- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduce a method for improving the topology of meshes generated by Trellis2. It keeps the original OVoxel representation and the decoder, states that Stage-2 shape-SLat generation is the major source of topology irregularity. The method decomposes each mesh-level group-relative advantage into additive token-wise attributions that exactly preserve the global advantage, then use an anchored dual-branch optimization to further improve the result quality. The methtod is evaluated on many benchmarkes and have reduced in non-manifold and boundary elements., while still maintain good surface distance metric.
Critical strengths
The method is well motivated. With the Trellis2 representation, the main issue is the open-edges and topology issues including holes in the generated mesh. The diagnostic is reasonable. The solution is also follows the supported finding in the dignostic process and the method is reasonable.
The evluation result is promising. The result show consisten imporvements over the originial trellis 2 model, while the quality is largely remain keept.
Critical weaknesses
The paper is awkwardly written. It more liked a generarted report than a research paper. Some terms like 'group-relative advantage' and 'token-wise advantage attributions' reads strange to me, maybe I lack some domain konwledge here.
The overall contribution is somewhat limited and a bit ad-hoc. There should be more systematic way to solve the problem, the currrent solution is more like analysis the Trellis2 and fixed the problem as what is shows.
The visual evaluaton is only on simple shapes and low token counts. I'd like to see stress test on high token counts and complex shapes.
Questions for authors
My first question is how much AI is being used to generate the submission.
Can the author discuss why the related work is put at the last? and the intention of having so many packed math in sec 3.3?
Can the author speaks more on how he evaluaton is conducted? is this performed on generation taks (from rendered image?) or on reconstruction tasks?
4 comments
Q1. Use of AI
A. As stated in the AI Use Statement of our paper, we used ChatGPT as an assistive tool, primarily for language editing and literature searches.
We made all methodological decisions, established the experimental protocols, and interpreted the results. We obtained all reported results using our own experimental pipelines.
Q2. Paper Organization and Mathematical Presentation
A. We originally placed Related Work after the experiments to highlight our contributions earlier. Relevant prior work is also discussed in the Introduction. This structure is also used in recent papers such as SAM 3D (CVPR 2026) [1], FlowR (ICCV 2025) [2], and two ICLR 2025 Outstanding Papers [3, 4]. We have adopted the suggestion and moved the Related Work section after the Introduction in the revised manuscript.
The mathematics in Sec. 4.3 explains why we use the anchored dual-branch objective. Direct negative weighting makes the flow-matching loss unbounded below. Our anchored negative branch keeps the loss bounded below while preserving the signed gradient at the sampling-model prediction. The proposition proves this property.
References
[1] Chen et al., SAM 3D: 3Dfy Anything in Images, CVPR 2026.
[2] Fischer et al., FlowR: Flowing from Sparse to Dense 3D Reconstructions, ICCV 2025.
[3] Fang et al., AlphaEdit: Null-Space Constrained Knowledge Editing for Language Models, ICLR 2025 Outstanding Paper.
[4] Qi et al., Safety Alignment Should Be Made More Than Just a Few Tokens Deep, ICLR 2025 Outstanding Paper.
Q3. Evaluation Setup and Experimental Design
A. Our main experiments evaluate single-image-conditioned 3D generation on four test benchmarks. Each input image is rendered from a ground-truth mesh, which is never provided to the generator and is used only for rendering and geometric-fidelity evaluation.
The reconstruction pipelines in Sec. 3.2 are separate diagnostic experiments. The test benchmarks, evaluation metrics, and protocols are detailed in Sec. 5.1 and Appendix B.5.
The evaluation setup is described in the "Experimental Setup" subsection.
Thanks for the updates. The visual result in the video although provide better numerics, the visual resutls are not nesseary improving from TRELLIS.2. There are still visible holes in the TopoFT, espeically the last three examples in the video, it is hard to say the TopoFT results are improved from TRELLIS.2.
This is a good submission, but still not conviencing enough. Especially the cliam in the rebuttal the method works beyond fixing TRELLIS.2 is a bit bold.
Thank you for your further comments.
1. Visual Result
To make the visual differences easier to examine, we have added enlarged comparisons of all examples from the supplementary video (Figs. 8–11 in the Appendix), including the last three examples mentioned in your comment. We did not select examples based on the extent of improvement.
The enlarged views show that TopoFT reduces many small holes, fragmented surfaces, and local irregularities present in TRELLIS.2, including on complex structures.
We acknowledge that some irregularities remain, particularly in highly complex shapes. TopoFT aims to reduce topology irregularities rather than guarantee fully manifold or watertight meshes.
2. Generality beyond TRELLIS.2.
To further investigate the applicability of TopoFT beyond TRELLIS.2, we conducted an additional experiment on LATO.2 [1], a flow-based 3D mesh generator developed as an extension of LATO (ICML 2026) [2].
Unlike TRELLIS.2, which generates shape-SLat features and decodes them into meshes through O-Voxel, LATO.2 separates vertex generation from topology generation. Its V-Flow generates vertex positions, while T-Flow generates per-vertex topology latents that are decoded into mesh connectivity.
We adapted both two components of TopoFT to LATO.2. Specifically, we attribute mesh topology irregularities to the corresponding T-Flow tokens and apply anchored dual-branch optimization to its velocity predictions. We keep V-Flow frozen and fine-tune only T-Flow.
Due to the limited rebuttal time, we performed only 400 optimization steps using the Objaverse-XL training pool, which is separate from the GSO test set. We then evaluated pretrained LATO.2 and its TopoFT variant on GSO.
| Topology Metric | Pretrained LATO.2 | TopoFT |
|---|---|---|
| NME (%) ↓ | 13.09 | 5.47 |
| NMV (%) ↓ | 1.21 | 0.26 |
| BND (%) ↓ | 4.42 | 1.43 |
| Geometric Fidelity | Pretrained LATO.2 | TopoFT |
|---|---|---|
| Chamfer (×10⁻²) ↓ | 0.61 | 0.60 |
| P95 (×10⁻²) ↓ | 1.20 | 1.15 |
| F-score @ 0.01 (%) ↑ | 89.59 | 90.39 |
Despite only 400 optimization steps, TopoFT substantially reduces all three topology irregularity ratios while maintaining comparable geometric fidelity. More details are in Appendix F.
These preliminary results provide evidence that both components of TopoFT can be transferred to a different mesh-generation architecture. While broader validation is still needed, they suggest that our approach has the potential to extend to other flow-based 3D mesh generators.
We hope this additional experiment helps clarify the scope and potential generality of our method.
[1] Long, H., et al. (2026). LATO.2: Factorized 3D Mesh Generation with Vertex and Topology Flow. arXiv:2607.10623.
[2] Zhao, T., et al. (2026). LATO: 3D Mesh Flow Matching with Structured TOpology Preserving LAtents. Proceedings of the 43rd ICML.
We thank the reviewer for their thoughtful comments and valuable questions.
W1. Writing and Terminology
A. Our paper progresses from controlled diagnosis (Sec. 3.2) to method development (Sec. 4) and experimental validation (Sec. 5).
Regarding terminology, group-relative advantage follows the established GRPO formulation introduced in DeepSeekMath (Shao et al., 2024) and subsequently adopted for flow-matching models in Flow-GRPO (Liu et al., NeurIPS 2025). It measures each sample's relative quality within a group.
Token-wise advantage attribution decomposes the sample-level advantage into token contributions whose sum equals the original advantage, as defined in Eq. (10). We use attribution to emphasize this additive relationship.
References
[1] Shao et al., DeepSeekMath: Pushing the Limits of Mathematical Reasoning in Open Language Models, 2024.
[2] Liu et al., Flow-GRPO: Training Flow Matching Models via Online RL, NeurIPS 2025.
The terminology definitions are provided in the Method section.
W2. Contribution and Generality
A. Recent diffusion- and flow-matching-based 3D generation frameworks have made substantial progress in generation quality and efficiency. However, the generated meshes can still contain topology irregularities. We address this common problem through post-training, with two main components.
Mesh-to-token topology attribution. Applying the same mesh-level feedback to all tokens does not distinguish which regions contribute to topology irregularities. We attribute mesh-level topology irregularities to individual latent tokens, providing localized optimization signals. The same attribution principle could apply beyond TRELLIS.2 to other 3D generators whose decoded mesh regions can be linked to latent tokens.
Anchored dual-branch optimization. The positive branch reinforces token targets with favorable topology feedback. The negative branch uses the current model prediction as a reference to discourage fitting targets with unfavorable feedback. We incorporate positive and negative topology feedback into flow matching through an objective that remains bounded below. The optimization uses flow predictions and signed feedback, so it could also be applied to latent flow-matching models beyond TRELLIS.2.
We use TRELLIS.2, a representative architecture, to evaluate the proposed approach. TopoFT improves topology across four test benchmarks while maintaining comparable geometric fidelity (Tables 1–2). Although our experiments focus on TRELLIS.2, the two components are not inherently restricted to this architecture and could be adapted to other latent flow-based mesh generators.
W3. High-Token-Count and Complex-Shape Evaluation
A. We have added a supplementary comparison video featuring more challenging geometries and higher token counts, such as engines and castles (see the newly attached video).
It reports normalized rates and relative reductions for non-manifold edges, non-manifold vertices, and boundary edges. The results show that TopoFT substantially reduces topology irregularities even for complex shapes, while preserving geometric fidelity.