- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates cross-domain radio frequency fingerprinting using only source-domain data, aiming to address the challenge where device hardware fingerprints are entangled with variations in the communication channel, receiver, and acquisition environment. To tackle this, the authors propose a two-stage representation learning framework called EquiRFF. In the first stage, the framework learns how structured physical transformations operate within the latent space, enforcing consistency between sequential and composite transformations. In the second stage, it extracts device-discriminative information—which remains stable across transformations—from the previously learned equivariant representations, while simultaneously preserving transformation-related information within the encoder. Experiments conducted on four public datasets—UAV, ManySig, ORACLE, and BLE31—demonstrate that this method outperforms existing baselines.
Critical strengths
This manuscript proposes incorporating a physics-guided equivariant world model into radio-frequency fingerprinting. By employing an equivariant encoder alongside invariant cross-attention query heads, the approach enables one-shot inference without the need for further adaptation. The research addresses a significant problem, and the experimental results are promising.
Critical weaknesses
(1) Although extensive comparisons were conducted across four public datasets, the depth of the experiments should be increased. This could include, for example, visual verification of equivariance/invariance in the latent space, comparisons of computational overhead, validation using multiple random seeds, and a control experiment involving supervised training solely during Stage II.
(2) Is there a logical issue in treating a device’s inherent hardware fingerprint as an environmental disturbance that needs to be removed?
Questions for authors
(1) The experimental evaluation requires strengthening—for instance, by including visual verification of equivariance/invariance in the latent space, comparisons of computational overhead, validation across multiple random seeds, and a control experiment involving only the Stage II supervised training.
(2) How does the equivariance of noise-free, static CPO/CFO/IQI facilitate model generalization to distance-induced shifts—such as those dominated by multipath fading and path loss (as seen in the UAV and BLE31 datasets)?
(3) The baselines included in the manuscript consist primarily of general self-supervised visual learning methods. Furthermore, the manuscript lacks a standard supervised learning baseline—which should employ the same 6-layer Transformer architecture—and fails to clarify whether these self-supervised baselines also utilized the Stage II supervised contrastive loss () and the same physical data augmentation views during training.
(4) In the experiments on the BLE31 dataset (Table 4), most methods exhibit lower training accuracy than validation accuracy—a pattern that is inconsistent with typical training and testing outcomes.
3 comments
4 Q3 — Supervised baseline and downstream supervision
The advantage does not come from the downstream recipe alone, and a supervised baseline on the same Transformer is now included. In the matched Stage-II control, Vanilla 1D-JEPA with its CE classifier gives 86.78 ± 0.07%; adding the full EquiRFF Stage-II procedure gives 87.07 ± 0.43%, a 0.29-point increase in the mean. With the same Stage-II physical views, Query readout, classification, SupCon, and relative-recovery objectives, EquiRFF reaches 95.51 ± 0.28%, a further 8.44 points. This comparison supports the contribution of physics-based Stage-I pretraining under matched downstream training. Stage II from scratch gives 79.26 ± 0.41%; same-Transformer Supervised ERM and ERM + matched-scale augmentation give 65.65 ± 0.05% and 69.31 ± 0.05%, respectively. These controls further examine supervised training and physical augmentation without the proposed pretraining.
The main SSL baselines use physical views during pretraining and CE for downstream classification; Appendix C.2 lists their readouts and budgets. The matched Vanilla JEPA → Stage II control additionally includes EquiRFF's multi-view supervised procedure, SupCon, and relative recovery. AS retains its supervised and augmentation-adversarial contrastive objectives, and Matched-capacity MLP controls readout parameter count.
Revision. Sections 4.1 and 4.3; Appendix A/C/D.
5 Q4 — BLE31 Train and Val
Most methods on BLE31 show the usual ordering: eight of ten have a higher three-run Train mean than Val mean. The two exceptions are EquiMod and EquiRFF, whose Val means are higher by 0.39 and 0.22 points. For EquiRFF, Train and Val are 98.17 ± 0.83% and 98.39 ± 1.44%, and the paired Val−Train differences for seeds 2025–2027 are +2.71, −0.47, and −1.57 points: validation exceeds training in only one of the three runs, so the ordering varies across runs rather than showing a consistent validation advantage. Train and Val measure performance on different finite subsets, whose sample composition and fitted predictions can yield either ordering. BLE31 contains 31 devices; the 1 m source split uses 160 training and 40 validation observations per device, totaling 4,960 Train and 1,240 Val observations. Both mean accuracies are approximately 98%, near the accuracy ceiling, and one additional validation error changes accuracy by about 0.081 percentage points. The small mean gap should be read alongside these sample sizes and the observed run-to-run variation. Each held-out target distance contains 6,200 observations. Accuracies at 1.5, 2, and 3 m are 98.93 ± 0.41%, 96.94 ± 0.50%, and 98.14 ± 0.30%, with a target mean of 98.00 ± 0.08%. These target results are close to the source means and support strong identification across the tested distances. Appendix A.2 reports the three-run Train, Val, and target accuracy statistics.
Revision. Section 4.1 and Appendix A.2, including the BLE31 classification statistics.
Thank you for the author's response. Based on the content of the response and the full manuscript, I will maintain my score.
Response to Reviewer 9R6t — Part 1/1
We thank the reviewer for the detailed feedback
1 W1 + Q1 — Experimental depth
The revision adds physical diagnostics, supervised and from-scratch controls, cost measurements, and repeated-run statistics. Appendix Figures S1–S2 visualize physical endpoint prediction, encoder sensitivity, composition-path distance, and Encoder–Query geometry. Table S3 includes Supervised ERM (65.65 ± 0.05%), ERM + matched-scale augmentation (69.31 ± 0.05%), and Stage II from scratch (79.26 ± 0.41%). Tables S6–S8 quantify deployment and training costs, including 5.484M deployment parameters, approximately 0.677 GFLOPs, and 2.991 ms single-observation latency. The classification tables now report mean ± sample SD for seeds 2025, 2026, and 2027 across all four datasets and the UAV ablations. Appendix A.1 defines the aggregation, and Table S9 lists the seed-specific target averages.
Revision. Sections 4.3–4.4; Appendix A/B/D.
2 W2 — Hardware fingerprint preservation
EquiRFF is designed to preserve hardware information: it learns the response to an applied transformation, with the measured observation as its starting point. Relative recovery supervises transformation information in the encoder; classification and SupCon supervise the Query readout. This assigns physical response and stable identity to complementary representation roles. In the diagnostic checkpoints, all three factors show action-dependent endpoint prediction, and Query drift relative to device separation is lower than encoder drift. The w/o recovery and Encoder SupCon controls additionally test recovery and the location of identity consistency, yielding 86.55 ± 0.30% and 86.22 ± 0.21% compared with the Full reference of 95.51 ± 0.28%.
Revision. Sections 3.3.2 and 4.3; Appendix A/B/E.
3 Q2 — Distance, multipath, and path loss
Distance shifts are evaluated on real recordings, and we added synthetic multipath and noise tests: accuracy changes little under mild perturbations, while at the strongest settings (echo-to-direct energy ratio 1; received-signal-to-added-noise ratio 0 dB) it is 85.02% and 83.49%, compared with the clean reference of 95.77%. Both exceed the highest baseline accuracies of 67.44% and 69.54%; seq-JEPA has smaller relative drops from its lower clean reference. The training views are generated from real recordings, preserving their initial channel and receiver effects. Known phase, frequency, and I/Q transformations supply controlled supervision for the encoder, while identity learning extracts a consistent device representation across views, and the distance benchmarks evaluate this representation under the combined acquisition shift. To evaluate propagation filtering separately, the synthetic tests apply random short FIR channels and Gaussian noise to UAV target observations with fixed model weights; they quantify sensitivity to the specified channels, complementing the recorded distance shifts. Appendix F.5 reports the tested channel and noise strengths, while Table S14 compares all methods under the strongest FIR and added-noise settings. Appendix E.4 discusses operator selection and channel modeling.
Revision. Appendix E.4/F.5–F.6.