- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes BRepLift, a framework for reconstructing boundary representations from 3D meshes using shared 3D foundation features. The method employs a pretrained Utonia backbone with LoRA-based adaptation and face-level contrastive learning to obtain primitive-aware representations. These features are then used for clustering-guided face segmentation and subsequently shared with context-conditioned decoders for geometry and topology reconstruction.
Experiments on three test sets demonstrate improvements over existing methods, particularly DualBrep. The improvements are especially noticeable on geometrically complex shapes.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses the challenging problem of recovering structured CAD representations from unstructured 3D meshes. The proposed pipeline integrates primitive segmentation, geometry reconstruction, and topology prediction through a shared feature representation. The overall framework is reasonably motivated, and reusing geometric features across different reconstruction stages is an interesting design choice.
- The method demonstrates improvements over strong existing baselines across multiple datasets with different geometric and topological complexities. The paper also provides component-level ablations and qualitative comparisons, which help demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed pipeline.
Critical weaknesses
A central claim of the paper is that pretrained 3D foundation features provide useful geometric priors for B-Rep reconstruction. However, the current experiments do not sufficiently isolate the contribution of foundation pretraining itself. The ablation studies mainly compare pretrained Utonia features w/and w/o task-specific adaptation. While these results demonstrate the effectiveness of feature adaptation, they do not establish whether large-scale pretraining is necessary or beneficial compared with a backbone trained from scratch on the same B-Rep data. Personally, a more informative comparison would include:
- a randomly initialized backbone trained from scratch
- a frozen pretrained backbone
- a pretrained backbone with LoRA adaptation
- a pretrained backbone with full-parameter fine-tuning.
Such comparisons would help distinguish the contributions of pretraining and task-specific adaptation. Also, the benefit of sharing foundation features across reconstruction stages is not sufficiently isolated.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors compare the current pretrained Utonia backbone against the same backbone trained from scratch on the B-Rep training dataset? This would help establish whether the improvements arise from large-scale pretraining or primarily from the task-specific architecture and supervision.
- What motivates using LoRA adaptation only in the final backbone block rather than full-parameter fine-tuning? Can the authors provide a comparison between frozen pretrained features, LoRA adaptation, and full fine-tuning under the same supervision?
- For personal curiosity: how much of the remaining B-Rep invalidity is caused by primitive segmentation errors, geometry prediction errors, or topology assembly and post-processing? A quantitative breakdown would help identify the main bottlenecks of the complete pipeline.
3 comments
Q3: The benefit of sharing foundation features across reconstruction stages
Response: Please refer to the response of XqXd-W1.
Q4: Sources of Remaining B-Rep Invalidity
Response: We conduct a progressive oracle ablation on the ABC-ParSeNet test set, cumulatively replacing intermediate predictions with ground truth while keeping the remaining pipeline unchanged
- + GT segmentation: Use ground-truth face segmentation, retaining predicted geometry and edge existence.
- ++ GT topology: Replace edge-existence predictions with ground truth.
- +++ GT geometry: Replace predicted face and edge grids with their ground-truth counterparts.
| Setting | B-Rep validity (%) |
|---|---|
| Full predicted pipeline | 22.14 |
| + GT segmentation | 28.81 (+6.67) |
| ++ GT topology | 31.09 (+2.28) |
| +++ GT geometry | 53.54 (+22.45) |
GT segmentation improves validity by 6.67 points, primarily by restoring missed small and detailed faces and providing more accurate contexts for geometry reconstruction. Adding GT edge existence yields a smaller gain of 2.28 points. Correct connectivity alone cannot resolve geometric inconsistencies that prevent successful trimming and sewing during post-processing. Adding the GT geometry produces the largest gain, indicating that geometric accuracy is a major bottleneck.
Even with the oracle setting, validity reaches only 53.54%, indicating limitations of the discretized point grid representation and post-processing. GT grids require B-spline fitting, which introduces approximation errors. The optimization may perturb otherwise accurate geometry. Moreover, shared-vertex identification and boundary-wire construction remain heuristic.
After reviewing the rebuttal, I find that the authors have substantially addressed my main concerns. In particular, the additional comparisons with training from scratch and full fine-tuning provide useful evidence for the benefits of foundation pretraining and the parameter efficiency of LoRA. The oracle ablation also helps clarify the main bottlenecks affecting B-Rep validity.
There are still few ablations remaining, but I appreciate the additional experiments and consider the response sufficiently convincing overall. I will maintain my rating of 3.
W1 (Q1): Comparison of Pre-trained backbone
The comparison with training-from-scratch indicates that pretrained geometric priors substantially benefit both segmentation and reconstruction.
The from-scratch encoder uses the same backbone architecture and is trained from random initialization with the contrastive objective (Eq. 2) on the same B-Rep training data. The resulting encoder is then frozen, and downstream segmentation and reconstruction modules with the same architectures as ours are trained using the frozen features. We compare the from-scratch variant and ours on the ABC-ParseNet testset in three aspects: local cluster consistency, B-Rep face segmentation, and reconstruction.
Clustering. We measure local consistency using mean cluster purity, i.e., for each cluster, we compute the fraction of mesh vertices belonging to its dominant ground-truth B-Rep face mask, then average equally across clusters. Under the same clustering setting, the from-scratch encoder and ours achieve similar results (from-scratch vs. ours, 0.970 vs. 0.967), both exceeding unadapted Utonia (0.871). This suggests that task-specific adaptation is important for aligning local clusters with B-Rep faces.
Segmentation. Despite similar cluster purity, ours yields substantially better B-Rep face segmentation.
Reconstruction. With identical ground-truth contexts, ours outperforms the from-scratch across all reported geometry and topology metrics.
Q2: Comparison of Adaptation Strategy
LoRA adaptation achieves performance comparable to full-parameter fine-tuning while reducing trainable parameters across the overall pipeline from 155.92M to 19.33M (an 87.6% reduction). We restrict adaptation to the final backbone block to preserve the pretrained representations in earlier blocks. Under the same primitive-aware contrastive supervision and clustering configuration, LoRA and full fine-tuning achieve similar cluster purity (0.9669 vs. 0.9686), supporting LoRA as a parameter-efficient choice for promoting local feature consistency.
We compare frozen pretrained features, LoRA-adapted features, and fully fine-tuned features on the ABC-ParSeNet test set. LoRA adaptation and full fine-tuning use the same primitive-aware contrastive supervision. After adaptation, each encoder is frozen, and the downstream segmentation and reconstruction modules are trained using the same architectures and training settings.
Segmentation. Both adaptation strategies substantially outperform frozen pretrained features. LoRA achieves nearly identical matched mIoU and F1 scores to full fine-tuning, with higher precision but lower recall.
Reconstruction. With identical ground-truth contexts, LoRA and full fine-tuning achieve comparable reconstruction performance, with small differences across geometry and topology metrics.
The best results are shown in bold, and the second-best results in italics.