- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This article proposes LiftGCN, a GNN surrogate model for predicting stress fields from finite element simulations in linear elasticity. The main contribution is a graph layer that projects the features onto the unit circle using the Joukowski transform, in order to better preserve local stress concentrations at a low computational cost. The authors compare it with several GNN models on three datasets and report a competitive overall accuracy and inference time.
Critical strengths
- The use of the Joukowski transform is an interesting way to limit the smoothing of local stress concentrations by standard GCN layers. It has a similar goal to more advanced spectral approaches, but is simpler and less costly.
- The paper is clearly written. The mechanical problem is well introduced, and the datasets, the graph construction and the training protocol are documented in detail in the appendices.
Critical weaknesses
- The contribution is somehow limited to a new graph layer for this mechanical problem. While this is interesting, the improvements should then be clearly significant and supported by an extensive evaluation, which is not completely the case here. The datasets used for the evaluation have very little variability. The model is only tested in linear elasticity, and within each dataset all the samples have the same load and boundary conditions. Only the material properties or the geometry vary between samples, within narrow ranges. As a result, the stress fields are very similar from one sample to another, and a simple GCN already gives good results. The method should be evaluated on more varied cases, with different loads and boundary conditions, or with nonlinear materials such as hyperelasticity or elastoplasticity, to show that it actually better preserves stress concentrations.
- The comparisons with the baselines are not always done in the same conditions. The small LiftGCN is presented as the fastest model on Mines Paris, but it has fewer layers than GCN. On the two other datasets, with the same number of layers, it is significantly slower than GCN. The latency comparison should be presented more fairly. The medium and large versions of LiftGCN also have many more parameters than the baselines, so their better scores may simply come from their larger size.
- There is no separate validation set. The checkpoint of each run is selected on the test set, which is also used to report all the results. In addition, only mean values over the 10 runs are reported, without standard deviations, while many of the differences between models are small. This makes it difficult to assess whether the reported improvements are significant and generalize to unseen data.
Questions for authors
- Why is LiftGCN slower than GCN on the two Abaqus datasets, while it is faster on Mines Paris? How do the two models compare with the same number of layers and the same width?
- How do the baselines perform when they have as many parameters as the medium and large versions of LiftGCN?
- The checkpoints should be selected on a separate validation set, and standard deviations over the 10 runs should be reported.
- How does the method perform on datasets with different loads and boundary conditions, or with nonlinear materials?
2 comments
Thank you for your detailed answers and the additional experiments. They clarify the points I raised, and the results on the new elastoplastic dataset are interesting. I will raise my rating accordingly.
Response to Reviewer FXaG
We sincerely thank you for your detailed and constructive comments. In particular, your concerns about dataset diversity, fair computational comparisons, and model capacity have helped us improve the experimental design and better characterize the scope of LiftGCN. We have uploaded a revised manuscript. Our responses are provided below.
Q3. Experimental protocol and statistical reliability.
We agree that selecting checkpoints based on test-set performance may compromise the reliability of the evaluation. We have therefore adopted a strict 70%/20%/10% training/validation/test split for each of the 10 independent runs (seeds 42–51). Checkpoints are selected using validation MSE, while the test set is used only for final evaluation. All relevant experiments have been rerun, and the revised manuscript reports mean ± standard deviation over 10 runs.
Q1. Fair latency comparisons with GCN.
Following your suggestion, we have revised the model configurations to ensure a more controlled comparison. Both GCN and small LiftGCN use the same number of layers and hidden dimensions, with closely matched parameter counts. The configurations and inference latencies are summarized below.
The results show that LiftGCN achieves inference latency comparable to GCN across the evaluated datasets. More importantly, our primary efficiency comparison is with UniGCN, which also employs unitary propagation to retain spectral information. On Mines Paris, small LiftGCN requires only 1.758 ms per mesh, compared with 18.866 ms for parameter-matched small UniGCN, achieving approximately 10.7× lower latency.
Q2. Parameter-matched comparisons.
We have added medium-sized UniGCN and Hybrid LG configurations on Mines Paris, with parameter counts closely matched to medium LiftGCN (3.299M, 3.323M, and 3.268M, respectively).
At the small scale, the three models achieve comparable results, with LiftGCN obtaining the highest PSNR@1%. More importantly, when increasing the model size from small to medium, the performance of UniGCN and Hybrid LG does not improve accordingly. Both models exhibit a slight decline in peak-region reconstruction and gradient accuracy. In contrast, LiftGCN improves consistently, with PSNR@1% increasing from 20.818 to 21.976 dB and HSG-NMSE@1% decreasing from 7.252 to 5.683.
This trend is also reflected in Figures 5 and 6. As model size and propagation depth increase, UniGCN and Hybrid LG tend to saturate or fluctuate, with some metrics even deteriorating. LiftGCN, on the other hand, exhibits consistent improvements across the tested configurations, benefiting from additional model capacity without sacrificing local reconstruction accuracy.
Q4. Evaluation under more diverse loading conditions and nonlinear material behavior.
To extend the evaluation beyond linear elasticity and fixed loading conditions, we have introduced a new Abaqus dataset: the Staggered-notch plate (Appendix B.2). This dataset uses elastoplastic steel with an initial yield stress of 355 MPa and subsequent plastic hardening. It contains 100 simulations with variations in notch depth (5–9 mm), axial force (28–58 kN), and load eccentricity (−6 to 6 mm). The resulting stress fields exhibit visibly different concentration patterns across samples, as illustrated in Figure 10(b). The key metric comparisons are summarized in the table below.
These results further demonstrate that LiftGCN achieves strong prediction accuracy while maintaining relatively low inference latency.