- Rating
- 4
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
GrowBrep proposes a new method for history free B-Rep generation in which the sequence output by the transformer creates a topologically closed shell by design. An innovative “grammar mask” keeps track of open halfedges and ensures that every halfedge receives one and only one mating halfedge. An ablation show this gives substantial gains in solid validity.
The method is shown to produce more complex bodies with higher validity than any of the “trained from scratch” baseline methods.
Critical strengths
The core idea of the paper, to design the sequence to ensure a topologically closed shell, makes a lot of sense. The results clearly demonstrate that approach delivers higher B-Rep validity. Low validity is the “achilles heel” of direct B-Rep generation.
Grammar mask is interesting and the ablation study proves that it adds value.
The details around the B-Rep checking (in the appendix) are very good. The authors have a good understanding of solid validity. Taking multiple samples and using the checker or CD to pick the best is a valid strategy. Good to see almost 90% for K=5
Paper is well written and avoids too much AI generated text (a refreshing change this year).
Critical weaknesses
Appendix A2 is for me one of the most impactful bits of the paper. Validity as a function of face count is the key metric for understanding direct B-Rep generation. GrowBRep beats all the baselines on this metric for sure. I would move this into the main paper if you have any extra space post review.
There are no comparisons with frontier LLMs. Sadly, these are now getting so good that “trained from scratch” methods are become unappealing. Hard to know how to compare with them for point cloud to B-Rep tasks. I believe they do well at image to B-Rep now.
The paper correctly states that the sequence ensures a topologically closed shell. The geometry/topology can still be inconsistent. Some snapping to work around this is described appendix B. I would consider having something in the introduction to acknowledge this.
Questions for authors
Interesting that you added a direction flag. I would have thought this could be worked out with geometric tests. Are there places where it actually helps? Does the post processing ever need to ignore the value from the ML.
Thank you for raising your score. The new experiments are in Appendix A.3 (Table 8) of the revised PDF, and they will stay in the final version. We agree the two figures can be clearer and will keep working on them.