- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Riemannian Orthogonal Decoupling Representation (RODR), a geometry-aware framework for continuous 3D surface recovery from noisy point clouds. The core idea is to decouple ambient Euclidean spatial updates into normal-direction surface fitting and tangent-direction point redistribution via orthogonal subspace projections. Additionally, a multi-scale planarity gate is introduced to dynamically suppress tangential flow near sharp geometric discontinuities, preventing feature over-smoothing. The paper provides theoretical analyses of the projected dynamics and validates the method across standard denoising benchmarks, dense CAD models, and real-world LiDAR data. The evaluation reports standard reconstruction metrics as well as LMFR, a metric used to measure local surface thinness.
Critical strengths
The paper provides a clear geometric interpretation of normal-direction surface attraction and tangent-direction point redistribution. Their explicit separation into complementary subspaces offers a simple formulation for controlling off-surface deviations in dense CAD recovery.
The dense-CAD experiments show improvements in LMFR, suggesting a potential benefit in reducing artificial manifold thickness. The cross-sectional visualizations provide complementary qualitative evidence.
Critical weaknesses
-
The methodological novelty of RODR is unclear. RODR maps the fitting and uniformity forces onto normal and tangent subspaces, respectively, but the underlying normal/tangent decomposition and orthogonal projection are standard geometry. It is unclear what fundamentally new methodological ingredient RODR introduces beyond this formulation.
-
The specific meaning of “Riemannian” in this paper could be clarified. While the paper motivates the formulation through the Riemannian manifold hypothesis, the proposed decoupling itself appears to be based on the normal/tangent decomposition and orthogonal projections. It would be helpful to clarify whether “Riemannian” refers primarily to this manifold interpretation or to an additional methodological property of the proposed method.
-
In Table 2, applying the orthogonal loss alone improves LMFR but degrades the P2F metric compared to the baseline. The significant P2F gain only appears after adding the Distance Magnitude Head. A deeper analysis is needed to isolate whether the orthogonal decoupling itself is inherently effective or if it relies heavily on the distance head to prevent overshooting.
-
In Table 5 (PUNet/PCNet), the proposed method does not show a consistent advantage across all metrics/resolutions compared to recent methods. Additionally, while Appendix F explores extreme noise on a thin plate, evaluation under higher noise levels (e.g., 3%) on complex 3D CAD benchmarks is needed, as local normal/tangent subspace estimation naturally degrades under strong noise.
Questions for authors
-
What is the key methodological novelty of RODR beyond the standard normal/tangent decomposition and orthogonal projection? Could the authors clarify which component of the proposed formulation is fundamentally new?
-
What specifically does “Riemannian” refer to in RODR beyond the underlying Riemannian manifold hypothesis?
-
Could the authors clarify why applying the orthogonal loss alone degrades the P2F metric compared to the baseline, and whether the performance gain relies primarily on the Distance Magnitude Head?
-
Given the mixed results in Table 5, could the authors clarify RODR's clear operational advantage over recent methods and provide evaluation results on complex 3D CAD models under higher noise levels (3%)?