- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes LADA, which is a non-manifold surface reconstruction method from point cloud by learning-based point cloud grouping. It reconstructs each patch using an existing manifold reconstruction method and assembles the patches along explicitly recovered non-manifold curves.
Critical strengths
1. Clear idea and formulation. This paper proposes a clear and well motivated decomposition-and-assembly framework. Separating manifold patch reconstruction from junction connectivity provides a coherent way to reuse established reconstruction methods while explicitly constructing the non-manifold connections between patches.
2. Improvements in topological accuracy and solid analysis.
-
Although chamfer distance drops slightly, the reported results show marked reductions in Betti number and Euler characteristic errors. On the clean benchmarks, LADA achieves the lowest Euler characteristic error across all three datasets and the lowest errors in all three Betti numbers on Constructed and Non-manifold ABC.
-
This work includes comparisons of affinity-head inputs, pairwise prediction against per-point classification and distance regression, and a sweep of the affinity threshold. The decomposition ablations support the proposed pair descriptor and pairwise formulation, while the threshold sweep shows relatively stable edge classification performance over a broad range of thresholds.
Critical weaknesses
1. Practical significance and application scope. This work addresses a rather specialized task of recovering explicit non-manifold connectivity from point clouds through a pipeline that combines several existing technical components. While the reported improvements in topological accuracy are promising, the broader practical significance of this particular problem formulation remains insufficiently demonstrated. The method seems primarily applicable to scenarios where a point cloud represents a complete object composed of multiple manifold parts, but the underlying non-manifold connectivity between these parts is unavailable. However, it is unclear how commonly such scenarios arise in practical applications, raising concerns about the relatively narrow scope and potential downstream utility of the proposed method. I believe the paper would be more convincing if the authors provided concrete application scenarios that motivate this specific reconstruction problem, along with experiments or demonstrations showing how the explicitly recovered non-manifold structures provide meaningful benefits in those applications. In particular, demonstrating a practical use case that directly leverages the recovered non-manifold connectivity would help strengthen the significance of the work.
2. Limited evidence for broader generalization and analysis of what the learned decomposition distinguishes.
-
Training uses about 1k procedural or mesh-derived shapes, and the three test sets contain less than 100 examples in total. Although the study includes CAD-derived geometry and learned-field examples, the coverage of distinct local junction configurations and more complex object geometries remains insufficiently addressed. It is therefore difficult to assess how broadly the method generalizes beyond the configurations represented in the current datasets. Additional qualitative results on a wider range of challenging objects, particularly those with junction configurations or local feature scales that differ from the training data, would strengthen the work. Showing both successful reconstructions and representative failures would also help establish its range of applicability.
-
The current experiments do not clearly show how reliably the learned affinities distinguish non-manifold junctions from sharp or highly curved manifold features. Although sharp manifold hinges are included in training, the paper does not provide a targeted evaluation of this distinction. Controlled qualitative comparisons between sharp manifold surfaces and actual non-manifold junctions, under comparable geometric and sampling conditions, would be informative. Visualizing the predicted affinities and resulting patch assignments would help clarify the model’s behavior and provide stronger evidence that it performs the intended decomposition.
Questions for authors
Please refer weakness part.
1. Practical significance. Could the authors clarify the practical application or future contribution that would benefit from the proposed decomposition-and-assembly framework? A concrete example illustrating the value of explicitly recovered patches and junction curves, beyond the reported reconstruction metrics, would help establish its broader significance.
2. Evaluation coverage and generalization. Could the authors address more diverse topological configuration and geometric complexity, particularly whether the test sets contain configurations absent from training? Additional qualitative results on challenging held-out objects, together with representative failure cases, would help clarify the method’s generalization scope.
3. Distinguishing junctions from geometric features. Given that the training data include sharp manifold hinges, could the authors provide controlled comparisons between sharp or highly curved manifold surfaces and non-manifold junctions under comparable sampling conditions? Visualizations of the predicted affinities and resulting patch decompositions would help assess whether the method reliably distinguishes these cases.
I am willing to raise my score if my concerns are resolved.
4 comments
To further evaluate the generalization of our mehtod, We conducted additional experiments on 50 non-manifold shapes from the ABC dataset, selected using a different random seed. We believe these additional experiments help strengthen the experimental validation and address your concern regarding the limited number of test examples. The results are shown in the table below.
| Dataset | Method | #Success | Global CD | Non-manifold CD | Non-manifold [email protected] | [email protected] | [email protected] | |Δb₀| ↓ | |Δb₁| ↓ | |Δb₂| ↓ | |Δχ| ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Non-manifold ABC (Additional 50) | DCUDF | 50 | 0.00279 | NA | NA | NA | NA | 3.38 | 26.16 | 0.90 | 27.28 |
| DMUDF | 50 | 0.00311 | 0.0890 | 0.116 | 0.062 | 0.999 | 12.16 | 727.74 | 4776.30 | 4060.72 | |
| MIND | 50 | 0.00318 | 0.0190 | 0.828 | 0.777 | 0.914 | 129.52 | 23.82 | 127.82 | 236.76 | |
| DCx | 50 | 0.00278 | 0.0073 | 0.904 | 0.846 | 0.982 | 0.90 | 9.78 | 40.16 | 32.48 | |
| SALS | 50 | 0.00284 | 0.0758 | 0.227 | 0.131 | 0.997 | 12.04 | 893.62 | 661.92 | 543.38 | |
| Ours | 50 | 0.00284 | 0.0069 | 0.937 | 0.938 | 0.937 | 0.04 | 0.46 | 0.48 | 0.94 |
I appreciate the response and the additional experiments. I agree that the method improves what it targets (especially non-manifold edge recovery), and the new multi-view results are consistent with this. However, I do not find this sufficient to fully resolve my concerns, so I will keep my score.
My final rating is mainly based on the following points.
- Problem setting and significance (W1). The quantitative benchmarks sample points from ground-truth meshes, including interior sheets that typical surface scanning would not observe. The applications named in the rebuttal start from neural fields rather than point clouds, and no scanned point cloud is used directly as input. They show where non-manifold surfaces appear, but not that the recovered connectivity brings a downstream benefit.
- Generalization (W2). Non-manifold ABC, including the additional 50 shapes, uses different base models but the same intersection procedure as the training data. The out-of-distribution cases (14 QMDF fields, 3 multi-view scenes) have no ground-truth curves and rely on manual topology labels.
That said, I consider this a borderline paper. Although I am slightly leaning toward rejection, the improvement on its target is real, and my rating reflects the remaining concerns above rather than a flaw in the method itself.
We sincerely thank you for the careful evaluation and response. We would like to clarify your concerns.
-
Problem setting and significance. We would like to clarify a potential misunderstanding regarding our target problem. The primary applications of non-manifold reconstruction are not conventional surface scanning, since internal structures are generally invisible to surface scanners. Instead, as discussed in our paper, important applications include transparent multi-view reconstruction and medial axis extraction. Indeed, the output of many medial axis methods is point cloud instead of distance field. We use point clouds as input because they provide a more general representation than UDFs. In particular, point clouds can be readily derived from a UDF by projecting sampled points onto its zero level set, whereas learning a UDF from point clouds is non-trivial. Our framework also supports UDF-derived inputs. We will clarify this distinction in the revised manuscript.
-
Generalization. Intersections provide a simple and effective way to generate abundant non-manifold models for quantitative evaluation, following the data-generation procedure used in SALS. Although the same intersection procedure is adopted, we do not believe that the resulting models necessarily share the same distribution, since their geometric characteristics depend heavily on the underlying shapes. In particular, the ABC CAD models have substantially different geometric styles and structures from our training data, which consists of no more than 4 planar shapes and 93 Thingi10K models. Thus, these experiments evaluate generalization across different underlying geometric models, rather than merely reproducing the training examples. Moreover, the Constructed data (See Appendix) are not generated from intersections. Furthermore, medial axis extraction and transparent multi-view reconstruction demonstrate the applicability of our method to substantially different practical scenarios. Although these applications do not provide ground-truth non-manifold curves for quantitative evaluation, they offer complementary evidence of the practical value and versatility of our method beyond intersection-based benchmarks.
We sincerely thank you for the careful evaluation of our manuscript and the insightful and constructive comments. We address each concern in detail below.
Practical significance and concrete application scenarios of explicit non-manifold surface reconstruction (W1, Q1)
Non-manifold surfaces are essential in at least three practical scenarios. First, the medial axis extraction: medial axes are inherently non-manifold along sheet junctions, and while methods like Q-MDF learn accurate UDFs, our method overcomes the junction connectivity bottleneck to extract explicit meshes (shown on QMDF). Second, real-world scene reconstruction involving transparent objects, where transparent and opaque surfaces usually meet along non-manifold junctions; our method extracts explicit meshes from multi-view learned distance fields, as shown on three new scenes (see Fig. 5 in the Revision PDF). Third, remeshing AIGC-generated 3D models with explicit non-manifold connectivity to optimize topology for animation and gaming.
Evaluation coverage, broader generalization, and representative failure cases (W2, Q2)
Our training and validation sets are generated from no more than 4 planar meshes and 93 Thingi10K models, augmenting them via random poses, scales, and positions into 1,800 intersecting shapes (1,200 from planar meshes and 600 from Thingi10K). Hence, the training and validation data sets only involve less than 100 independent models. We evaluate zero-shot on 31 Constructed shapes, 50 Non-manifold ABC shapes, and 14 QMDF fields. Despite using intersection operations, the styles of ABC's CAD models are clear different from Thingi10K's models. To broaden the generalization evaluation, we further evaluate three multi-view reconstructions tasks (see Fig. 5 in the Rebuttal Revision PDF). Our method again recovers a continuous sequence of non-manifold edges along each non-manifold curve, without introducing edges elsewhere. By contrast, DCUDF detects no non-manifold edges. DMUDF and SALS distribute non-manifold edges across the surfaces. For the Jug, MIND produces fragmented chains with nearby holes and DCx yields broad, irregular bands of non-manifold edges.
The Limitations section shows failure cases. When a rectangular strip connecting two parallel squares narrows from 0.05 to 0.04, its two non-manifold edge chains merge and the strip vanishes. Because points across the two curves lie too close, the network cannot distinguish the thin structure from noise, and cross-curve KNN connections render both features and predicted affinities unreliable.
Distinguishing non-manifold junctions from sharp or highly curved manifold features (W2, Q3)
As shown in Fig. 3 (rows 1–2), our test sets contain abundant sharp manifold features (e.g., sharp edges of the tree model and the creases of the CAD model). Our model reliably groups points across sharp manifold creases into the same patch rather than incorrectly splitting them at non-manifold junctions. To further illustrate this behavior, we added targeted visualizations comparing patch decompositions at sharp manifold features and non-manifold junctions (see Fig. 12 in the revision PDF).
Even if manifold sharp features were split across manifold patches, this would not impair the reconstruction and might even help recover these sharp features.