- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper presents a framework for reconstructing 2D building-occupancy maps from wireless channel measurements by treating reconstruction as posterior inference. The framework comprises two key modules: a pretrained foundation model and a diffusion model. The foundation model maps each channel measurement and receiver position into a latent representation, while the diffusion model combines multiple representations to generate 2D occupancy samples, whose cellwise consensus produces the final reconstruction. The framework was evaluated on datasets generated from digital twins; it achieves a mean balanced accuracy of 0.758 and a mean IoU of 0.506.
Critical strengths
-
The posterior formulation is well motivated by the physical characteristics of radio propagation and its interactions with the environment. The distinction between propagation-relevant and propagation-irrelevant regions is interesting and well explained.
-
The hierarchical design is thoughtful. Propagation-aware masking, spatial-spectrum distillation, scene alignment, and consensus sampling are well connected to the underlying physical principles.
-
The foundation model is designed and pretrained using intense GPU resources. It provides a unified latent representation of the channel measurements and receiver positions, enabling the downstream diffusion model to combine information from multiple observations.
Critical weaknesses
-
My primary concern is the dataset. It is insufficient to evaluate the proposed framework and demonstrate its performance on simulated channel datasets generated by digital twin. There is no evidence that the performance from simulated dataset can be translated to the real channel measurements.
-
The methodological novelty of the individual learning components is limited. Majority of content in Section 3.2 might not be needed as it is the standard diffusion model.
-
The evaluation lacks baseline comparison, making it hard to understand how the proposed framework advances the state of the art.
Questions for authors
-
My primary concern is the dataset. The evaluation data are generated using Sionna RT, a ray-tracing radio-channel simulator operating on virtual environments. Although Sionna RT produces considerably higher-fidelity channel measurements than simplified statistical models such as Rayleigh fading, simulated channels are far from fully capturing real-world channel measurements. The paper provides no evidence that the performance gains observed on digital-twin-generated data will transfer to measured channels. I am highly skeptical about this transfer because prior work has demonstrated substantial gap between simulated and real wireless channels.
-
The methodological novelty of the individual learning components is limited. Both the transformer-based foundation model and the diffusion model build on established techniques. Although the paper makes a valuable effort to adapt and investigate these techniques for physics-guided radio-based reconstruction, their practical significance should be demonstrated using measured channels rather than only simulated data. We understand that acquiring and learning from representative real-world channel measurements is difficult, but addressing this challenge is essential to establishing the value of the proposed framework.
-
Several novelty claims appear overstated. For example, the paper states, “To our knowledge, this is the first demonstration that communication-infrastructure channel measurements can support reconstruction...” However, prior studies have investigated closely related problems using different formulations, including "Environment Reconstruction Based on Multi-User Selection and Multi-Modal Fusion in ISAC" and "Diffraction and Scattering Aware Radio Map and Environment Reconstruction". Although the paper includes internal baselines and ablations, it does not compare against representative methods from this prior literature (It's fine with different methodologies). Therefore, it is difficult to determine how much the proposed framework advances the state of the art.
-
Radio propagation interacts with the environment in three-dimensional space rather than on a two-dimensional plane. Building heights, trees, terrain, and other objects can fundamentally affect channel observations. Nevertheless, the framework reconstructs only a 2D occupancy map. Although the authors explain that their uniform linear array primarily resolves azimuth, the paper does not sufficiently establish when a 2D representation is physically adequate or how variations in object height affect reconstruction.
4 comments
Response to Reviewer jSma (2/2): Contribution, prior work, and building heights
Response to Reviewer jSma (2/2)
W2 / Q2 and W3 / Q3: methodological contribution and comparison with prior work
Our contribution lies in how we formulate and solve wireless scene reconstruction. We formulate it as posterior inference over occupancy and make this posterior tractable through a hierarchical design: a foundation model with physics-grounded representations maps each measurement to the scene structure that shaped it, a diffusion decoder jointly integrates these representations to model the posterior, and a consensus readout over posterior samples yields a per-cell Bayes-optimal reconstruction (Props. 3–4). We added controlled baselines showing that conventional techniques fail at each level of this hierarchy, with their results included in the table below:
- Physics-guided pretraining. The new baseline Diffusion + CLS (results in the table below) conditions an identical decoder on the [CLS] token of a foundation model with the same architecture, capacity, and data as ours, pretrained as a conventional masked autoencoder. Its performance stays near chance-level (0.537 balanced accuracy vs. 0.758 for ours), demonstrating the importance of our design in representation learning; Masked autoencoding retains what is needed to recover the channel, but nothing ties the representation to the scene structure that shaped the link, whereas [PHYSC] is anchored to the underlying physical properties and explicitly aligned with the propagation-relevant scene structure (Sec. 3.1).
- Hierarchical design. Conditioning the same diffusion decoder directly on raw channels (Diffusion + Raw Meas.) collapses to chance (0.505). This is a failure of learnability rather than information: the decoder must simultaneously discover the propagation-to-geometry mapping and perform posterior generation, the two burdens our hierarchy separates.
- Comparison with prior work. We thank the reviewer for pointing to these works. We added Geometry-Assisted DL + RSS (results in the table below), adapted from Chen & Chen (2024), which fits a virtual obstacle map to each link's received power; we use a strengthened variant whose propagation model is pretrained on our data. We demonstrate that such a simplified obstructed-vs.-free-space propagation model, like the generic embedding baseline, cannot expose the scene structure each link interacted with, and it severely underperforms our framework on all metrics.
| Model (mean over 671 test scenes) | Bal. Acc. | F1 | IoU |
|---|---|---|---|
| Geometry-Assisted DL + RSS | 0.534 | 0.449 | 0.293 |
| Diffusion + Raw Meas. | 0.505 | 0.054 | 0.030 |
| Marginal Prob. + Raw Meas. | 0.621 | 0.397 | 0.251 |
| Diffusion + CLS | 0.537 | 0.225 | 0.138 |
| Marginal Prob. + FM (ours) | 0.738 | 0.633 | 0.470 |
| Diffusion + FM (ours) | 0.758 | 0.663 | 0.506 |
The two cited works also operate under different requirements. Chen & Chen rely on hundreds of thousands of received-power measurements per area (about 600k) from aerial transmitters across many different viewpoint, and Lin et al. (2024) reconstruct sparse multipath point clouds that are fused with camera images at the users. To our knowledge, our framework is the first to provide meaningful reconstruction of arbitrary outdoor building layouts from the channels that conventional communication infrastructure already measures, without dense aerial links or additional sensors.
Q4: building heights and the 2D representation
The 2D occupancy grid in our framework is a choice of output, not an assumption about propagation. All channels in our digital-twin evaluation arise from full 3D scenes: buildings are extracted from OpenStreetMap with their individual heights, and ray tracing computes propagation in 3D between a base station at 15 m and users at 1.5 m (App. G). The reported results therefore already include the effect of varying building heights. For example, whether a building blocks a link depends on whether it is tall enough to intercept the ray, which our formulation treats as part of the residual ambiguity of the problem (App. B.3). The over-the-air experiments (Sec. 4.5) further confirm this in real environments, where every measured channel is shaped by the full 3D geometry of the site.
We reconstruct footprints rather than heights because, with a uniform linear array at the base station, the channel resolves paths only in azimuth, so building height is severely underspecified by the measurements. A 3D extension using a uniform rectangular array that resolves paths in elevation is a natural next step that we leave for future work (Sec. 4.1).
We hope these additions address the reviewer's concerns and would be glad to clarify further.
Experimental settings
Thank you for your response and adding results on the over-the-air experimental datasets. Could you please provide images to show your base station equipment and the tested sites, so that we have an idea about the system setup and environmental layout. Also, could you please confirm that the coverage of 32-antenna 5.8 GHz base station is only 40m x 40m?
We thank the reviewer for acknowledging the new experimental demonstration with over-the-air transmissions and for the opportunity to clarify the system setup and measurement environment.
Details and Images of the equipment and deployment sites. As the reviewer suggested, we have added Appendix N, which describes the measurement campaign in detail. Figure 9 shows the testbed: (a) the base station with its fully digital 32-element receive array and (b) the mobile transmitter with its 6-element array and RTK-GNSS receiver. Figure 10 shows the layouts of the five measurement sites, with the base-station location and the measured region at each site.
System setup summary.
- Base station: a 32-element uniform linear array of 4-patch subarrays. It is fully digital: each element has its own RF chain and ADC, and all 32 channels are digitized coherently and processed on a CASPER ROACH-2 FPGA platform, so the channel is captured at all elements simultaneously without analog beamforming.
- User: a 6-element uniform linear array driven by a Pi-Radio software-defined radio front end with a Xilinx ZCU111 RFSoC back end.
- Waveform and channel estimation: 128 subcarriers spanning 100 MHz around 5.8 GHz, matching the carrier, bandwidth, subcarrier count, and base-station array size of the digital-twin corpus. The six transmit antennas send Zadoff–Chu OFDM pilots in turn; after CFO correction and least-squares estimation, each measurement yields a 32 × 6 × 128 channel tensor. Per-chain hardware phase offsets are calibrated with a far-field horn antenna for accurate over-the-air channel estimation.
- Positioning: an RTK-GNSS receiver provides centimeter-level user positions.
- Sites: five outdoor sites in different parts of a campus, each with different buildings and materials, with 150–241 measurement points per site (about 1,000 in total) and occupied fractions from 16.0% to 47.5%.
Coverage. The extent of the measurement region is set by the transmit power of our testbed: to stay within the unlicensed 5.725–5.850 GHz band and the FCC limits, and to keep the amplifier stage below saturation, we transmit at relatively low radiated power, at which the user signal cannot be received reliably outside the dedicated measurement campaign area and at larger distances from the base station. We therefore confirm that 40 m × 40 m is the region measured and reconstructed in this campaign, but we emphasize that this is not a limitation of the method or of a 32-antenna base station. The street-level mounting of the base station (1.5 m) further restricts the coverage area. The region is thus limited by the testbed’s transmit power and mounting height rather than by the method. In the digital-twin evaluation, the same framework reconstructs 200 m × 200 m areas from a base station mounted at 15 m (Section 4, Appendix G), and a deployed base station with higher transmit power and elevated mounting would be expected to observe a correspondingly larger area.
We thank the reviewer again and hope this addresses the questions.
Response to Reviewer jSma (1/2): Summary and real-world evaluation
Response to Reviewer jSma (1/2)
We thank the reviewer for the thoughtful feedback and for recognizing the physical motivation of our posterior formulation, the distinction between propagation-relevant and -irrelevant regions, and the hierarchical design. We addressed every concern with new experiments and analyses.
Summary:
We have uploaded a revised PDF (changes in blue): over-the-air evaluation in Sec. 4.5 (p. 10, Table 3); new baselines in Sec. 4 (p. 7); Table 1 and Sec. 4.1 (p. 8); Table 2 (p. 9).
W1 / Q1: evaluation on measured channels
As the reviewer suggested, we evaluated our framework on real over-the-air measurements. Since no public dataset provides multi-antenna wideband channels together with accurate user positions and ground-truth building layouts in a configuration compatible with our setting, we collected them with a custom large-scale, fully digital MIMO testbed at 5.8 GHz with 100 MHz bandwidth (Sec. 4.5), matching the carrier, bandwidth, and base-station array size of our digital-twin corpus. A fixed base station with a fully digital 32-element array receives OFDM pilots from a mobile 6-element user array and estimates the channel on every subcarrier, while RTK-GNSS provides user positions. We measured five outdoor sites with distinct building layouts, with about 200 user locations each, covering a 40 m × 40 m area in front of the base station (a 20 × 20 grid at 2 m resolution). These measurements contain what the digital twin may abstract away, including real hardware nonidealities, antenna radiation pattern and coupling, and the true RF materials properties of each site.
Protocol. The pretrained foundation model is kept frozen and maps each measured channel and position to a [PHYSC] token, exactly as in the digital-twin evaluation. The diffusion decoder is retrained on the same simulated environments to match the output configuration. To bridge the simulation-to-reality gap, both encoder and decoder stay frozen and only the linear context adapter network through which [PHYSC] tokens enter the decoder is fine-tuned. We use a leave-one-site-out protocol: the adapter is trained on four sites and evaluated on the fifth, whose map is never used within adaptation, scene matching, or model selection, ensuring no leakage during evaluation.
Results (Table 3, each site held out):
On held-out sites, the framework recovers the main geometric structure of each scene, with results comparable to those on digital-twin data (Table 1) despite real hardware nonidealities. Additionally, since only the linear adapter is tuned during evaluation, this shows that the physics-grounded representations learned in simulation transfer well to real hardware and real propagation condition. It also directly addresses the reviewer's point in Q2 that practical significance should be demonstrated on measured channels. Extending the campaign to larger and more complex environments is left for future work.
Our response continues in Part 2/2.