- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduecs CADre, a system that uses frozen large language models to reconstruct CAD models from B-rep or point-cloud inputs without additional training. It divides the task among three agents: an investigator examines the input shape using Python queries and rendered views, a generator writes CadQuery programs, and a verifier checks the results and provides feedback for further revisions. The authors evaluate CADre on subsets of DeepCAD, Fusion 360, and ABC with different levels of shape complexity and report higher reconstruction accuracy than the selected baselines.
Critical strengths
-
Metrics look promising. With point-cloud inputs, CADre–Gemini achieves IoU scores higher than the strongest reported point-cloud baselines on the Hard splits of DeepCAD, Fusion 360, and ABC . The ablation results also suggest that using code to measure and inspect shapes helps improve reconstruction. It shows that frozen language models can reconstruct complex CAD shapes.
-
Support for different input types and language models. CADre accepts both B-rep models and point clouds, and the authors test it with Gemini and Qwen, which can be run locally. With B-rep inputs, the Qwen version also outperforms the selected baselines on all three Hard splits. These results suggest that the approach can work beyond a single proprietary model.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited methodological novelty. Earlier agentic CAD systems already use frozen language models, code execution, geometry tools, and repeated feedback. CAD-Assistant, for example, performs reverse engineering from 3D scans without additional training, and CADre’s generation and verification loop is adapted from an existing framework. The main additions seem to be a separate investigation stage and the integration of CAD-specific tools. While the evaluation is valuable, the paper does not clearly explain how these additions represent a substantial advance over prior methods.
-
The comparisons do not fully isolate the benefits of the proposed method. CADre and the baselines differ in both the information they receive and the computation they use. CADre can query exact B-rep properties, while the baselines use point clouds or rendered depth views. A single CADre refinement step can also involve many model calls, so matching the number of steps does not ensure a fair comparison. The point-cloud experiments help address the input difference, but model capability and inference budget still vary. A key missing comparison is a simpler agent given the same language model, geometry tools, inputs, and total inference budget.
Questions for authors
-
How much of the performance gain comes from the capabilities of the underlying VLM, and how much comes from the proposed framework? The image-only ablation uses the same model but also removes programmatic geometry access and the investigator. Could you compare CADre against a simpler single-agent loop using the same frontier VLM, geometry tools, inputs, and total inference budget?
-
What is the principal methodological advance over existing tool-augmented CAD systems? CAD-Assistant already demonstrates training-free CAD interaction and reverse engineering from 3D scans, while CADre adapts an existing generate–verify framework. Could you clarify which technical contribution goes beyond these prior approaches and provide evidence of its benefit?
-
How comparable are the information access and computational budgets across methods? CADre can query exact B-rep properties, whereas the baselines consume point clouds or rendered depth views, and one CADre refinement step can involve multiple model calls. Could you clarify whether the point-cloud inputs use comparable sampling and point counts, and report reconstruction accuracy against total inference cost rather than refinement steps alone?
5 comments
C3. Are the inference budgets comparable between CADre and the baselines?
The inference budgets are not directly comparable, as CADre makes multiple LLM API calls, whereas the baselines employ different inference procedures. Smaller specialized models may cost more over their lifecycle because they may require task-specific data, training, as well as retraining to benefit from newer backbone models. These introduce substantial development, computational, and maintenance costs that are not reflected in inference-only comparisons.
CADre instead leverages frozen frontier LLMs without task-specific training. And importantly, the capability can also be easily upgraded via the agentic harness as the base model gets better.
More broadly, the inference cost of proprietary LLMs is rapidly decreasing and is not necessarily more expensive than open-weight models. For example, on OpenRouter, GPT-6 Luna costs $0.10/$0.50 per million input/output tokens, compared to $0.25/$2.00 for Qwen3.6-27B. Crucially, CADre can benefit from increasingly capable and cost-efficient frontier models without task-specific retraining.
C4. How much of CADre's performance gain comes from the underlying VLM versus the proposed agentic workflow, and is multi-agent decomposition essential to its effectiveness?
We thank the reviewer for raising this question. We would like to clarify that our main contribution is an agentic workflow designed for autonomous CAD reverse engineering through programmatic geometric inspection, rather than a claim that multi-agent decomposition is inherently superior to a single-agent approach. In Table 2, our Image-only ablation is designed to answer the question: Is a powerful frontier VLM with visual feedback and iterative refinement sufficient for accurate CAD reconstruction?. In this ablation, we remove both the investigator and programmatic access, so the system represents a generic generate-verify refinement loop. The substantial performance drop shows that a powerful VLM with visual feedback and iterative refinement alone cannot account for CADre's reconstruction performance. Our second ablation, w/o Code inspection, aims to test the importance of code inspection for CAD reconstruction. This configuration keeps the investigator and other tools, but removes the ability to execute custom geometric queries. Reconstruction accuracy again decreases substantially, demonstrating that programmatic inspection is a key contributor to CADre's performance. Together, these experiments support the effectiveness of our CAD-specific agentic workflow and the importance of programmatic geometric inspection. These ablations are not intended to isolate the contributions of individual agent roles, as we do not claim that the particular decomposition into three agents is necessary or optimal. Our contribution lies in enabling frozen LLMs to autonomously reconstruct CAD geometry through programmatic inspection and iterative refinement, without learned 3D encoders or task-specific fine-tuning. We have revised the discussion of Table 2 in Section 4.4 (L466–480) to reflect this interpretation.
2. Questions and Clarifications
Q1. Could the authors report reconstruction accuracy against total inference cost rather than refinement steps alone?
We agree that refinement steps are not directly comparable across methods in terms of inference cost. Figure 3 is intended to illustrate refinement behavior rather than computational efficiency. We also provide detailed per-task cost breakdowns in Appendix A.2 (Tables 3–4), but acknowledge that these do not directly show the accuracy–cost relationship.
Thank you for your clarifications, I now have a more thorough understanding of the contributions of this paper. I now have 2 more concerns/questions, i will raise my score accordingly if you can give suitable explanations.
- the title is definitely not suitable for this paper. Is this the first work to reverse engineer cad without 3d encoder? From my understanding of your contributions now, 3d encoder free is not one of your contribution, this is very confusing and misleading.
2.How reliable is this framework? when will it fail? From your paper, the model will first use rendering of the target to grasp the general shape and begin investigation. If the target shape has inside structures, will this fail?
We thank the reviewer for the thoughtful questions and constructive feedback. We have revised the manuscript to clarify our approach and experimental comparisons.
1. Main Concerns
C1. What is CADre's principal methodological contribution beyond existing tool-augmented CAD systems such as CAD-Assistant?
We acknowledge that CAD-Assistant is an important conceptual precedent for using frozen LLMs with programmatic access to CAD geometry. However, CAD-Assistant primarily focuses on CAD question answering, sketch autoconstraining and sketch parameterization. Its reverse-engineering demonstration (Fig. 5, center) relies on a user-specified modeling procedure, including the slicing plane, extrusion operation, and extrusion length.
In contrast, CADre tackles autonomous CAD reverse engineering without user-specified procedure. We introduce a dedicated investigation stage in which the agent autonomously determines which geometric properties to inspect, writes programs to obtain these measurements, and synthesizes a reconstruction plan specifying the modeling operations needed to rebuild the target geometry. This goes beyond executing a user-provided modeling procedure. CADre further extends this approach to point clouds. We demonstrate that even without access to analytic geometry, the LLM can write programs to estimate the geometric properties it needs to reconstruct the shape autonomously.
Beyond this methodological distinction, we provide systematic quantitative evidence on 450 shapes across three CAD datasets under both B-rep and point-cloud inputs, demonstrating that training-free, encoder-free LLM agents can outperform specialized CAD reverse-engineering models on challenging shapes.
We have clarified these connections and CADre’s technical differences in Section 2 of the revised manuscript. (L160-175)
C2. How comparable is the geometric information available to CADre and the baselines?
We thank the reviewer for raising this question. The methods differ in how they make geometric information accessible to LLMs, and this distinction is central to the research question our work addresses. For example, CAD-Reasoner also starts from B-rep geometry but converts it into multi-view depth renderings before processing them with a trained neural network. In contrast, CADre treats B-rep as a queryable object, allowing the LLM to directly inspect the geometry through code execution, without a learned 3D encoder.
For point-cloud inputs, we sample 32,678 points from the target mesh, following DualBrep[1] and PI3DETR [2] (which use 32,768 points). CADre uses the full sampled point cloud by treating it as a queryable file. On the other hand, CAD-Recode and Cadrille further downsample the points to 256 as part of their respective preprocessing pipelines before feeding them into their neural networks. All methods obtain their geometric information from the same type of source. The difference lies in how each method processes and utilizes this information, rather than being given fundamentally different sources of geometry.
We argue that this distinction reflects an important advantage of our approach. By treating point clouds as queryable objects, CADre can flexibly inspect large point sets through programmatic queries, without being tied to a particular input resolution specified by a learned encoder.
Reference: [1] Liu et al., DualBrep: A Dual-Field Continuous Representation for B-rep Modelling. [2] Oberweger et al., PI3DETR: Parametric Instance Detection of 3D Point Cloud Edges With a Geometry-Aware 3DETR