- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes PACC that learn representation for encrypted network traffic. Each protocol layer in the networking stack is treated as a separate view. PACC explores the redundancy withing a layer and exploit consistency across layers. Four datasets are used to evaluate the performance and the application classification shows substantial enhancement while the other three tasks show minimum enhancement if any by considering statictial signifiance.
Critical strengths
The vision of removing redundancy and exploiting consistency within and among netowrking protocols at different layers is a great idea that has potential to bring great benefits.
The performance enhance on the applicaiton classification is substantial.
Critical weaknesses
This pape is motivated by protocol redundancy and cross-layer consistency, but never reutrns its findings back to networking knowledge.
Performance evaluaton in table 1 lacks standard deviation when the average is presented. Statistical significnance is not established, especially when comparng performance on tasks 2-4.
Investigate how much of the performace gain on task 1 comes from the exploititation of the proposed principle of removing redundance and exploiting consistency. The baselines' perforamnce is too bad to belive when compared with MLP. Make sure that the baseline is correctly and fairly configured.
Questions for authors
none