- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
TopoMamba predicts two-dimensional material-density fields using finite-element physical fields, explicit load–support features, and a four-direction Mamba backbone. Its distinctive mechanism is a spatially varying scalar gate between horizontal and vertical scan aggregates; predictions subsequently undergo optional SIMP refinement. The model is evaluated on the TopoDiff/NITO 2D benchmark: 30k training samples, 1,800 in-distribution (ID) and 1,000 out-of-distribution (OOD) test samples. The paper reports compliance error (CE), volume-fraction error (VFE), parameter count and end-to-end runtime, plus a single-seed ablation. The headline claims are 0.17% mean CE on ID and 1.07% on OOD with 10 SIMP steps, using 7M parameters and 0.48 s per design.
Critical strengths
TopoMamba has a reasonable motivation that use the relationship between loads and supports to guide how the model combines information from different spatial directions. The compact model and the reported results after SIMP refinement are encouraging. However, the current experiments leave substantial uncertainty about both the reliability of the predictions and the benefit of the proposed architectural changes that I have tried to outline in the weaknesses section below.
Critical weaknesses
It seems to me that the method distinction is the specific load–support representation and its use in a spatial scalar blend between row and column scan groups. However, Table 4 reports favorable but small absolute changes from the proposed relation and fusion components, without uncertainty estimates or sufficiently precise ablation definitions. These results neither establish negligible effects nor conclusively establish robust improvements. The paper consequently offers a promising engineering result without yet explaining how much its distinctive mechanisms contribute.
The ablations provide limited evidence for the distinctive contribution. Removing the load–support relations or adaptive fusion changes the reported errors much less than removing the inherited physical-field inputs, and no variation across training runs is reported. These smaller gains may be useful, but they need a controlled comparison with a standard four-direction backbone using the same inputs and training procedure, evaluated before and after refinement. The method description also needs to explain how relations defined at support nodes become features at every patch, since that operation is central to reproducing the proposed mechanism.
Physical-field conditioning is explicitly inherited from TopologyGAN, as secgtion 3.3 already acknowledges in your paper. Four-route visual state-space scanning is established by the cited VMamba. Learned prediction followed by a few SIMP steps is already central to NITO. So contribution (3), described as a prediction-optimization collaborative framework, is not independently new as presently specified and the claims should be clearly stated.
TO-MambaLDM already combines Mamba, physical conditioning, and topology generation, although for a different multiphysics cooling-design problem. Optimize Any Topology (OAT) addresses the same benchmark family and reports better mean CE than this paper’s baseline NITO. It is important to discuss both works and qualify the broad state-of-the-art claim by resource regime. A comparison with the OAT architecture is needed to establish performance claims, as it offers additional resolution and shape-dependency benefits.
The evaluation excludes predictions with compliance errors above 1000% without reporting how many predictions are removed for each method. Table 2 omits unrefined TopoMamba and OOD volume-fraction error, preventing assessment of the predictor’s standalone OOD performance and constraint satisfaction. Because refinement precedes binarization, the prescribed volume constraint during refinement alone does not establish feasibility of the final binary output; the thresholding procedure and OOD constraint results matter.
Overall, the reporting makes it difficult to judge robustness, since a low average among retained predictions can coexist with frequent failures. The paper should report failure rates, constraint violations, and results on common test conditions. It should also explain exactly what changes in the out-of-distribution test set and report accuracy and runtime at matching refinement budgets.
Several comparisons also mix refinement budgets (Tables 1–2). Such comparisons can describe complete systems, but cannot isolate the predictor’s advantage.
Questions for authors
See questions mentioned above.
8 comments
Response to Weaknesses 2: Controlled Ablations and Node-to-patch Mapping
R2. Controlled Ablations and Node-to-patch Mapping
We thank the reviewer for identifying the specific methodological distinction. To directly address concerns regarding effect, uncertainty, and mechanism clarity, we combine controlled ablation studies with mechanism .
First, to quantify each mechanism, we evaluate four configurations while holding the physical-field inputs, the scanning backbone, and all training settings strictly constant across three independent runs (Tables R3-1 and R3-2). Notably, the two-module ablation uses a standard four-direction backbone. While the absolute gains over the strong physical-field baseline are moderate, the results reveal systematic improvements in initial prediction quality and median compliance: relative to removing both modules, the full model reduces ID mean CE by 10.66%, 8.85%, and 7.38% at 0, 5, and 10 SIMP steps, and lowers OOD median CE by 8.46% and 6.91% at 0 and 5 steps. As SIMP iterations progress, physical refinement naturally narrows the gap, transparently showing that the primary value of these modules lies in providing a superior structural initialization.
Second, these quantitative gains are directly corroborated by our mechanism representation analyses. Specifically, linear probes on frozen features demonstrate that the relation-encoding branch successfully decodes explicit geometric relations, achieving an of in predicting FEA-derived critical load-bearing regions across the OOD set (substantially outperforming raw inputs at ). Furthermore, our analysis of the adaptive fusion module confirms that the network dynamically tailors directional blending to specific loading and boundary conditions predominantly via layer-wise weight modulation, rather than collapsing to uniform averaging. Together, the controlled ablations and mechanistic analyses demonstrate that both modules perform their intended physical roles.
Finally, we will clarify the exact node-to-patch mapping and feature integration pipeline in the revised manuscript:
-
Node-Grid Representation: On the finite-element node grid, we construct two seven-channel groups corresponding to the - and -displacement constraints. Each group encodes a load-presence indicator, two relative-displacement components, two normalized force components, a signed geometric moment, and squared distance, yielding 14 channels masked by the active supports.
-
Element-Level Aggregation: The relation CNN processes these inputs into 64-channel node features, and each element feature is computed by averaging its four corner-node features.
-
Feature Integration & Patch Embedding: A learned scalar gate scales the relation feature before adding it to the base conditioning feature, after which a patch embedding generates 256 spatial tokens for the Mamba backbone.
-
Geometry-Conditioned Routing: A separate routing path generates layer- and patch-specific row/column blending weights. Thus, relation encoding shapes the initial spatial representations, whereas adaptive fusion governs internal directional mixing during sequence propagation
Response to Weaknesses 3: Relation to Prior Components and Contribution
R3. Relation to Prior Components and Contribution
We thank the reviewer for pointing out the inaccuracies in our contribution statements. We do not claim that the combination of neural prediction and SIMP optimization is proposed here for the first time. Instead, we wish to clarify the original intent of Contribution 3, which aims to highlight the practical value of TopoMamba within a complete topology design pipeline: delivering high-quality initial material distribution via fast prediction, followed by a small number of SIMP iterations to further enhance mechanical performance, thereby achieving a favorable trade-off between structural quality and computational efficiency.
Accordingly, we have revised Contribution 3 in the manuscript as follows:
TopoMamba enables high-quality structural designs with only a few SIMP refinement steps, achieving a favorable balance between structural performance and computational efficiency.
Response to Weaknesses 1: Contribution of Relation Encoding and Adaptive Fusion
R1. Contribution of Relation Encoding and Adaptive Fusion
We thank the reviewer for identifying the specific methodological distinction: the load–support representation and its use in conditional blending of row- and column-scan features. To address concerns regarding effect sizes and ablation rigor, we provide a rigorous four-way controlled evaluation holding physical fields, the Cross4 backbone, and training settings strictly constant across three independent runs (reporting mean and sample standard deviation in Tables R3-1 and R3-2).
While the absolute performance gains over the already strong baseline are nuanced, the ablation results demonstrate systematic improvements in key regimes. Specifically, the full model consistently enhances initial prediction quality and median performance: relative to removing both modules, it reduces ID mean CE by up to 10.66% at 0 steps and decreases OOD median CE by 8.46% and 6.91% at 0 and 5 steps, respectively. This confirms that explicit relation encoding and adaptive fusion provide a superior starting point for downstream physical refinement.
As physical SIMP iterations increase (5 and 10 steps), iterative optimization naturally compensates for initial differences, causing performance gaps to narrow. Minor variations in specific metrics (such as OOD 0-step mean CE or 10-step median CE) transparently illustrate the boundaries of these modules—primarily serving as an effective initialization framework rather than replacing physical update
Table R3-1. Four-way controlled ablation with matched physical inputs and Cross4 backbone.
Table R3-2. Joint-module effect across SIMP budgets.