- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper focuses on fingerprint generation that is controllable by selected task-defined factors. The challenge is to modify the target attributes without altering the ridge strcutures and other correlated semantics of the fingerprint. A two-stage approach is introduced in the paper: the first stage learns latent representations while the second stage disentangles factors and exchanges selected factors through residual refinement. Experiments on two datasets show the effectivenss of the proposed method.
Critical strengths
-
The motivation of the control problem is explained clearly. The paper clearly distinguishes selective attribute control from visual quality.
-
The paper is well-structured and easy to follow.
-
The authors show that their proposed method can also generalize to Shape3D.
Critical weaknesses
-
There are similar attribute disentanglement and synthesis methods from other attribute control tasks [1][2] except they use GAN. This paper mainly focuses on the fingerprint generation task, but I did not see a model design to address challenges specific for the fingerprint task.
-
The metrics lack an explicit evaluation on minutiae preservation and fingerprint identity preservation. The reported metrics are reconstruction scores, DCI, and classifier-based CFSS, which do not directly establish preservation of minutiae or fingerprint matchability. I suggest the authors to refer to GenPrint paper on the evaluation.
-
The authors mentioned that controllable fingerprint generation can be used to synthesize data in some downstream tasks where real data are difficult to acquire. I suggest the authors add an experiment on one such downstream task using the fingerprint images synthesized by their method to evaluate its generalization ability.
Questions for authors
In the introduction, the authors address the importance of keeping the ridge strcuture unchanged after controllable generation. Is there a specific design choice in the model that can improve the preservation of the ridge structure? If there is, can the authors provide ablationon that?
Clarification of the motivation of model design, identity-related structure preservation, and downstream utility
We sincerely thank you for your time and effort in reviewing our manuscript and for your insightful comments. We appreciate your positive assessment of the clear motivation, the distinction between selective attribute control and visual quality, the paper’s organization, and the applicability of our approach to Shapes3D. Your suggestions have helped us clarify our design rationale and strengthen the evaluation of identity-related structure preservation and downstream utility. We address your comments below:
1. Clarification of the motivation behind the model design
Thank you for your insightful comments. We address the connection between our model design and the fingerprint task, as well as the role of this design in ridge structure preservation below.
(1) Motivation of model design . Our design is motivated by the fingerprint control task: modifying a target attribute, such as material, while preserving identity-related ridge structure and other non-target information. To support this goal, TRACE learns factor-aligned latent blocks from task-defined labels and generates images by explicitly swapping the target block. Thus, the connection to the fingerprint task lies in the factor-structured representation and selective exchange mechanism, rather than a fingerprint-specific architecture. The results on Shapes3D further demonstrate that this mechanism is also applicable beyond fingerprints.
We could not locate the bibliographic details for [1] and [2] in the review and would appreciate clarification to enable a precise comparison.
(2) Clarification of design for ridge structure preservation and ablation. We do not introduce a ridge-specific choice in our model. In the fingerprint setting, the content block is intended to capture identity-related ridge structure, while exchanging the material block is intended to modify material-related characteristics while retaining the source image’s identity-related structure. Accordingly, there is no ridge-specific component to isolate in a dedicated ablation. To assess preservation empirically, we have added a SIFT-based keypoint comparison protocol in the revised manuscript in Appendix A.6. These results provide complementary evidence of identity-related local structure preservation.
2. Clarification of identity-related structure preservation
Thank you for your valuable comment. Commonly used fingerprint identity preservation methods, such as NFIQ and minutiae detection in GenPrint, are typically evaluated on larger fingerprint images (e.g., 388 × 374, 296 × 560, or 300 × 300 pixels in FVC2002 database). In contrast, our dataset consists of narrow, 160 × 26 partial fingerprints. Directly applying existing recognition methods to these images yields poor recognition performance for all compared baselines.
We therefore applied a SIFT-based keypoint comparison protocol to assess the preservation of identity-related local structures after swapping. For material swaps, our model achieves the second-highest score (0.463) for material-swapped images and the highest score (0.559) for batch-swapped images . The detailed algorithm and results are updated in Tables 2 and A9, and Appendix A.6 in the revised version.
3. Clarification of downstream utility and generalization
Thank you for your constructive suggestion. We have added a downstream material classification experiment in Section 4.3 and Appendix A.7 in the revised version, using images generated through TRACE’s material swapping to augment the training set. The results show that standard data augmentation, including flipping, rotation, translation, brightness/contrast jitter, and random erasing, improves classification performance on held-out real fingerprint images, while TRACE-based augmentation yields greater improvements. Specifically, TRACE achieves 75.51% accuracy, 74.12% balanced accuracy, and 72.44% macro F1, exceeding standard augmentation by 2.23, 1.78, and 2.28 percentage points, respectively. These findings support the generalization ability of TRACE-generated data in this downstream task and suggest its potential to reduce the costs of sample fabrication, image collection, and dataset maintenance.