- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes FresGRT, a radio digital twin that predicts signals at unseen frequency bands using measurements from a single band. It represents scene geometry with 3D Gaussians and learns material parameters used in a differentiable Fresnel-based ray tracer. A staged training procedure fits line-of-sight attenuation, adjusts geometry using frequency-selective fading, and then fine-tunes the materials. Experiments on three real sites and 24 ray-tracing datasets report lower cross-band received-power errors than existing RF rendering methods.
Critical strengths
-
The method learns material properties rather than a signal representation tied to one frequency. Combining these parameters with Fresnel equations and Gaussian ray tracing allows the model to predict received power at unseen bands without collecting new RF measurements.
-
The evaluation includes both real measurements and simulated environments. FresGRT reduces cross-band received-power error compared with existing RF rendering methods, and the ablation results show improvements from the geometry and material training stages.
Critical weaknesses
-
The baseline comparison does not fully isolate the benefit of the proposed learning method. Most compared RF representations are tied to their training frequency, so poor performance at unseen bands is expected. A conventional ray tracer with material parameters calibrated from the same single-band measurements and initial geometry is an important missing reference. Without it, the contribution of the Gaussian representation and staged training is difficult to separate from that of the frequency-dependent propagation equations.
-
The evaluation focuses on band-mean received-power error, although the renderer models frequency-dependent channel responses and the training method uses frequency-selective fading. The accuracy of per-subcarrier power and complex CSI at unseen bands is not evaluated. The reported results support received-power prediction, but do not establish whether the model is accurate enough for applications requiring detailed channel information.
Questions for authors
-
Is a comparison available with a conventional ray tracer whose material parameters are calibrated using the same single-band measurements and initial geometry? If not, how do the current comparisons separate the contribution of the proposed renderer and training procedure from the underlying propagation equations?
-
Are unseen-band results available for per-subcarrier power or complex CSI, rather than only band-mean received power? Which intended applications can be supported by the reported evaluation?
3 comments
I maintain my original score. The calibrated baseline and additional evaluations substantially address my concerns and support the reported cross-band gains. However, the Gaussian representation’s contribution remains difficult to isolate, and the shared simulation assumptions and limited real-world validation leave broader robustness uncertain.
Follow-up to Reviewer pURZ
We thank the reviewer for reading our response and for the positive assessment. We briefly clarify the remaining points.
Contribution of the Gaussian representation. With the initial geometry, as the reviewer asked, Sionna RT reaches a cross-band error of 11.3 dB on the real sites and 11.4 dB on the ray-tracing datasets, as reported in our first response. In the latest revision, we further give Sionna RT the faces of FresGRT after the LoS stage, i.e. with the spurious faces already pruned, with the same ITU material model and the same training links. Its cross-band error then becomes 7.8 dB and 7.9 dB, while FresGRT reaches 4.4 dB and 4.3 dB. The remaining difference is that Sionna RT traces fixed rectangular meshes, whereas FresGRT continues to adjust the position and the thickness of each face in its geometry stage.
Table 1: MAE of the band-mean power (dB) averaged on the real sites (revised). The initial-geometry row is from our first response. *In-band.
| Train → test (GHz) | 2.4 → 2.4* | 2.4 → 5 | 2.4 → 5.8 | 5 → 5* | 5 → 2.4 | 5 → 5.8 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sionna RT (initial geometry) | 7.67 | 13.93 | 11.73 | 6.72 | 9.66 | 10.01 |
| Sionna RT (pruned faces) | 5.94 | 7.34 | 8.09 | 5.12 | 7.08 | 8.50 |
| FresGRT | 3.60 | 4.31 | 4.96 | 3.76 | 3.92 | 4.32 |
Shared simulation assumptions. Although Sionna RT is the ray tracer that generated the datasets and shares every physical model with them, its cross-band error on these datasets is 7.9 dB, while FresGRT reaches 4.3 dB. We think that sharing the physics does not explain the better performance of FresGRT. More importantly, FresGRT outperforms the best baseline by 30% on the three real sites, which share no simulation assumption with FresGRT.
Response to Reviewer pURZ
(Q1, W1) Conventional ray tracer. We thank the reviewer for pointing out this missing reference. We now add Sionna RT, a conventional ray tracer whose ITU materials are calibrated with the same single-band links and the same initial geometry, to Tables 1, 2, 10, and 11 of the revision. Averaged over all cross-band testing, Sionna RT reaches 11.3 dB on the real sites and 11.4 dB on the ray-tracing datasets, while FresGRT reaches 4.4 dB and 4.3 dB. Since Sionna RT shares the frequency-dependent propagation equations with FresGRT, this gap comes from the Gaussian representation and the staged training, which correct the initial geometry with the RF measurements.
Table 1: MAE of the band-mean power (dB) averaged on the real sites (revised). *In-band.
(Q2, W2) Per-subcarrier power and complex CSI. We thank the reviewer for this suggestion. We now evaluate the per-subcarrier power of FresGRT, i.e. the error of the power of each subcarrier averaged over the subcarriers, in Table 13 of the revision. On the real sites, the per-subcarrier error is 5.2 dB in-band and 5.5 dB cross-band, only 1.3 dB and 1.2 dB above the band-mean error. On the ray-tracing datasets, the per-subcarrier error is 4.5 dB in-band and 5.1 dB cross-band, only 0.5 dB and 0.5 dB above the band-mean error. FresGRT therefore also predicts the power of each subcarrier at unseen bands.
Table 13: MAE (dB) of the band-mean power and of the per-subcarrier power of FresGRT on the real sites (revised). *In-band.
We use the per-subcarrier amplitude instead of the complex CSI as the target, since the measured phase of commodity Wi-Fi hardware is corrupted by carrier frequency offset (CFO), sampling frequency offset (SFO), and other phase offsets. The target of FresGRT is the signal strength prediction at any bands. In practical deployments, most network management decisions, such as access point placement, coverage planning, band steering, and roaming, rely on the band-mean power, i.e. the received signal strength indicator (RSSI), rather than on the power of individual subcarriers. The well-trained cross-band digital twin simulates in software the signal strength between any transmitter and receiver configurations (any positions, any bands). Network planners can therefore place the devices, e.g., multi-band access points, with the DT before deployment, without collecting measurements for each transmitter and receiver configuration, which can take several hours of measurements.