- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes GLCR, a self-supervised framework for associating Wi-Fi probe requests under MAC address randomization. The method learns global and local representations from Information Elements (IEs) without using RSSI or timing information. The learned representations are combined and clustered using DBSCAN. The authors evaluate the method on three public datasets and a newly collected WiDAR dataset.
Critical strengths
- The paper proposes an approach to associating Wi-Fi probe requests without relying on RSSI or timing information. Learning representations from IE content and ordering is useful because wireless measurements can vary across environments. The self-supervised approach also avoids the need for device identity labels during training.
- The experimental results are promising. Table 2 shows that GLCR outperforms the evaluated baselines across all four datasets. Table 3 provides ablation studies for the proposed components. Figures 6 and 7 examine performance under different device operating modes and observation windows.
Critical weaknesses
- The MAC randomization behavior during data collection is not sufficiently described. Section 5.1 explains that WiDAR was collected using a passive Wi-Fi sniffer, but it is unclear whether the devices had previously connected to nearby Wi-Fi networks or were performing scans for unknown networks. This distinction matters because probe request behavior and MAC randomization can differ depending on the connection history and scanning conditions. Section 4.1 filters frames with locally administered MAC addresses, but this alone does not establish that the addresses changed during the experiment. The paper also does not clearly explain how ground-truth device identities were established for WiDAR. Since associating requests across randomized MAC addresses is the main objective, these details are important for evaluating the results.
- The paper does not provide a breakdown of performance across device types. Section 5.1 states that WiDAR contains 50 devices from eight vendors, including smartphones and personal computers. However, the authors do not report how many devices belong to each category, their operating system versions, or their Wi-Fi chipsets. Table 2 reports aggregate clustering accuracy, but it is unclear whether the method performs differently on iPhones, Android phones, and computers. In particular, devices with similar hardware and software configurations may generate similar IE patterns. It would be useful to understand which devices are more likely to be incorrectly associated and whether newer MAC randomization implementations affect the results.
Questions for authors
- Section 5.1 describes the WiDAR collection setup. Were the devices previously connected to nearby Wi-Fi networks, or were they scanning for unknown networks? Did the authors verify that each device generated multiple randomized MAC addresses? How were the ground-truth device identities established?
- Could the authors provide a breakdown of the WiDAR dataset by device type, model, operating system version, and Wi-Fi chipset? It would also be useful to report association performance separately for iPhones, Android phones, and computers, particularly for devices with similar hardware and software configurations.
- In Table 3, removing the local branch reduces ACC on WiDAR from 81.30% to 81.18%, while the decrease is much larger on WPR24 and NEST. Could the authors explain this difference? Also, could they report the computational cost of the individual components to better understand the tradeoff between model complexity and accuracy?
- The authors deliberately exclude RSSI and timing information to improve robustness across environments. However, these measurements could provide complementary information when multiple devices have similar IE patterns. Have the authors considered combining IE representations with RSSI or timing information? It would be useful to understand whether these additional measurements improve association accuracy, particularly for devices with similar hardware and software configurations.
4 comments
Response to Reviewer 53zf (Part 2/2)
5. Response to Q4: RSSI and Timing Information
Following your suggestion, we evaluated whether combining RSSI and timing improves the association accuracy. The results show that neither feature improved the association performance of GLCR in our experiments. On WiDAR, ACC decreased from 81.30% (IE-only GLCR) to 76.51% (+RSSI), 80.78% (+Time), and 78.59% (+RSSI+Time), with corresponding decreases in NMI and ARI (Appendix F, Table 11). Furthermore, we compared existing approaches that combined RSSI and timing in Table 2 of Section 5, such as Cappuccino, CrowdWatch, and TC-Hybrid. The results show that GLCR consistently outperforms these methods in ACC, NMI, and ARI across all four datasets, despite relying solely on IE content and structure.
These results are attributed to the instability of RSSI and timing under different device behaviors and measurement conditions. Our measurements showed that RSSI values for the same source MAC address fluctuate between −90 and −34 dBm, even at a fixed device-to-sniffer distance. Timing is likewise affected by scanning behavior, device state, missed frames, and irregular transmissions. Although more sophisticated fusion strategies may benefit devices with similar IE characteristics, the evaluated configurations did not improve overall association performance. We have clarified the motivation for IE-only association in the Introduction.
Table 11. Clustering results (%).
| Configuration | ACC ↑ | NMI ↑ | ARI ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|
| GLCR | 81.30 | 92.26 | 83.36 |
| GLCR + RSSI | 76.51 | 88.94 | 80.02 |
| GLCR + Time | 80.78 | 91.51 | 82.24 |
| GLCR + RSSI + Time | 78.59 | 88.46 | 80.20 |
Response to Authors and Final Assessment
Thank you for the detailed responses and additional experiments. The new gate ablation addresses my main concern, while the additional baseline comparisons and device-count results strengthen the paper.
I appreciate the revisions and will maintain my current rating.
Ethics and Privacy Concerns
We appreciate your valuable suggestions. In the future, we will continue to improve our work by taking your professional suggestions and questions into consideration.
On the other hand, we noticed that you marked the `Flag For Ethics Review’ and had some concerns about the potential use of the proposed technique GLCR for unauthorized WiFi device tracking. We would like to clarify that the technique only associates probe requests from the same Wi-Fi device when the device uses multiple randomized MAC addresses. Neither the device's factory-assigned MAC address nor the identity of its owner is recovered or identified. Therefore, there are no privacy problems at all for the proposed technique. In addition, existing studies, including Nozari et al. (2025b), Uras et al. (2020), Uras et al. (2022), Baccichet et al. (2024), Pintor and Atzori (2022a), and He et al. (2023), did not raise similar privacy concerns about reliable Wi-Fi device counting. Instead, they highlighted its applications, such as crowd monitoring and emergency response. Our WiDAR dataset was collected in a controlled environment with the informed consent of the device owners. The revised Ethical Statement describes the collection conditions, data minimization, limits on association scope, and controlled artifact release.
We hope our responses have adequately addressed your privacy concerns about the proposed technique. If so, we would sincerely appreciate it if you may remove the Flag For Ethics Review.
Please feel free to let us know if you have any further questions or concerns. Thank you again for your time and constructive feedback.
Response to Reviewer 53zf (Part 1/2)
Thank you for your constructive review and suggestions. In the following, we answer the questions from you one by one.
1. Response to Ethics and Privacy
We note your concerns about the potential use of GLCR for unauthorized device tracking and the need for an ethics review. We would like to clarify that GLCR only associates probe requests originating from the same Wi-Fi device when the device uses multiple randomized MAC addresses. Neither the device's factory-assigned MAC address nor the identity of its owner is recovered or identified. Therefore, there are no privacy problems at all for the proposed technique.
In addition, existing studies, including Nozari et al. (2025b), Uras et al. (2020), Uras et al. (2022), Baccichet et al. (2024), Pintor and Atzori (2022a), and He et al. (2023), did not raise similar privacy concerns about reliable Wi-Fi device counting. Instead, they highlighted its applications, such as crowd monitoring and emergency response.
We agree that any real-world deployment should undergo a separate ethics and privacy assessment covering the scope of association, the outputs made available, data access, and retention. Sections 4.1 and 5.1 describe the preprocessing and collection procedures, respectively, where our WiDAR dataset was collected in a controlled environment with the informed consent of the device owners. The Ethical Statement describes the scope of the evaluation.
2. Response to Weakness 1 and Q1: Collection Conditions and Ground Truth
During WiDAR collection, the devices were not previously connected to nearby Wi-Fi networks, and they were scanning for unknown networks. We verified that each device generated multiple randomized MAC addresses. For example, 21 of the 25 devices (84%) generated more than 10 distinct randomized MAC addresses in the WiDAR test set. Probe requests from each ground-truth device were captured separately in a shielded environment, and all captured frames were labeled with the corresponding device identity independently of their source MAC addresses. The recordings were subsequently combined. We have clarified these procedures and the source-MAC statistics in Section 5.1.
3. Response to Weakness 2 and Q2: Device Composition and Performance
Following your suggestion, we have provided a breakdown of the available device information for the WiDAR test set in Table 9 of Appendix F. We have also added Table 10 to report association performance separately for each device group. Among the phone groups, Android phones achieve the highest ACC (85.14%) and ARI (83.64%), while HarmonyOS phones achieve the highest NMI (92.56%). Overall, GLCR demonstrates effective association performance across diverse device groups, including groups containing devices with similar model and OS configurations.
Table 10. Association performance by device group on WiDAR.
4. Response to Q3: Local Branch Contribution and Computational Cost
The different ACC reductions across datasets are mainly attributed to variations in the discriminative information provided by the selected IE subsequences. The local branch encodes these subsequences to complement the complete IE-sequence representation learned by the global branch. On WiDAR, the selected IEs contain fewer device-discriminative cues, resulting in a smaller contribution from the local branch. In contrast, on WPR24 and NEST, the selected IEs provide more useful complementary information, leading to larger performance gains. We have clarified this dataset-dependent behavior in the Ablation Study.
We have added Table 7 in Appendix F to report the computational costs of GLCR and its component ablations, including parameter counts, FLOPs, and inference latency. The local Transformer and SFM comprise 6.71K parameters and require 0.65M FLOPs per frame. Removing the local branch and its associated CGR reduces inference latency from 1.93 to 1.22 ms per frame. Together with the dataset-specific accuracy gains in Table 3, these results quantify the tradeoff between association performance and computational cost.
Table 7. Network-level costs of GLCR-Base and its ablations.