- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The same solid volume can be represented by many different B-Rep shell topologies. For example, some modelling kernels can split periodic faces. In “LEARN THE SOLID, NOT THE FILE” the authors explore how these topological changes, often introduced by data exchange between modelling kernels, can cause catastrophic loss of robustness on downstream tasks. The lack of rotational invariance is also highlighted.
The authors provide a strategy for mitigating both problems. The B-Rep graph can be canonicalized by removing unnecessary edges between faces which share a geometrically identical underlying surface. The rotation invariance problem can also be fixed by transforming the B-Rep data into a canonical orientation based on the moment of inertia tensor of the shell.
Numerous experiments show these mitigations are effective.
Critical strengths
The authors show an important weakness in many academic B-Rep encoders. These encoders exhibit an over-reliance on the B-Rep topology, making performance on downstream tasks extremely fragile, especially when CAD models are passed between CAD systems.
Encoders often do not provide rotational invariance or equivariance. Consequently, changes in the pose of a solid can cause search and retrieval applications built on the embeddings to fail. The solution of moving the solid to the canonical coordinate system is a pragmatic fix to the problem.
The mitigations suggested by the authors are shown to be effective in all the experiments done. This is a major selling point for the value of the paper. The authors clearly show what is going wrong and how the problems should be fixed.
Why augmentation is not the answer This set of experiments was very interesting.
Critical weaknesses
This paper needs extensive re-writing by a person with good skills in English. Too much of it was impossible to understand due to what I suspect is a language barrier.
It turns out, the exact same solid can be represented by different B-reps: for example, two engineers using different operations, a geometry kernel rebuilding the file
This sentence is very unclear. You mean that the same boundary shape can be modeled by B-Rep shells with very different topologies.
We show that existing B-rep encoders are not robust to variation in the B-rep with the same solid on perturbations applied to standard benchmarks, naturally occurring variations inherent to CAD software, and differences in how designers model the same part via a human dataset we created in FreeCAD.
This sentence is very badly worded.
Appendix D
I’m very interested in the details of how the canonical frame is selected when two eigenvalues are (nearly) equal. The section in the main paper didn’t have enough detail, so I am closely reviewing the appendix section.
We resolve both. Axis signs are fixed by the solid’s third-order moments (its skew along each axis), exactly with a closed-form cubic over the mesh triangles
This is not enough. A reader will need to know exactly how this stuff was computed. What function was used in the CAD system? Did you triangulate and then use your own algorithm? The paper needs to get right down into the integral definition of the moment of inertial tensor and the computation of the third-order moments.
Proposition 1
I understand what the authors are getting at here. The proof makes sense. The weakness is that rational NURBS are capable of defining a single parametric surface which contains multiple primitives. Consider the extrusion of the following 2d NURBS curve.
Degree:
Knot vector:
Control points: (x,y,w)
0, 0, 1
1, 0, 1
2, 0, 1
3, 0, \sqrt{2}/2
3, 1, 1
After extrusion this will build a surface with both a cylindrical and planar section. This kind of surface is actually valid in formats like STEP and it’s quite common from surface modellers which NURBify arc-line sketches and extrude them into single surfaces. CAD software needs to cope with this kind of thing. The definitions leading up to Proposition 1 don’t cover this kind of weird example and consequently the uniqueness to the decomposition suggested by the authors doesn’t really hold. Another wired case to think about is when a T-spline model and then converted to B-Rep.
Questions for authors
Have you read
Vector Neurons: A General Framework for SO(3)-Equivariant Networks
Congyue Deng, Or Litany, Yueqi Duan, Adrien Poulenard, Andrea Tagliasacchi, Leonidas Guibas
This is the only paper I have seen which really addresses rotation invariance issues correctly.
Thank you for recognizing the importance of the robustness problem and the effectiveness of the proposed mitigations. We have revised the presentation substantially and address your questions below.
Clarity and presentation. We agree that the original wording obscured the central idea: the same geometric boundary can be represented by B-rep shells with different face and edge decompositions. The revised introduction states this explicitly. The method section now explains the purpose of each construction before introducing its details.
Moment computation and repeated eigenvalues. Appendix D now specifies the boundary-area integrals defining the centroid and inertia tensor, the OpenCASCADE routines used to compute them, and the integration procedure for third-order moments. We triangulate the faces and compute third moments using our own closed-form integration over each triangle. This is exact for the triangles; representing a curved surface by a mesh is still an approximation.
When two axes are ambiguous from repeated eigenvalues, the affected features retain quantities independent of rotation within that plane. For near repeated eigenvalues, directional information in the vector and tensor features is reduced gradually as the eigenvalue gap shrinks. Appendix D now explains these operations and their thresholds, including sign averaging and the separate treatment of region grid features.
Composite NURBS and Proposition 1. Your construction identifies a genuine limitation, which we reproduced. Grouping faces can remove subdivisions within a primitive region, but cannot separate a single face that spans both planar and cylindrical regions. We have revised the result to explicitly restrict the guarantee to primitive-compatible face decompositions: faces may subdivide primitive regions but cannot cross their boundaries.
Vector Neurons. We have now cited and evaluated Vector Neurons. Its rotation-equivariant architecture addresses orientation, while canonical-region construction addresses changes in face partitioning before encoding. Even a rotation-equivariant network can remain sensitive to replacing one face with several because its input graph changes. The VN comparison in our main response shows that canonical regions substantially reduce this sensitivity with an equivariant encoder as well. This supports the compatibility of our representation with different architectures.
We are happy to work with you to ensure that the method, its assumptions, and its contributions are clearly and accurately presented.