- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a method for AI-generated image detection based on the quaternion Fourier phase and learns phase-related representations through masked quaternion modeling. The paper also attempts to address the compression and resolution shortcuts in GenImage, which is a relevant issue. However, the core motivation, problem setting, and main technical narrative of this paper overlap substantially with recent work. The paper does not demonstrate enough independent novelty. In addition, the experiments only compare against methods published in 2025 or earlier, which is not sufficient to support the paper’s conclusions.
Critical strengths
1.The paper attempts to address the compression and resolution shortcuts in GenImage, an issue that has often been overlooked in previous work.
2.The idea of using the quaternion Fourier transform (QFT) to capture properties of the physical imaging process is interesting and potentially useful.
Critical weaknesses
- Although the paper cites related works, it does not provide a direct experimental comparison or clearly explain the fundamental differences between these methods, such as Any resolution AI-generated image detection by spectral learning, CPTFormer.
2The experiments do not sufficiently compare against the latest relevant methods. Most of the baselines are from 2023–2025. This is not sufficient for an ICLR 2027 submission and makes it difficult to assess the actual state-of-the-art performance of the proposed method.
3.The experimental results suggest that the main performance gain comes largely from the input preprocessing rather than from the quaternion phase itself.
4.The diversity of the generators used for evaluation is insufficient to support broad generalization claims. The current set of generators is relatively limited, and it does not adequately cover newer generation models or substantially different generation mechanisms.
5.The method relies on many manually designed and data-dependent choices, and its generalization requires further validation. Authors should provide more extensive sensitivity analyses and evaluate whether the method remains effective under different datasets, real-image domains, and preprocessing settings.
Questions for authors
1.Why does the paper not compare against methods published after 2025? Since this is an ICLR 2027 submission, please clarify whether the authors evaluated the latest relevant methods, especially those published in 2026.
2.The authors have only provided empirical validation for the core hypothesis. Could you provide a more in-depth mechanistic analysis?
2 comments
- The authors only promise comparisons with methods published in 2026, without providing results. Despite having sufficient time during the rebuttal period, they have not provided additional experimental evidence sufficient to establish superiority over existing methods.
- The authors still do not adequately explain the substantive differences between their method and closely related work. This distinction is essential for assessing the paper’s independent novelty.
Overall, I maintain my original rating.
We thank the reviewer for the constructive and detailed comments.
W2 / Q1 — Baselines from 2026
Most baselines are indeed from 2023–2025. Methods from 2025 are included (SPAI, AIDE, LOTA, and C2P-CLIP retrained under the same protocol in Table 1; Effort and AlignedForensics as literature values in Tables 1 and 2), but none from 2026. We will evaluate the 2026 methods with public implementations and GenImage-SD1.4 weights (OmniAID [ICML 2026], IAPL [CVPR 2026]) under the same protocol on GenImage, Synthbuster, and Chameleon, and add them to Tables 1 and 2 in the revision.
W3 — Preprocessing or quaternion phase?
The point is partly correct numerically, so we separate the contributions (GenImage average, %):
The imaging channel is the largest contribution and part of the method; it adds 13.4 points to QPP while working against the baselines, so most of the 14.9-point gap comes from this asymmetry. With the preprocessing fixed, the pretraining objective accounts for 4.9–6.0 points, and without the channel QPP still leads the best baseline by 2.6 points. The revision will stop presenting the 14.9 points as a representational gain and report Table 1 with and without the channel.
The preprocessing does not create the sensitivity. The channel is applied identically to every baseline, and QPP leads without it (Table D.10). Keeping the preprocessing, readout, and mixture model fixed and swapping only the backbone for a public model lowers the deviation AUROC and removes the response to phase perturbations of real photographs:
The sensitivity to phase regularity therefore comes from pretraining that masks the spectrum and restores real images. (MAE and MFM use a decoder fitted post hoc, so the match is not perfect.)
W4 — Diversity of generators
Agreed. The evaluated generators are the eight of GenImage and the nine of Synthbuster, without latest-generation models. We will drop “broad generalization” and state the evaluated range as a limitation in Section 7.
W5 — Sensitivity analysis
Threshold sensitivity is in Table 4 and Tables D.7–D.9. Sensitivity to the number of clusters, the channel settings (JPEG quality, downscaling ratio), and the real-image reference set (ImageNet / COCO / RAISE) will be added to the appendix.
Q2 — Mechanistic analysis
We examined what the detector reads from both sides. On real photographs, the score ignores white balance, chrominance gain, and uniform rotation of the relative phase (FPR changes by at most 4.7 points) but rises monotonically from 11.7% to 97.4% under per-bin phase noise (response to Reviewer rFw5, W2). On generated images, matching the amount of high-frequency detail changes the AUROC only from 0.848 to 0.820 (response to rFw5, W1), the relative-phase measures alone carry most of the discrimination (0.842; response to Reviewer 3ML5, W1), and the public MAE and MFM backbones show no phase sensitivity (table above). Accordingly, we restrict the central hypothesis to measuring the deviation from the statistical regularity of the chrominance phase structure of imaged photographs, and reposition the illuminant-cast derivation (Appendix D.1.4) as a property of the representation.