- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Pixel Echo, a fixed statistic that pools the luminance Laplacian response into a 16x16 phase grid and exactly splits it into four period increments (P2/P4/P8/P16). They show generated images and the same decoder's reconstructions share a strongly aligned fingerprint pattern (r ~ 0.996) but differ in amplitude, and the decoder's own structure only appears at periods up to its upsampling factor. On a self-built closed-set benchmark, a 340-d feature with frozen linear heads reaches 95.1%/90.9% source attribution for C2I/T2I, and 98.6%/94.9% when frequency features are added.
Critical strengths
1、The paper cleanly shows generated images carry the same fingerprint as their decoder's own reconstructions, and that this fingerprint only exists at periods up to the upsampling factor — which also explains why some sources are much harder to detect than others. 2、 The experiments are unusually careful and honest: the classifiers are frozen before testing, the statistics are properly corrected, and the authors also report results that are bad for them, like their method failing after one resize.
Critical weaknesses
1、The method is a hand-crafted statistic with no learned part, and it is close to earlier work on up-sampling artifacts. The key finding is only checked on about 8 decoders at 256x256 ImageNet, so we do not know if the period rule holds for other resolutions or longer downsampling chains. 2、The method breaks easily in real use. One ordinary resize drops attribution to chance, JPEG compression halves it, and almost all shared images online have passed such steps — so it mostly works only on original untouched exports. 3、Detection is weak on the hardest and most common sources: DiT is caught only 1.6% of the time, and same-decoder sources are barely above guessing. The best numbers actually come from adding the older frequency features, not from Pixel Echo itself.
Questions for authors
1、Beyond the 256x256 ImageNet, how much of the periodic rule is retained - do you think that for decoders running with other output sizes or multi-stage upsampling chains, the writing methods of P16 and P8 will change? 2、Does your real dataset guarantee that it has not undergone upsampling or re-encoding? A "real" dataset contaminated by the decoder would expand the shared P16 parameters in Section 4.3. 3、What is the joint full-head false positive rate in the real situation when all sources' heads are triggered simultaneously? Does this exceed the 0.8% to 1.4% per head that you reported? 4、Can you quantify that 98.6% of Max's attribution comes from only the additional frequency features, such as using only the frequency heads in the same test? 5、After bilinear resampling, is there a robustness (such as phase grid estimation) that can restore a higher probability attribution? Or is the grid requirement fundamental? 6、ORT is cited only as a 2026 GitHub repository. Can you confirm its checkpoint, prompts and export settings are frozen and verifiable, given the Test is a single pass?
4 comments
Response to Reviewer Yok7 (2/2): Q1–Q6
Q1 (other resolutions, longer chains). For ×8 decoders the rule holds from 256² to 1024², and the commercial services match its prediction. A ×8 system should carry no decoder-specific P16: Imagen 3, Nano Banana and Seedream 3 put ≤ 1 % of their energy there (Table 18). The ×16 decoders are ImageNet-256 models, so ×16 is measured at 256².
Q2 (is the Real data free of resampling?). Yes for the cohorts behind our claims — and we found and report exactly this contamination elsewhere. Benchmark ImageNet Real is cropped without resizing; the matched cohort's per-image bicubic crop shows no phase-locked P16 (split-half −0.13). COCO Real, resampled by 16/15, does (1.00) and is analysed in Appendix E.5.
Q3 (joint false-positive rate). 2.6 % for Pixel Echo, 3.6 % for Max with all four heads together (Table 35) — above the per-head rates, as a union must be.
Q4 (Max without Pixel Echo). On the same held-out test, Frequency-64D alone gives 95.3 % (C2I) and 83.1 % (T2I) against 98.6 % and 94.9 % for Max: Pixel Echo adds 3.3 and 11.8 pp (Tables 4–5).
Q5 (phase-grid estimation after resampling). It restores translation, not resampling. A 256-offset search recovers a crop-shift (90.6 %), but after bicubic rescaling every variant is at chance (Table 38): the period-16 lattice no longer exists.
Q6 (is ORT frozen and verifiable?). Yes. Public weights (https://huggingface.co/donglixu/ORT) and paper (https://openreview.net/forum?id=s8kdXG7Zu4); chosen as the strongest published latent autoregressive generator on a conventional tokenizer we could find. Checkpoint, conditions, seeds and export settings were fixed before the test (Appendix H.1).
Thank the authors for the rebuttal and accept the corrections on decoder scale, JPEG and the T2I ablation. However, my concerns about practical scope, generality and novelty remain, so I keep my rating.
The accepted corrections were the basis of the remaining concerns
Thank you for the reply. We note that the three corrections you accept are the evidence the review gave for these concerns:
- Generality rested on "about 8 decoders at 256x256". It is twelve decoders, 256² to 1024².
- Practical scope rested on JPEG halving C2I attribution. It does not: 81.5 % at q90.
- Detection rested on frequency features carrying the best numbers. Combining the two adds 3.3 points on C2I and 11.8 on T2I over frequency features alone (98.6 and 94.9), so they carry different information. K5hR (S3): "phase-aligned structure carries information that spectral magnitude features alone do not"; vb5L: the improvement from combining them "demonstrates the value of the proposed representation". On T2I the best numbers come from Pixel Echo (90.9 vs 83.1).
Novelty. Our finding is new: a decoder leaves its own pattern only at periods up to its upsampling factor. Our analysis is new: we tested this with hypotheses fixed before seeing the data. Our application is new: using this pattern, Pixel Echo gives the best T2I attribution of all methods we compare (90.9 %), on the newest commercial services at their native high resolution. Our benchmark is new: class-to-image and text-to-image sets built from the latest open models and commercial services, with manifests released with the code. If earlier work already shows any of this, please name it and we will compare.
If a further reason stands behind any of the three concerns, please let us know which one. The same holds for the other reviews: if you see a point our replies there leave open, tell us. We stand by those answers, and we can run any analysis today and post it before the discussion closes.
Response to Reviewer Yok7 (1/2): W1, W2, W3
We thank the reviewer for the careful reading and for recognising the frozen-before-test protocol and the reporting of unfavourable results. Two statements in the review are factually incorrect (W1 on scale, W3 on the frequency features); we correct them first, with the evidence.
W1 (hand-crafted; ~8 decoders at 256²). Correction: the period rule is tested on twelve decoders from 256² to 1024², not on ~8 decoders at 256² only. The operator audit (Table 20) covers seven ×8 decoders (four kl-f8 weight sets, the SDXL VAE, TAESD, the consistency decoder), three ×16 (AliTok, RAE, VAR) and two pixel-space heads (JiT, PixelDiT). Beyond 256²: six ×8 decoders at 512² (Table 17), seven disjoint 7,000-image cohorts at 512² (Table 21), a 384² latent crop (P16 r = 0.93 to its 512² decode) and SDXL at 1024² (Table 18). The T2I benchmark adds the strongest commercial services available before submission (GPT Image 1/2, Imagen 3, Nano Banana, Seedream 3) at their native resolution. Only the ×16 evidence is at 256². The statistic is hand-crafted by design, so that each period can be read separately; §3.2 now states its DFT equivalence and §2 adds AEROBLADE and Sundara Rajan et al. (2025).
W2 (breaks under ordinary processing). The paper states this scope up front — abstract, §1, §5.3 and the first item of Appendix I with Table 37 — and the revision now removes its translation part. The folded-map DFT magnitude keeps 95.0 % C2I attribution under a random crop-shift, where the published feature gives 49.6 % (Table 38); resampling destroys the structure itself (Q5). One correction: JPEG q90 does not halve C2I attribution (81.5 %); it does on T2I (40.4 %), and at q75 C2I keeps 57 %. The method targets raster-preserving media such as native service exports, where held-out T2I attribution is 90.9 % across seven services.
W3 (weak detection; best numbers from frequency features). Correction: on T2I the best numbers come from Pixel Echo, not from the frequency features. On the held-out T2I test Pixel Echo alone reaches 90.9 % against 83.1 % for Frequency-64D, and inside Max the Pixel Echo block carries 9.5 pp against 3.8 for the frequency block (Table 31); on C2I the frequency features are indeed strong (95.3 vs 95.1). Low DiT detection at 1 % FPR is what the period rule predicts for a ×8 decoder, yet attribution recognises DiT at ≥ 91.2 % recall (Table 4). That sources sharing one decoder are hard to separate is the finding that the signal identifies the decoder (Table 32), not a failure of attribution.