- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents GaussTwin for jointly predicting wireless channel characteristics and recovering scene surfaces from channel measurements, without external geometry or geometric supervision. It represents the environment with oriented 2D Gaussian primitives and predicts power distributions using a physical model of direct propagation, reflection, scattering, and occlusion. The primitives are initialized by RF backprojection and refined through channel prediction losses, replacement, and splitting. Experiments evaluate channel prediction and surface recovery in six simulated environments. Two public measurement datasets are used to evaluate spatial spectrum and RSSI prediction.
Critical strengths
-
The same surface primitives support channel prediction and geometry recovery. They model reflection, scattering, and occlusion across multiple links, allowing different channel observations to constrain a shared scene representation. This provides an explicit connection between the learned geometry and the propagation model.
-
The initialization and structural refinement form a plausible solution to a difficult nonconvex problem. RF backprojection provides spatial support. Replacement guided by residuals and splitting based on visibility conflicts address limitations of local gradient updates.
-
The reported results provide useful evidence of feasibility in controlled environments. Table 1 shows substantial indoor channel prediction gains over the adapted baselines, and the appendix examines initialization, geometry learning, propagation mechanisms, primitive capacity, and measurement sparsity.
Critical weaknesses
-
Initialization in Appendices C.1 and C.6.1 requires complex channels and subcarrier frequencies, which are not provided by RFID spectrum images or BLE RSSI measurements. These inputs lack the required phase and wideband delay information, and the paper does not describe how initialization and surface refinement are adapted to them. For the RFID experiment, Equation 13 uses a complex response without explaining its relation to phase averaging and diffuse power in the main model.
-
In Section 4.1, existence probability and reflectance enter the reflection and scattering power factors through their product . For a primitive observed only through reflection or scattering, without independent attenuation constraints, different parameter pairs with the same product yield identical predictions when geometry and other parameters are fixed. These observations cannot uniquely determine both parameters.
-
Section 3 uses one channel realization per link to estimate mean power, but Equations 7 and 8 average over random phases. The power in a single realization can differ substantially from the predicted mean because of interference between paths. The experiments do not assess how this discrepancy affects prediction and geometry recovery.
Questions for authors
-
What measurements and procedures are used to initialize and refine the RFID and BLE models? How does the complex response in Equation 13 handle random phases and diffuse scattering?
-
How is the ambiguity between and handled without independent attenuation constraints? Can each parameter be validated against known values?
-
Why is power from one channel realization suitable for fitting the means in Equations 7 and 8? Can the authors quantify how path interference affects prediction and geometry recovery?
3 comments
Response to Weakness 1-2 & Question 1-2
Weakness 1 & Question 1. Appendices B.3, B.4 and C.6.1 now describe both adaptations. Initialization keeps the placement procedure of Appendix C.6.1, using only training observations with their Tx and Rx positions. RFID builds its support from spectrum residuals, BLE from excess received power, and each refines the surfaces through errors in its own observable. This keeps both models as close as possible to the main method.
For RFID, Equation 14 writes out the complex response of Equation 13. Its reflection phase is learned instead of drawn at random, and it omits the diffuse term. BLE keeps both the phase average and the diffuse term of Equations 7–8.
Weakness 2 & Question 2. Reflection and scattering constrain only the product , while blockage separates the two parameters through the transmittance , which involves without . Appendix C.2 now verifies this numerically. When varies with held fixed, predictions barely change for a primitive that blocks no direct path, but change substantially for one that does.
The learned reflectances on the known surfaces preserve the concrete–wood ordering of the simulated materials (Appendix C.2). The existence probability has no direct reference, and the reported surface metrics evaluate geometry independently of it.
Thank you for your response. I have no further questions. I think the topic of this paper is very interesting, and the overall quality is good. Since I am not very familiar with this topic, I will keep my rating at weak accept.
Response to Weakness 3 & Question 3
We thank Reviewer WC9E for the careful review and the positive assessment of our work.
Weakness 3 & Question 3. GaussTwin predicts only power and averages over the reflection phases in Equations 7–8. In the marginal spectra used for training, single-realization power stays close to this phase average, as quantified in General Response G1 and the new Appendix D.7.