- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper presents TopoGen, a framework for generating executable CadQuery programs from point clouds or multi-view images. It uses BRep-derived constraint graphs for structural supervision and introduces ToRPO, which combines geometric rewards with essential-operation and feature checks. The authors also construct TopoCAD-1M, a CAD dataset annotated with constraint graphs. Experiments across multiple datasets show improvements in geometric reconstruction and program validity in most evaluated settings.
Critical strengths
- Significant problem. The paper addresses structural consistency in visual CAD reconstruction and uses BRep-derived constraint graphs to provide explicit supervision for program generation.
- Valuable dataset. TopoCAD-1M combines approximately one million CAD models with constraint annotations and covers a range of geometric complexities.
- Clear writing. The manuscript is well organized and clearly presents the research motivation and overall framework.
Critical weaknesses
- Limited novelty. The method follows an established SFT–RL framework with a GRPO-style objective, while its constraint-graph supervision offers limited novelty over prior structural supervision.
- Insufficient baseline comparisons. Only three baselines are evaluated per modality, with limited coverage of recent CadQuery-based methods. The paper also leaves unclear whether baseline results were reproduced or cited and why they differ from the original reports.
- Limited evaluation of complex models. The qualitative results provide limited evidence of performance on highly complex parts, and results across different complexity levels are not reported.
- Insufficient ablations. The ablations lack a baseline without topology supervision under the same RL setup and do not evaluate the essential-operation and feature rewards separately. The individual contributions of these components remain unclear.
- Insufficient dataset documentation and long-tail analysis. Operation frequencies and distribution comparisons are missing, leaving the long-tail mitigation claim insufficiently supported. CadQuery program acquisition and validation, along with training sample counts and sampling procedures for each modality, also remain unclear.
- Incomplete evaluation and reporting. The evaluation lacks direct measures of constraint and essential-operation recovery, limiting support for structural consistency. Mean and median CD are not reported separately, despite the statement in the text.
Questions for authors
- Component ablations. Please add a matched SFT + ToRPO baseline without topology supervision, compare geometric-only and full rewards, and evaluate the essential-operation and feature rewards separately.
- Dataset construction and long-tail distribution. Please provide operation-frequency distributions for the source data and TopoCAD-1M, together with performance on rare operations. Please also describe how the CadQuery programs were obtained and validated.
- Structural recovery. Please report quantitative results on constraint-relation and essential-operation recovery to establish whether improved geometric metrics also reflect better structural recovery.
- Input modalities and training setup. Please clarify whether both modalities can be input jointly and how they are used during SFT and RL, including sample counts and sampling proportions for each modality.
- Baseline results. Please specify the source, checkpoint, and evaluation settings for each baseline, and explain the differences from the original results.
Dear Reviewers, the authors have posted their comments in response to the reviews. Please make an effort to discuss your review and the authors' response. - regards AC