- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper attributes the poor cross-generator generalization of existing AIGI detectors to the entanglement of semantic content and forensic cues in deep representations, which causes detectors to overfit to semantic shortcuts. To address this issue, it proposes DeCue, which consists of two components: hard fake sample construction and feature decoupling pipeline. DeCue reports an average accuracy of 99.23% across eight benchmarks, including five academic benchmarks and three in-the-wild benchmarks, outperforming the SOTA baseline by 11.29 percentage points.
Critical strengths
1.The experiments are comprehensive. The paper evaluates the proposed method on eight benchmarks, compares it with 16 competing methods, and provides visualizations, ablation studies, and robustness evaluations.
2.The paper generates semantically aligned fake samples from real images, designs a decoupling module to separate forensic cues from semantic features, and trains the model using the fused representation. This is a meaningful direction with clear motivation.
3.The decoupling losses are reasonably designed, and the visualization results provide evidence of their effectiveness.
Critical weaknesses
1.The values in the “Mean” column of Table 1 do not appear to be arithmetic averages. The authors should verify whether these values were calculated correctly.
2.The full model achieves 98.20% on AIGI-Now in Table 2, whereas Table 1 reports 98.90%. Similarly, the full model achieves 94.10% on AIGIBench in Table 3, whereas Table 1 reports 94.80%.
3.Around line 222, “x = Exr” should be “z = Exr.” In addition, panels (d) and (e) are mislabeled in the caption of Figure 4.
4.The hard fake sample generation procedure largely follows DDA, while feature decoupling has already been extensively explored in both deepfake detection and AIGI detection. Therefore, the methodological novelty is limited.
5.The t-SNE and Grad-CAM visualizations provide only limited evidence for successful feature decoupling. The paper lacks quantitative evaluations or analytical tests to substantiate this claim.
Questions for authors
See my comments above.
Reviewer's responses to authors
Dear reviewers,
If not done already, could you please take a look and reply briefly to the "Official Comment(s) by Authors" / Rebuttals, possibly by an acknowledgement that you have seen it.
Feel free to respond in more detail, in particular, if you have further questions or opinions to the replies from the authors.
With best regards, an AC