- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies rain-field reconstruction from commercial microwave links using discrete diffusion priors with an explicit dry class and quantized positive rain intensities. It compares in-filling and likelihood-guided methods, introduces D-MGPS, and evaluates reconstruction accuracy, wet/dry classification, runtime, and uncertainty quantification.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses a practically relevant inverse problem, and the explicit dry class is well motivated by the distribution of rainfall data.
In the reported experiments, masked in-filling achieves RMSE comparable to continuous diffusion baselines at substantially lower computational cost.
Reporting coverage over both all locations and wet locations exposes shortcomings obscured by aggregate metrics. The authors also transparently acknowledge the limitations of their proposed sampler.
Critical weaknesses
Lack of a unified framework overview. The encoding scheme, prior training, and conditional sampling procedures are scattered across the main text and appendices, making the overall pipeline and relationships between components difficult to follow.
Insufficiently established novelty. The method primarily combines and adapts existing techniques without clearly demonstrating that it addresses a substantive gap left unresolved by prior work. The newly proposed D-MGPS also fails to demonstrate a clear advantage in the reported experiments.
The manuscript reads more like an experimental report. Substantial space is devoted to listing methods, configurations, and results, with insufficient analysis of why the design works, what drives the performance differences, and what generalizable insights the experiments provide.
Questions for authors
Beyond combining an explicit dry class with existing discrete diffusion and conditional sampling methods, what is the substantive methodological novelty of this work?
Why does D-MGPS underperform simpler in-filling methods, and what value does the proposed D-MGPS contribute given these results?
Could the authors provide a unified framework diagram illustrating the overall pipeline?
We appreciate the reviewer's feedback, below we address their concerns.
Q1 and W2:
To our knowledge, this is the first study to formulate CML-based rain-field reconstruction using discrete diffusion priors. The framework separates zero rainfall from strictly positive intensities, quantizes the latter, and learns a prior over the resulting categorical fields. It then conditions this prior on CML-derived information for reconstruction. This formulation preserves an explicit dry state while learning spatial rainfall structure.
Quantization and discrete diffusion are established techniques. Our contribution is their formulation and evaluation for the CML-based rain-field reconstruction problem, together with the D-MGPS sampling construction revisited below in Q2. The reported performance of VRG masked in-filling supports the practical value of the framework: it achieves reconstruction accuracy comparable to continuous diffusion baselines at substantially lower inference cost in the evaluated setting.
In the revisited version, we will strengthen the scope and contribution of the paper.
Q2:
D-MGPS explores where likelihood information is introduced along the discrete diffusion sampling trajectory. For a reverse transition from t to t−1, G2D2 uses likelihood information at time zero, whereas GILC uses information at the current noisy state. D-MGPS instead introduces likelihood information at an intermediate time 0<u<t. Its contribution is the resulting sampling construction and derivation.
The reported experiments do not demonstrate an empirical advantage for D-MGPS. We acknowledge that we do not yet have a conclusive explanation for its weaker performance. We are investigating several hypotheses as part of ongoing work.
W1, W3, Q3:
We agree that a unified overview would make the relationships between the components clearer. We will add a diagram showing rainfall encoding, prior training, and CML-conditioned reconstruction, including the two priors, observation models, and conditioning approaches. We will also revise the discussion to distinguish the methodological contribution from the experimental findings and to explain the limitations of D-MGPS and the current evaluation.