains that justify its cost over the version retaining projection at the end of each step? Does the larger benefit observed in the skull case hold across other subjects?
-
For geometric outputs reported as feasible, are the task's coverage constraints satisfied when all observation points are checked? Do the worst-point residuals or the fraction of violating points support the exact-feasibility claim?
2 comments
Thank the author for the additional comparisons. The equal-denoiser-call aorta experiment gives a concrete justification for the inner loop. It improves reported feasibility and worst-case violation even though K=0 achieves lower Chamfer error. This substantially reduces my concern about its added computational cost. Also, the pointwise-violation and whole-shape feasibility results also clarify what is achieved in practice. They support improved constraint adherence within application tolerances, rather than a guarantee that every generated shape is feasible. These additions address most of my original concerns. I'm now willing to raise my score accordingly.
We thank the reviewer for their thoughtful feedback. We respond extensively to their comments on hard constraint satisfaction and the need for an inner loop in the general response to all reviewers (see general response above).