- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
Finetuned some model on image --> CAD task, where image is a multi-view image (top / left / bottom / etc), and the output is a full parametric 3D CAD.
Small innovation on forcing the generated CAD program to be parsable with a syntax check (strcture aware ..)
Optimization is rather hard as CAD structure is quite discrete, so you cannot back-prop gradients, but you need some kind of RL to handle these discrete choices, which the authors do.
Critical strengths
It works well on the things they tested.
Critical weaknesses
They don't really test it on more complicated geometries, it seems the complexity of the generated CAD are <30 faces, or simpler. Only 3 extrusions or so.
Lack of a gallery. Papers like these at least need a 1 page "gallery" showing concrete datapoints of what the model can do. For example, if your paper is on image generation, have a gallery of 100 images generated by your neural network. If this work is img --> CAD, I'm expecting at least 20+ instances of image --> CAD examples, displayed proudly in the main text of the paper.
The fact that the authors did not display what they could generate proudly leads me to conclude they're worried that their actual results are not impressive.
Which also leads me to suspect if I just prompt GPT-astra and it would just 1 shot their task.
Questions for authors
Do baseline comparison against GPT astra. For a maximum budget of 100 dollars, at least.
Response to authors' feedback
Thank you for the response, which has addressed some of my concerns. However, I still believe that the current experiments do not provide strong enough support for the authors’ claims, so I find it difficult to raise my score to 3. I would consider a score of 2.5, but since this option is not available, I will keep my original score.
I also carefully read the other two reviewers’ comments and the authors’ follow-up responses. Unfortunately, the authors have not provided the additional experimental comparisons requested by these reviewers, such as comparisons with ReCAD and GPT-6 Astra. I therefore believe that the paper still needs further work, particularly in its experimental design and evaluation.