- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a geometry-grounded transformer architecture to predict the physical response of thin shells when they encounter moderate point impacts. The method is augmented with a new benchmark for this task using automotive data, and the paper shows that it outperforms or is competitive with the state of the art on all tests.
Critical strengths
The paper is mostly well written, and does a great job of intuitively justifying the need for the specific geometric representation used. It tackles an important problem in a way that outperforms the state of the art, and it does so while providing theoretical insights that will likely inspire future work. Given the usual replication crisis that plagues work on neural PDE surrogates, I also think that the benchmark is a great contribution for the community.
Critical weaknesses
In my opinion, the main weakness of the paper is in its justification and comparison to classical alternatives. The paper uses finite element analysis to generate training data: how does inference on this model compare to direct, classical finite element analysis? Is inference faster? The sentence in the introduction "parametric studies become expensive when these simulations..." seems to hint at this, but it is unclear if it's a general statement or it applies to this paper's specific problem setting. Any finite element method will have a tradeoff curve between accuracy and runtime as one decreases the grid/mesh resolution. Even discounting training time, where does this method's inference fall in relation to this curve? Some of this information is in Appendix J.2 but it is quite incomplete: what do the error of the two methods look like if the FE mesh / tolerances are reduced to match equal runtime? The same effort put into hyper parameter tuning of this method and baselines should be put into finding the optimal setting for FE, and then compared at equal time and equal error with the method proposed.
To be clear, I do not think it is necessary for the method to outperform classical FE analysis, but I really do think that "how well does this research line compare to traditional alternatives" is a critical question any paper on this topic should answer, comprehensively (and in the main text).
For such an application-driven paper, I also missed a result in which the neural surrogate is used for some real engineering task. For example, how good is the surrogate for tasks like shape optimization? Or to predict fracture with von Mises stress? After all, these are the motivations stated for the work. I don't think this is a massive problem precluding publication, but it would have made the paper stronger.
Finally, I believe the clarity of Sections 3.4-3.X should be improved. Currently, the text relies on the reader having knowledge of a prior work or reading sections of the Appendix to even understand most of the notation and get even just an intuitive understanding of how the architecture works. While I really appreciate the intuition in 3.3; if necessary, it can be compressed (after all, it seems somewhat intuitive that deformation depends on relative positioning to both the impact and the rest of the ship) in favor of a clearer and more complete explanation of the method.
Questions for authors
The main thing that would affect my assessment is an answer on the comparison against classical methods (see above). Where does the method compare to traditional FE on an error vs runtime tradeoff curve? Do the authors plan to include such a result in a revised version of the paper?
I would also appreciate if the related work section could be improved. For example, the difference between "graph-based physical modeling" and "neural operators and latent global interaction" is unclear to me. Don't graph neural network also "learn mappings between input and response fields"? Perhaps an introductory paragraph, a clarification of how these methods are related to the present paper, and clearer subheadings would be an improvement.
5 comments
Please Respond to the Authors’ Rebuttal
Dear Reviewer kika,
The discussion period ends in a few hours. Could you kindly check the authors’ responses and let us know whether your concerns have been addressed?
Thank you!
Best regards, The AC
Thanks, AC. It would be very helpful if the authors' revision had highlighted changes!
Response to Reviewer kika
Thank you for your constructive comments on the finite element comparison, engineering relevance, and clarity of the paper. We address these points below and describe the corresponding additions and planned revisions.
1. Accuracy–runtime comparison with finite elements
We thank the reviewer for suggesting an accuracy–runtime comparison with finite element analysis. We have added Section 4.6 and Figure 5, comparing GeoSlice-MGN with an FE mesh-resolution sweep on ten floorfrontdriver impact cases using a common numerical reference.
GeoSlice-MGN achieves a mean joint relative difference of 20.31% with a GPU forward-pass time of 15.33 ms per case, compared with 22.17% in 50.65 s and 17.49% in 61.77 s for the two coarser FE meshes. These results demonstrate comparable differences relative to the numerical reference at substantially lower execution cost, while finer FE meshes achieve smaller differences at higher cost.
2. Engineering relevance and application scope
Our work focuses on rapidly predicting displacement and von Mises stress fields in automotive floor panels under varying impact conditions. Excessive deformation may cause interference with surrounding components, while regions of elevated stress warrant further structural assessment. These responses are therefore relevant to engineering evaluation, but obtaining them across numerous impact conditions through nonlinear FE simulations is computationally expensive.
We evaluate the prediction accuracy on three vehicle-derived floor panels and further compare accuracy and execution cost against FE simulations at different mesh resolutions in Section 4.6. These results establish the accuracy and computational efficiency of the surrogate for the targeted prediction task. We agree that downstream applications would provide additional engineering validation. Shape optimization requires evaluation across changing design geometries, while fracture prediction requires additional failure modeling beyond von Mises stress. Both are valuable directions for future work.
3. A self-contained method description
Thank you for pointing this out. We agree that the method description should be self-contained and easier to follow without referring to prior work or the appendix. We will streamline the intuition in Section 3.3 and revise the subsequent sections to present the complete forward process, from local mesh encoding and geometry-conditioned slice assignment to occupancy-aware aggregation, global interaction, deslicing, and local refinement. We will also define the necessary notation and tensor dimensions alongside the corresponding operations to make the connections between modules clear.
4. Organization of related work
We agree that the previous organization did not clearly distinguish the perspectives of graph-based physical modeling and neural operators. Both can learn mappings from physical inputs to response fields, and graph-based computation can also be used within neural operators. Rather than treating them as separate categories, we have revised Section 2 to clarify their relationship and organize the discussion around local mesh propagation, global interaction, and geometry-aware modeling. The revised introduction and subheadings also make the connections between these approaches and GeoSlice-MGN more explicit.