- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces a large-scale dataset for 3D topology optimization under a linear-elastic minimum-compliance formulation and proposes OAT3D, a conditional generative model for structural topology design. OAT3D outperforms the evaluated NITO-3D baselines on the proposed benchmark, with further improvements achieved through best-of-N sampling and post-optimization.
Critical strengths
-
The paper addresses a practically important problem in 3D structural topology optimization and introduces a large-scale dataset covering diverse domain dimensions, loading conditions, supports, and material budgets.
-
The proposed framework is well suited to low-volume-fraction structures: its two-stage representation concentrates fine-scale modeling on occupied regions, while spatial encodings of loads and supports guide generation according to the prescribed mechanical conditions.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited external validation. The main performance evaluation is conducted on the proposed dataset. Although the paper discusses differences from NITO-3D and evaluates a partially overlapping subset, evaluation on the NITO-3D benchmark would provide stronger evidence of generalization. If direct evaluation is not feasible, the authors should clarify the limitations and any adaptations required for a meaningful comparison.
-
Insufficient ablation of mechanical performance. The ablations primarily assess geometric overlap through IoU, which does not necessarily reflect structural performance. In particular, the benefits of BNG conditioning should be evaluated using end-to-end compliance error, volume constraint violations, and failure rates, to establish whether it improves mechanically valid generation rather than only geometric similarity.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors analyze the main failure modes beyond the volume-fraction breakdown in Appendix I?
- How well does OAT3D generalize to unseen loading and support configurations, particularly those outside the training distribution?
- How representative are the randomly sampled loads of practical structural design problems, and what checks ensure that the resulting problems are physically well posed?
3 comments
These comments address reviewer's questions to authors
Reviewer:
Could the authors analyze the main failure modes beyond the volume-fraction breakdown in Appendix I?
Authors: We provide an additional study in Appendix J, where we (1) break down the overall failure rate, (2) investigate the mechanical causes, and (3) examine additional problem attributes like number of loaded nodes, number of loaded regions, number of fixed nodes, and number of elements (Table 18 in revised manuscript). We also added a figure to show some sample generations of all the four models side-by-side, demonstrating OAT3D’s advantage in generating structures with intact load paths, which the table below (Table 17) quantifies.
Failed single-generation predictions on the OAT test set by structural cause, as a percentage of the problems in each volume-fraction range. The five cause columns are exclusive and sum to the overall failure rate. Numbers in parentheses are shares of compliance failures in each class.
| Volume fraction | Problems | Method | Overall failure (%) ↓ | Solve failed (%) | Compliance failure: incomplete load path (%) | Compliance failure: partial load path (%) | Compliance failure: intact load path (%) | Volume failure only (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.05 ≤ v* < 0.10 | 312 | NITO-3D (NITO-trained) | 100 | 1.92 | 43.3 (44.4) | 48.4 (49.7) | 5.77 (5.9) | 0.64 |
| NITO-3D (OAT-trained, 23M) | 97.4 | 0.00 | 46.8 (48.0) | 36.2 (37.2) | 14.4 (14.8) | 0.00 | ||
| NITO-3D (OAT-trained, 811M) | 96.5 | 0.00 | 40.7 (42.2) | 40.1 (41.5) | 15.7 (16.3) | 0.00 | ||
| OAT3D | 71.8 | 0.00 | 0.96 (1.4) | 6.41 (8.9) | 64.4 (89.7) | 0.00 | ||
| 0.10 ≤ v* < 0.20 | 793 | NITO-3D (NITO-trained) | 99.4 | 2.40 | 41.4 (42.8) | 50.7 (52.4) | 4.67 (4.8) | 0.25 |
| NITO-3D (OAT-trained, 23M) | 93.8 | 0.00 | 17.2 (18.3) | 44.4 (47.3) | 32.3 (34.4) | 0.00 | ||
| NITO-3D (OAT-trained, 811M) | 91.6 | 0.00 | 13.4 (14.6) | 38.7 (42.3) | 39.5 (43.1) | 0.00 | ||
| OAT3D | 50.3 | 0.00 | 0.50 (1.0) | 2.14 (4.3) | 47.5 (94.7) | 0.13 | ||
| 0.20 ≤ v* ≤ 0.30 | 895 | NITO-3D (NITO-trained) | 99.4 | 2.46 | 21.5 (22.4) | 65.1 (67.9) | 9.27 (9.7) | 1.12 |
| NITO-3D (OAT-trained, 23M) | 81.0 | 0.00 | 3.58 (4.4) | 27.9 (34.5) | 49.5 (61.1) | 0.00 | ||
| NITO-3D (OAT-trained, 811M) | 79.7 | 0.00 | 3.46 (4.4) | 21.0 (26.4) | 55.1 (69.2) | 0.11 | ||
| OAT3D | 24.8 | 0.00 | 0.22 (0.9) | 1.34 (5.4) | 23.2 (93.7) | 0.00 |
Reviewer:
How well does OAT3D generalize to unseen loading and support configurations, particularly those outside the training distribution?
Authors: We added Appendix M.1, which presents common topology optimization problems unseen during training, including the MBB beam, the middle- and bottom-loaded cantilever beams, and a bridge, across three resolutions. Without post-optimization, OAT3D achieves an average compliance error of 23.84% on these problems. For configurations outside the training distribution, we evaluated OAT3D on 2,000 problems from the NITO-3D test set, which differs from our training data in domain size, volume-fraction range, and boundary-condition sampling (Appendix M.2). With a factor-of-two grid refinement to match our training domain sizes, OAT3D achieves lower compliance error on the NITO-3D test set than on the OAT3D test set, and after 5 post-optimization updates the median compliance error is 0.89%.
Reviewer:
How representative are the randomly sampled loads of practical structural design problems, and what checks ensure that the resulting problems are physically well posed?
Authors: It was our intention to sample as randomly as possible for the OAT3D dataset. We did check for physical well-posedness through our dataset filtering scheme described in Appendix B.3. We ensured that after thresholding (quantization), the topology did not exhibit rigid body motion. Mechanically, we also ensured that the loaded degrees of freedom do not coincide with the fixed degrees of freedom.
Additional Remark
We hope these clarifications address the reviewer’s concerns and improve the presentation of this work.
Thank you for the thoughtful clarifications and additional experiments, particularly the mechanical ablations and failure analysis, which substantially address my concerns. The external evaluation is also helpful, but it does not yet establish a consistent advantage of OAT3D over the baselines beyond the proposed benchmark. I therefore remain somewhat uncertain about the settings in which OAT3D is most beneficial and the limits of its applicability. Thus, my overall assessment remains Weak Accept.
These comments address reviewer's comments on critical weaknesses
We genuinely appreciate the reviewer’s valuable feedback.
Reviewer:
Authors: We evaluated OAT3D generation on 2,000 problems from the NITO-3D test set and reported the results in Appendix M.2, together with the one adaptation we found necessary because NITO-3D domains are smaller than any domain in the OAT3D training set. The model never saw NITO-3D data during training or fine-tuning, and we used checkpoints from the initial draft submission. With the adaptation, OAT3D achieves lower compliance error on the NITO-3D test set than on the OAT3D test set. After 5 post-optimization updates, the median compliance error of OAT3D-generated topologies on the NITO-3D test set is 0.89%.
We also present common topology optimization problems at three resolutions in Appendix M.1, including the MBB beam, the middle- and bottom-loaded cantilever beams, and a bridge.
Reviewer:
Authors: We ran an additional best-of-N experiment without the conditioning, and the results are appended in Table 7. Across the experiments, the BNG conditioning does lead to better structural performance.
Best-of-N selection from OAT3D, comparison between with BNG and without BNG.