- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces a mesh extraction approach from (neural) UDFs. While SDFs can represent only closed & manifold surfaces, UDFs can represent open & non-manifold surfaces. Due to this property, the mesh extraction algorithms for UDFs should handle the non-manifoldness. The most prominent problem is the non-manifold edges, where multiple smooth surfaces meet with each other, and create junctions. This work delves into this problem, and provides a solution that extracts topologically cleaner meshes from UDFs than the other baseline methods.
The work seems to be inspired by the two baseline methods: 1) DCUDF2, and 2) VoroCrust. This work starts its extraction process from the double layer proxy of the surface from DCUDF2. This baseline work produces meshes of good geometric quality, but it removes the non-manifold edges by creating false structures near the junctions. To amend this issue, this work leverages the similar apporach as VoroCrust, to sample ball covers on the double layer proxy. With these ball covers and hand-crafted hyperparameters, this approach provides a theoretical guarantee about the surface approximation quality. Also, to produce geometrically more accurate mesh, this approach designs multi-stage approach, to get coarse approximation of the underlying surface in the first step and fine-tune the mesh in subsequent steps to get more accurate mesh.
To validate their approach, authors provide the comparisons with the other baseline methods in diverse scenarios: 1) objects with non-manifoldness, 2) objects with complex inner structure (car), and 3) manifold objects (other scenarios are in Appendix as well). They also provide ablations about the hyperparameters they selected in their algorithm.
Critical strengths
-
Robust mesh extraction for non-manifold objects: As UDFs can represent non-manifold shapes, the mesh extraction algorithms for UDFs should faithfully reconstruct the non-manifoldness in the output. In terms of this, this algorithm shows more robust outputs compared to the other approaches.
-
Theoretically sound approach: This algorithm is theoretically grounded on the Voronoi diagram and ball coverings, so geometrical & topological properties are guaranteed.
Critical weaknesses
While authors claim that their method can handle all kinds of geometry under single pipeline (line 428-431), I don't think this is correct statement. I think this algorithm is particularly useful for handling the non-manifold cases, while the baseline works (DCUDF, DCUDF2) focus on the closed manifold cases. As shown in the Table 1 and 2, these baseline works generate manifold surfaces, which are usually more desirable in many downstream applications. Therefore, I'm not convinced that this work is better than these baseline approaches for every geometrical structures. Also, as this method heavily relies on DCUDF2 to first extract the double layer structure (which also accounts for almost half of the computation time), I feel this method is kind of incremental work.
One follow-up question in terms of this -- can you also report the number of non-manifold cases in Table 3 (when the GT geometry is manifold)? If VoroFacet guarantees to generate manifold mesh for these cases I think the claim would become stronger. At least, as this method starts from DCUDF2's double layer structure from the beginning, I think the authors should show that it should not harm DCUDF2's manifoldness property when the GT shape is manifold as well.
Questions for authors
No particular questions that affect my assessment.
5 comments
Responses to Reviewer NGep (2/2)
Comment 2: Also, as this method heavily relies on DCUDF2 to first extract the double layer structure (which also accounts for almost half of the computation time), I feel this method is kind of incremental work.
Response: Thank you for raising this concern. VoroFacet introduces a connectivity construction distinct from DCUDF2’s deformation-based extraction. DCUDF2 supplies a near-surface geometric proxy; VoroFacet neither modifies its deformation algorithm nor inherits its mesh connectivity. Instead, ball-induced Voronoi facet selection and junction-aware re-extraction construct a single-layer surface with shared vertices and edges at junctions. The proxy guides local facet selection, for which a double-cover topology is not itself a requirement.
We have also added a controlled experiment replacing DCUDF2 with DCUDF while keeping the learned UDFs and all downstream parameters unchanged (Appendix B, Table 6). Surface accuracy remains comparable, and NM-F1 reaches 62.15 with the DCUDF proxy, exceeding the strongest baseline, DCx (53.19). These results demonstrate that VoroFacet does not require DCUDF2 specifically. More broadly, separating geometric approximation from connectivity construction allows proxy generation to focus on geometric fidelity while VoroFacet reconstructs the shared surface connectivity.
Follow-up on our response
Dear Reviewer NGep,
Thank you again for your thoughtful review. In response to your concerns, we have:
- Clarified our unified single-layer extraction pipeline, which requires neither user-specified surface types nor min-cut layer separation. We also report the requested numbers of outputs with non-manifold edges and compare self-intersections across methods on manifold inputs (Table 9).
- Clarified the novelty beyond DCUDF2, explaining how Voronoi facet selection and junction-aware re-extraction construct new connectivity rather than inherit the proxy’s. The DCUDF-proxy experiment further shows that VoroFacet does not require DCUDF2 specifically (Table 6).
As the discussion period is coming to a close, we would be grateful to know whether these address your concerns, or if there is anything else we can clarify.
Best regards, The Authors
Responses to Reviewer NGep (1/2)
Thank you for your time and thoughtful review. We appreciate your recognition of VoroFacet’s robust non-manifold reconstruction and its foundation in Voronoi geometry. We address your concerns below.
Comment 1: While authors claim that their method can handle all kinds of geometry under single pipeline (line 428-431), I don't think this is correct statement. I think this algorithm is particularly useful for handling the non-manifold cases, while the baseline works (DCUDF, DCUDF2) focus on the closed manifold cases. As shown in the Table 1 and 2, these baseline works generate manifold surfaces, which are usually more desirable in many downstream applications. Therefore, I'm not convinced that this work is better than these baseline approaches for every geometrical structures. ... One follow-up question in terms of this -- can you also report the number of non-manifold cases in Table 3 (when the GT geometry is manifold)? If VoroFacet guarantees to generate manifold mesh for these cases I think the claim would become stronger. At least, as this method starts from DCUDF2's double layer structure from the beginning, I think the authors should show that it should not harm DCUDF2's manifoldness property when the GT shape is manifold as well.
Response:
Thank you for raising this concern. For non-manifold targets, DCUDF and DCUDF2 retain a manifold double cover rather than a single-layer surface with shared junction connectivity. Although these overlapping layers can render accurately, they contain extensive self-intersections: on Non-manifold Objects, 68.352% and 43.947% of triangles are affected on average, respectively (Appendix B, Table 8). Such outputs cannot directly serve as the single physical sheet required by applications such as thin-shell simulation. Manifold connectivity alone therefore does not establish suitability for these downstream uses.
DCUDF’s single-layer recovery requires user-specified surface types to select the appropriate post-processing, including min-cut separation for orientable surfaces with boundary. In our manifold-object experiments, we enable min-cut for both DCUDF and DCUDF2, yet two outputs from each method still retain double layers, substantially increasing their mean self-intersection percentages. VoroFacet instead reconstructs single-layer surfaces through Voronoi facet selection, without user-specified surface types or min-cut layer separation.
We have added the requested statistics for all methods on the 50 Manifold Objects in Appendix B, Table 9, with the relevant comparison below. Triangle percentages are reported as mean ± standard deviation across all 50 objects; NM-incident triangles are those incident to non-manifold edges.
VoroFacet does not guarantee strict manifoldness: 46 outputs contain non-manifold edges. However, their incident triangles account for 1.321% of all triangles on average, while self-intersections involve only 0.070%. These reconstructions also achieve the lowest mean CD on Manifold Objects, 4.515 versus 4.529 for DCUDF and 4.528 for DCUDF2 (Table 2). Our unified-pipeline claim refers to this ability to reconstruct single-layer surfaces across manifold, open-boundary, and non-manifold inputs without switching extraction procedures according to surface type.